apple ordered to comply with court’s decision in epic games case over in-app payments

A federal judge has ruled that Apple can’t push back the deadline to update App Store policies, as previously ordered in the court’s decision on California’s Epic Games v. Apple lawsuit. Though Apple largely won that lawsuit when the judge declared that Apple was not acting as a monopolist as Epic Games had alleged, the court sided with the Fortnite maker on the matter of Apple’s anti-steering policies regarding restrictions on in-app purchases. The court’s original ruling stated that Apple would no longer be allowed to prohibit developers from pointing to other means of payment besides Apple’s own payment systems, but Apple wanted that decision put on hold until its appeals case was decided — a delay that would have effectively pushed back the App Store changes by a matter of years.

Specifically, the September 10, 2021 ruling issued by U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on the Epic Games antitrust case had ordered Apple to no longer stop developers from:

“…including in their apps and their metadata buttons, external links, or other calls to action that direct customers to purchasing mechanisms, in addition to In-App Purchasing.”

The court also said Apple couldn’t prevent developers from communicating with customers through points of contact obtained voluntarily from customers through their account registration within the app.

Apple in October officially updated its App Store rules to address developers’ ability to communicate with their users, as that change was also a part of its settlement with a group of U.S. developers in a class-action lawsuit over the same matter. However, upon its appeal of the Epic Games lawsuit, Apple asked for a stay on the injunction Judge Gonzalez Rogers had put into place which would open up the App Store to non-Apple payment systems.

Per the ruling, the required App Store policy changes had an early December deadline, as the judge ordered the injunction to be implemented within 90 days of the September 10 ruling. That meant, if Apple wasn’t granted this stay on the injunction, it would have to permit developers to point to alternative means of payment inside their iOS apps.

During a November 9 hearing to hear arguments both for and against the stay, Apple’s legal counsel argued that the changes Apple was being forced to implement would “upset the platform.”

“They will harm consumers. They will harm developers. That is the fact. It is going to happen,” said Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher partner Mark Perry, a lead lawyer for Apple on the Epic Games case. He reiterated Apple’s position that allowing links inside apps could introduce security and privacy risks into the iOS ecosystem.

Epic Games’ counsel, Gary Bornstein, pointed out that Apple said during the trial that its first-party payments platform competed with web payments. It can’t turn around and now say that raising consumer awareness about this competitive alternative would now cause “irreparable harm.” He added, too, that Apple shouldn’t be left to sort out the changes on its own as, so far, many of the steps Apple has taken to open up the App Store were in response to either class action lawsuits or legislative and regulatory developments. Apple disagreed, pointing to other pro-consumer changes it has made, like the App Store privacy labels.

Ultimately, the judge ruled today that Apple failed to successfully argue its case for a stay and denied the motion.

“In short, Apple’s motion is based on a selective reading of this Court’s findings and ignores all of the findings which supported the injunction, namely incipient antitrust conduct including supercompetitive commission rates resulting in extraordinarily high operating margins and which have not been correlated to the value of its intellectual property,” wrote Judge Gonzalez Rogers. “This incipient antitrust conduct is the result, in part, of the anti-steering policies which Apple has enforced to harm competition.”

Reached for comment, Apple said it intends to try again.

“Apple believes no additional business changes should be required to take effect until all appeals in this case are resolved. We intend to ask the Ninth Circuit for a stay based on these circumstances,” an Apple spokesperson said.

Epic Games didn’t have any immediate comment.

The court’s decision, if upheld, could have a significant impact on the App Store’s business model, as developers looking to skirt Apple’s commissions would be able to point their users to other payment methods when the policy is updated. The fallout from the decision could cost the company billions, depending on how many developers take up the opportunity and how many consumers decide to pay outside the App Store.

Already, some in the market were moving forward to capitalize on that potential change before the policy had been officially revised.

For example, Paddle, a solutions provider for subscription businesses, announced rather prematurely it would introduce a new in-app purchasing system aimed at iOS developers that would allow a drop-in replacement to Apple’s own payments system as soon as the injunction went into effect. Facebook, meanwhile, just rolled out a system for direct creator payments bypassing the App Store. This system was technically permitted because Facebook isn’t taking a cut of creator revenues for the time being. But with a decision that permits other payment mechanisms, that system could change in the future opening up a new revenue stream for the social network.

It’s unclear how exactly Apple will rewrite its rules to comply with the court’s decision if it’s not able to convince the court to grant its motion. When South Korea issued a new law also requiring app stores to allow for other payment mechanisms, Google complied but Apple said its current policies were in compliance due to how the law was written.

