appeals court rejects $310 million iphone battery throttling settlement

AppleInsider is supported by its audience and may earn commission as an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner on qualifying purchases. These affiliate partnerships do not influence our editorial content.

A federal appeals court has ruled that Apple’s settlement offer of $310 million to users over iPhone “batterygate” has to be rejected and reconsidered because of a legal mistake in the lower courts.

In 2020, US District Court Judge Edward J. Davila approved Apple’s offer to settle a class action suit regarding its controversial battery slowdown. Users in 2017 had discovered that the then-new iOS 10 intentionally reduced, or throttled, the speed of iPhones including the iPhone 6, iPhone 6 Plus, iPhone 6s, iPhone 6s Plus, iPhone 7, iPhone 7 Plus and original iPhone SE.

Apple refuted an allegation that it was slowing down older phones in order to get people to upgrade. The company said that slowing these phones down extended their useful life.

However, Apple had not explained this before issuing the throttling. It later apologized for this, and cut out-of-warranty battery replacement $79 to $29, for a limited period.

The subsequent court cases covered the issues of how many people were affected and to what degree, but ultimately Apple offered a settlement that court then approved. However, the that ruling was appealed by 144 members of the suit.

They objected to how the court approved $80.6 million to cover both attorney fees, and to pay “service awards to the named plaintiffs.”

Now according to Bloomberg Law, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit have vacated the lower court’s approval. It rejected the settlement offer, however, not on any issues over its appropriate nature.

Instead it was vacated solely and specifically because the lower court used the wrong legal standard in its ruling.

“The district court properly resolved most of the objections at issue on appeal,” wrote Judge Jacqueline H. Nguyen in her filing. “However, in finding the settlement fair, reasonable, and adequate, the district court committed legal error.”

“While we commend the district court’s thoughtful and thorough analysis, which suggests that the court took great care in considering the terms of the settlement,” she continued, “its written order explicitly states that the court applied a presumption that the settlement was fair and reasonable.”

“Because the district court applied the wrong legal standard when reviewing the settlement’s fairness,” concluded Judge Nguyen, “we vacate the orders granting final settlement approval and awarding fees, expenses, and incentive awards, and we remand for application of the correct standard.”

The district court will now presumably proceed to reissuing its approval, citing the correct legal standards. However, no further details or dates have been issued.

Separately, Apple was correct in what it claimed about how slowing down the iPhone helped with preserving the overall life of a battery. For a primer on how battery technology works, see AppleInsider’s in-depth look at the science of batteries.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Best iPhone gadgets for people who love to cook

Smart kitchen appliances make cooking much easier AppleInsider may earn an affiliate commission on purchases made through links on our site. Cooking has never been easier. There are now an incredible amount of accessories that will connect to an iPhone to help out people who love to cook — and ...

View more: Best iPhone gadgets for people who love to cook

The 5 worst iPhones of all time

Apple debuted the original iPhone in 2007, and we’ve come a long way, as demonstrated by 2022’s iPhone 14 lineup. There are 38 total iPhones that have come out in 15 years, and more coming with each year that passes. Contents iPhone 4 iPhone 5c iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 ...

View more: The 5 worst iPhones of all time

Samsung Galaxy S23 just tipped to pull further ahead of iPhone 14 Pro with video upgrade

Samsung Galaxy S23 could be the 8K video king of 2023

View more: Samsung Galaxy S23 just tipped to pull further ahead of iPhone 14 Pro with video upgrade

7 Best Ways to Fix Notification Badges Not Showing on iPhone

You can customize notifications on your iPhone, whether it’s a sound, banner, or pop-up. Besides that, you can use the numbered notification badges on the app icons to know if there are any notifications. That’s helpful if you have a Focus mode on. Notification badges can be great if you ...

View more: 7 Best Ways to Fix Notification Badges Not Showing on iPhone

Almost 100 days after launch, iOS 16 is installed in 7 of every 10 iPhone models

Since its launch, iOS 16 has comparatively achieved a higher user base than iOS 15. Almost 100 days after its release on September 12, the latest operating system is in 68,91% of all iPhone models. The information comes from the third-party analytics website Mixpanel. Comparatively, nearly 100 days after its ...

View more: Almost 100 days after launch, iOS 16 is installed in 7 of every 10 iPhone models

The iPhone just got an official deadline to ditch Lightning for USB-C

EU says December 28th, 2024 is when all phones must offer USB-C charging

View more: The iPhone just got an official deadline to ditch Lightning for USB-C

6 Best Fixes for Dolby Atmos Not Working in Apple Music on iPhone

Dolby Atmos is available to enjoy in Apple Music for iPhone users. And with iOS 16, you can use the Personalized Spatial Audio feature for a three-dimensional surround sound experience. But only some users can enjoy the benefits of Dolby Atmos on their iPhone. Some users complain of being unable ...

View more: 6 Best Fixes for Dolby Atmos Not Working in Apple Music on iPhone

iOS 16 Installed on Almost 70% of iPhones Nearly 100 Days After Launch

iOS 16 is installed on almost 70% of compatible devices as the update’s 100-day launch anniversary approaches, according to third-party analytics website Mixpanel. ‌iOS 16‌ was released to the public on September 12, 2022, and was initially doing better than last year’s iOS 15 update regarding how quickly users were ...

View more: iOS 16 Installed on Almost 70% of iPhones Nearly 100 Days After Launch

The iPhone 15 Ultra could be every bit as expensive as we feared

iPhone 15 Ultra: what we know so far

iPhone 15 Ultra price might go up to $1,299, leaker claims

Apple's Largest iPhone Supplier Investing $500 Million in India as Supply Chain Diversification Continues

Foxconn ends 'closed loop' at iPhone megafactory in China

Apple Music Sing Karaoke Mode SKIPS These iPhone, iPad Models

Folding MacBook with OLED display reported alongside folding iPhone update

Apple iOS Blocks 16.1, 16.1.1 Downgrades for iPhone Users

After Heated Battle, Genshin Impact Wins Player's Voice at The 2022 Game Awards

Apple Music Sing will only work on selected iPhone and iPad models, even if they have iOS 16.2

How to Disable Cellular Data for Specific Apps on iPhone

Vampire Survivors Announced for iOS and Android

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News