apple

A class action lawsuit alleging that Apple has an App Store monopoly has been rejected by a federal court judge, in a 34-page ruling.

Part of the ruling essentially said that the plaintiffs did a poor job in stating their case, but another element potentially puts Apple in a strong position when it comes to defending other antitrust cases against the App Store …

The lawsuit was led by the developers of Coronavirus Reporter, whose app was banned by Apple under rules, which only allow COVID-19-related apps from official governmental health bodies.

Courthouse News reports that the developer initially wanted a preliminary injunction prior to a full hearing, but the judge rejected the claim in its entirety.

The developers claimed Apple used its monopoly power to exclude Coronavirus Reporter from the App Store to benefit its own “institutional partners.” Apple rejected the software under a policy that bans Covid-related apps unless they are submitted by a recognized health entity such as a government agency or medical institution. The developers said Apple used similar policies to exclude or suppress the rankings of other apps for anticompetitive reasons.

Coronavirus Reporter and its co-plaintiffs sought a preliminary injunction that would temporarily block Apple from keeping certain apps out of its App Store and charging developers a $99 yearly App Store submission fee.

In a 34-page ruling issued Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Edward Chen denied the motion for an injunction as moot after dismissing the lawsuit.

A significant part of the ruling was that the lawsuit failed to properly define the market in which it claimed Apple held a monopoly.

The developers described multiple markets in their complaint, including the “smartphone market,” “iOS institutional app market,” and the “national smartphone app distribution market.”

In subsequent briefs, the developers sought to clarify that Apple dominates two primary markets, defined as the “U.S. smartphone market” and “U.S. iOS smartphone market.” They also identified five downstream markets, including markets for wholesale app competition, iPhone apps, permission tokens to launch iOS apps, onboarding software and access to iOS users.

Chen concluded those market definitions were unclear and “failed to pass muster.”

As our antitrust guide explains, the entire debate centers on the definition of the word “market.”

Apple argues that it does not have a dominant position in this market, as it considers the relevant market to be either “smartphones” or “apps.” Since the company holds a minority share of the smartphone market in most of the countries in which it operates, it believes it cannot be considered to have a dominant position.

Competition regulators tend to take the view that the relevant market is “iOS apps,” and here Apple has a 100% monopoly on their sale and distribution. Edge cases aside, there is no way for a developer to bring an iOS app to market without selling it through the App Store.

But the judge went further, ruling that even where Apple does undeniably hold a monopolistic position, that isn’t necessarily an antitrust violation.

Most of the markets identified are “single-brand markets” in which Apple is “inherently and necessarily” the only participant, Chen wrote. The judge said the developers offered no facts that would justify an “extremely rare” finding that a single-brand market gives rise to an antitrust claim […]

Chen compared the App Store to a newspaper that publishes advertisements. If a newspaper accepts some ads and refuses to print others, the rejected advertiser has not suffered an antitrust injury, the judge wrote. A true antitrust injury would look more like a newspaper barring advertisers to stop them from promoting a competing news service, he explained.

This is now an argument that can be used by Apple, with the authority of a federal court ruling behind it. However, the plaintiffs plan to appeal, and the antitrust claims continue across multiple countries.

Via Patently Apple. Photo: Pxhere.


TECH NEWS RELATED

Roblox Islands Pineapple Update Patch Notes

We've got all of the details that have been released on the new Roblox Islands Pineapple update!

View more: Roblox Islands Pineapple Update Patch Notes

Amazon Great Republic Day Sale 2022: Best offers on smartphones including iPhone 12 and Samsung Galaxy S20 FE 5G

Amazon Great Republic Day Sale 2022 offers are live in India. The e-commerce platform is offering several deals and discounts on smartphones across all ranges. In addition to the best Amazon Great Republic Day sale offers, customers with an SBI credit card can avail 10 percent discount. iPhone 12 ...

View more: Amazon Great Republic Day Sale 2022: Best offers on smartphones including iPhone 12 and Samsung Galaxy S20 FE 5G

Apple AR/VR Headset's Potential Name

What could be the name for the upcoming Apple goggles? Some actually say it could be called “Apple Vision.” Apple Rumored to Create Its Virtual Headset with AR Capabilities As of press time, Apple is strongly rumored to be creating its own virtual reality (VR) headset with AR capabilities. ...

View more: Apple AR/VR Headset's Potential Name

When will DogLife be available on iOS/Apple devices?

We'll take a look at when you can expect the release of DogLife on Apple devices!

View more: When will DogLife be available on iOS/Apple devices?

Get the COVID-19 booster shot, Apple reportedly tells staff

Apple has reportedly told its store and corporate employees to get the COVID-19 booster shot or face frequent tests for the virus. “Due to waning efficacy of the primary series of COVID-19 vaccines and the emergence of highly transmissible variants such as Omicron, a booster shot is now part ...

View more: Get the COVID-19 booster shot, Apple reportedly tells staff

Apple iPad Air 5 Rumored to Launch in Early 2022

The Apple iPad Air 5 is rumored to launch some time early this year and some of its most notable features are the use of the A15 chip and 5G. Specifically, rumors are saying that it can launch along with Apple’s 3rd gen iPhone SE in March or April. ...

View more: Apple iPad Air 5 Rumored to Launch in Early 2022

iPhone Safari Bug Can Leak Your Google Account Info, Let Hackers Spy on Your Browsing History: Is There a Fix?

Unfortunately, Apple has yet to address this severe iPhone Safari bug that reveals an Apple user’s browser history and even leaks login information on Google accounts. Photo : LOIC VENANCE/AFP via Getty Images A flaw discovered in iPhones and iPads can leak user data from third-party browsers. It reveals ...

View more: iPhone Safari Bug Can Leak Your Google Account Info, Let Hackers Spy on Your Browsing History: Is There a Fix?

How to pre-register for My Hero Ultra Impact (Android or iPhone)

We'll walk you through the process of pre-registering for the global release of My Hero Ultra Impact!

View more: How to pre-register for My Hero Ultra Impact (Android or iPhone)

Genesis to add Apple CarKey unlocking and engine start tech: report

How to spoiler an image on Discord Mobile (iPhone, iOS, Android)

How to change Nickname on Discord Mobile (iPhone, iOS, Android)

Motorola’s ‘Frontier’ Project is a Flagship Smartphone Says Leaks, to Rival Samsung, Apple, and MORE; Specs?

ProMotion 120Hz could stick to iPhone 14 Pro models after all

iPhone 14 non-Pro models might not get ProMotion displays after all

iPad Air 5 with ultra-wide cam might beautify video calls

New leak suggests Apple’s VR headset could cost as much as a MacBook Pro

Apple’s AR/VR headset could be priced above $2,000, feature M1 Pro-like performance

What Can We Expect From The New iPhone? Everything, Apparently

Major Apple Safari privacy bug means any websites can access your Google ID, other private data

Apple Requiring Employees to Submit Proof of COVID-19 Booster Shot or Face Frequent Testing

OTHER TECH NEWS

;