The court reminded Apple it had 90 days to comply with the injunction per the original ruling and still has approximately 30 days before it goes into effect.

gov.uscourts.cand.364265.830.0_8 by TechCrunch on Scribd

TECH NEWS RELATED

How to reset and restore your iPhone's settings, network, location, and more

Source: Luke Filipowicz / iMore Al technology can sometimes act a little weird or glitchy, and your best iPhone is no different. If you’re having issues with your networks not working correctly or your keyboard keeps suggesting odd words, you can reset many settings in just a few simple steps. ...

View more: How to reset and restore your iPhone's settings, network, location, and more

Apple's MagSafe Charger is just $29.99 — a pre-Christmas bargain!

If you’re struggling to find a relatively inexpensive Christmas gift for the iPhone lover in your life, look no further. If they carry an iPhone 12 or iPhone 13, this bargain Apple MagSafe Charger is just the ticket. Priced at just $29.99, you’ll save almost a full quarter off the ...

View more: Apple's MagSafe Charger is just $29.99 — a pre-Christmas bargain!

2022 INFINITI QX50 impresses with standard ProPILOT Assist, wireless Apple CarPlay, added convenience features

Curated materials, remarkable craftsmanship, and now connectivity with the capability to further support drivers, the 2022 INFINITI QX50 with Apple CarPlay compatibility and ProPILOT Assist

View more: 2022 INFINITI QX50 impresses with standard ProPILOT Assist, wireless Apple CarPlay, added convenience features

Report: Snap and Facebook use App Tracking Transparency loophole to continue sharing ‘aggregated’ user data

With the launch of iOS 14.5 earlier this year, Apple rolled out its new App Tracking Transparency capability. This privacy feature is designed to give users the ability to opt out of being tracked across other apps and services, but a new report from the Financial Times today details ...

View more: Report: Snap and Facebook use App Tracking Transparency loophole to continue sharing ‘aggregated’ user data

Next-gen AirPods Pro could bring new design, better chip in late 2022

They could look a little like this. Concept: Killian Bell/Cult of Mac We could be waiting close to a year for Apple’s much-anticipated AirPods Pro upgrade, but according to one analyst, it will be well worth the wait. The next-generation buds are expected to deliver a brand-new design and ...

View more: Next-gen AirPods Pro could bring new design, better chip in late 2022

Best thin cases for iPhone 13 Pro 2021

Best thin cases for iPhone 13 Pro iMore 2021 You’ve got a gorgeous iPhone 13 Pro, and you want to keep it looking that way. You know you need one of the best iPhone 13 Pro cases, but you don’t want to bulk up your iPhone or obscure its sleek ...

View more: Best thin cases for iPhone 13 Pro 2021

Best deals Dec. 8: $299 iPad Pro Magic Keyboard in white, $999 M1 MacBook Pro, more!

AppleInsider is supported by its audience and may earn commission as an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner on qualifying purchases. These affiliate partnerships do not influence our editorial content. Wednesday’s best deals include big Netgear router discounts, 35% off a Samsung 4K monitor, $140 off a Sabrent 2TB M.2 ...

View more: Best deals Dec. 8: $299 iPad Pro Magic Keyboard in white, $999 M1 MacBook Pro, more!

The best notes apps for iPhone and iPad

AppleInsider is supported by its audience and may earn commission as an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner on qualifying purchases. These affiliate partnerships do not influence our editorial content. Whether you need to jot down a phone number, figure out your shopping list, or capture crucial meeting details, a ...

View more: The best notes apps for iPhone and iPad

Apple reportedly allowing 'looser' adherence to ad privacy rules & requirements

Apple iPhone 13 Pro Max Price in Malaysia & Specs

Apple iPhone 13 Pro Price in Malaysia & Specs

Satechi launches new Thunderbolt 4 dock, two USB-C hubs

Satechi launches Thunderbolt 4 Dock for the new MacBook Pro alongside two USB-C hubs

How to free up iPhone storage without deleting your apps or photographs

How to recover deleted files on Mac with 4DDiG Mac Data Recovery Software

Razer just revealed an RGB cooling fan accessory for both iPhone and Android devices

Apple Self Service Repair preps underway with iPhone service history in iOS 15.2

Apple planning upcoming release for macOS Monterey 12.1, fixes YouTube HDR crashing issue and more

This unlocked iPhone 12 Pro deal is better than its Black Friday price

iPhone 13 Pro review - Is this flagship worth upgrading?

OTHER TECH NEWS

;