Exclusive: James Cameron was fooled by his own VFX

entertainment

(Image credit: © 2022 20th Century Studios. All Rights Reserved.)

Much of Avatar: The Way of Water’s rub-your-eyes-in-disbelief magic stems from its ability to convincingly blur the practical and the digital – and the animators at Wētā FX did such a good job in that department that director James Cameron was often duped into approving entirely computer-generated shots. 

In an exclusive interview with TechRadar, Daniel Barrett, Senior Animation Supervisor at the New Zealand-based visual effects company, revealed that he and his team were sometimes forced to side-step Cameron’s desire to keep things as practical as possible in order to maintain the realism of certain shots. 

“There’s a lot of interaction between [Na’vi] characters and Spider [played by Jack Champion] in The Way of Water,” Barrett explains, “and getting the kind of contact accuracy that you need in a stereoscopic film can be a real challenge. The planning on set was done to such a high level that many of those shots worked. But there were also times [when they didn’t]. 

“If you think of those shots where Quaritch is carrying Spider to the drop zone – that was all shot practically, but we realized pretty quickly that there were elements of Jack’s body that we needed to replace with a digital one to make sure we could get all of that contact done. Our digital doubles got to a really high level. We had plenty of situations on the film where we tricked Jim [Cameron] – where he thought we were practical, and we were in fact digital.

entertainment

Jack Champion’s Spider interacts with Na’vi characters in Avatar: The Way of Water (Image credit: © 2021 20th Century Studios. All Rights Reserved.)

“We would make the decision: which is the path of least resistance to give Jim back his plate exactly as he shot it? And sometimes the savings were too great not to go digital […] But obviously there was still a lot of work to be done there. For the camera team to create matchmoves that are accurate enough to hold up in 3D movies, there’s a real challenge in that. And they did amazing work on this film to reconcile some of those situations for us.” 

Animation 101 with Wētā FX 

As someone whose team was “largely responsible for everything that moves” in The Way of Water, Barrett is among the few people who can give an informed answer to the question: how the heck did Cameron pull this off? 

If you’ve seen any of the film’s behind-the-scenes featurettes, you’ll know that the processes involved in bringing the entirely fictional world of Pandora to life on screen must have been mind-bogglingly complex. So, naturally, we asked Barrett to explain – in layman’s terms – how Wētā turned the likes of Sam Worthington and Zoe Saldaña into 10-foot Na’vi.

entertainment

Kate Winslet, Cliff Curtis, Zoe Saldaña and Sam Worthington on the set of Avatar: The Way of Water (Image credit: 20th Century Fox/Disney)

“The way we broke it up,” he begins, “there were certain teams for certain sequences, but we also have specialist artists. So, for instance, we have a facial team, who did the lion’s share of the facial work, and they sit as a separate department. We have a motion edit team whose starting point is the performance capture data – obviously, they did a huge amount of work on this film. Then we have the animation team, who do a little bit of everything – they’re responsible for all the creatures, vehicles and things like that. And we also have a crowds team, who deal with the bigger crowd [animations], whether it’s fish or birds or Metkayina at a village. So all of those groups of people, in those departments from what we call the motion realm, totalled about 150 at our peak.

Your facial animation will fall over if you don’t have a very accurate version of the performance.

Daniel Barrett, Wētā FX

“So the motion capture is captured – the bulk of that was done at Lightstorm [studios] – and [the footage] is then selected by Jim, whatever he likes,” Barrett continues. “Then it’ll be turned over to Wētā, where it comes through the motion capture team. The data tracking is done at Lightstorm, but we like to re-track it to make sure we maintain all the fidelity and detail of the performances. That will then go through to the motion edit team, who begin work on the bodies – and there’s sometimes a bit of cleanup involved in that [stage]. The motion edit team – also sometimes the animation team – will deal with the bits and pieces that you don’t get to capture,” Barrett explains, giving Na’vi fingers and tails as examples.

Image 1 of 2

Ronal and Tonowari in Avatar: The Way of Water (Image credit: © 2022 20th Century Studios. All Rights Reserved.)

Initial Metkayina concept art for Avatar: The Way of Water (Image credit: © 2021 20th Century Studios. All Rights Reserved.)

“We like the bodies to be pretty much done before we move to facials – and on that note, there’s a huge amount of attention paid to what the head is doing, because your facial animation will fall over if you don’t have a very accurate version of the performance. Once that’s done, we move to facial [animations] – although sometimes, if we realize we’ve missed something with the head, we have to push it back one step. And that’s pretty much the process for performance capture, [with regards] to the motion team.

“Obviously, beyond us,” Barrett adds, “there’s an awful lot of work done prior in terms of the models, the rigging of the characters, the shading and the textures. But once the motion is there, the footage goes through the creatures team, who simulate cloth, costume and hair. And then of course we’ve got a very clever lighting team who work their magic, which is always such a wonderful thing. To see these characters finally rendered… oh, it’s just such a thrill. To have been working on something that looks a little cartoony and then see something that looks like the real thing. It’s such a pleasure, such a gift.”

Judging by The Way of Water’s near-$2 billion global box office receipts, audiences are enjoying the pleasure, too. 

Avatar: The Way of Water is now playing in theaters worldwide. 

TechRadar Newsletter

Sign up to get breaking news, reviews, opinion, analysis and more, plus the hottest tech deals!

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions (opens in new tab) and Privacy Policy (opens in new tab) and are aged 16 or over.

Axel Metz

Staff Writer

Axel is a London-based staff writer at TechRadar, reporting on everything from the newest movies to latest Apple developments as part of the site’s daily news output. Having previously written for publications including Esquire and FourFourTwo, Axel is well-versed in the applications of technology beyond the desktop, and his coverage extends from general reporting and analysis to in-depth interviews and opinion. 

Axel studied for a degree in English Literature at the University of Warwick before joining TechRadar in 2020, where he then earned a gold standard NCTJ qualification as part of the company’s inaugural digital training scheme. 

TECH NEWS RELATED

How to Disable Screenshot Thumbnail Previews on Mac

Modern versions of macOS feature a floating thumbnail preview for screenshots that allows users to quickly apply edits to their screenshots before they save them. If you find this interface too obtrusive, or simply prefer to edit your screenshots later using the Preview app, Here is how you can ...

View more: How to Disable Screenshot Thumbnail Previews on Mac

LG’s smart projector is the square cousin of Samsung’s cool The Freestyle

This Tiny MSI PC is Packed With Power

MSI Following the example set by the Mac Mini, many Windows-powered compact PCs have popped up recently with solid hardware. If none have quite caught your eye, though, maybe this PC by MSI will. MSI has just released a new tiny PC called the Cubi 5 12M, and it’s ...

View more: This Tiny MSI PC is Packed With Power

Logitech’s New Colorful Keyboards and Mice Look Great

Logitech Logitech makes some of the best keyboards and best mice around, and you might be familiar with the company’s RGB-packed gaming products. These new peripherals are really packed with color, but we’re not really talking about lights. Logitech has announced a range of new colors for a bunch ...

View more: Logitech’s New Colorful Keyboards and Mice Look Great

“Part of the Journey Is the End;” Marvel’s Avengers Seems to be Shutting Down

Whether it be purely the lackluster quality of the game or the general distaste for live service games, Marvel’s Avengers never truly found its footing in the two years since it was released. Despite the fact that both the Marvel and Avengers labels should guarantee a happy, comic-lover audience, ...

View more: “Part of the Journey Is the End;” Marvel’s Avengers Seems to be Shutting Down

Satechi Thunderbolt 4 Slim Hub review: A sleek and portable laptop hub

Thunderbolt 4 docks are now much more widely available, meaning that it’s much easier to get a high speed dock that works with your laptop. But unfortunately, while they’re relatively widely available now, they’re still quite expensive. Thankfully, however, that price seems to now be coming down a little through ...

View more: Satechi Thunderbolt 4 Slim Hub review: A sleek and portable laptop hub

Wi-Fi routers are being hit by a dangerous new Android malware with extra DNS hacks

With the DNS changed, users are redirected to malicious pages

View more: Wi-Fi routers are being hit by a dangerous new Android malware with extra DNS hacks

Netflix renews Cobra Kai for sixth and final season

In a sea of cancellations, we actually have some good news for fans of one of Netflix’s longest-running original series for once. On Friday, Cobra Kai co-creators Jon Hurwitz, Josh Heald, and Hayden Schlossberg shared a lengthy statement on Twitter announcing their Karate Kid sequel series would return for ...

View more: Netflix renews Cobra Kai for sixth and final season

Servant unleashes a bed bug blitz [Apple TV+ recap]

Hostinger quietly shutters Zyro to focus on Hostinger Website Builder service

Redmi Note 12 Turbo Tipped to get Snapdragon 7-series SoC

Super Bowl 2023 live stream: how to watch the game, commercials and halftime show from anywhere

The Minecraft Community Answers the Age-old Question: “Can it Run Doom?”

Mark Hamill Hints That His Time as the Joker Is Over

Deadpool joins Marvel's Midnight Suns next week, adding new story missions

Chic-Fil-A’s Training Program Apparently Features a Familiar Fallout Face

6 other zombie shows and movies to watch if you’re loving The Last of Us

Nintendo is reportedly increasing Switch production ahead of Breath of the Wild 2

Ex-Halo dev believes those who pushed for a better game ‘got laid off for it’

There are two clear winners in the PSVR 2 launch lineup

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News