books, culture, film & tv, history, sociology

The last 12 months has witnessed a bit of a frenzy surrounding kids’ entertainment, from bisexual Superman to the first gay dads in Sesame Street to a brief kiss from a lesbian couple in Pixar’s new animated feature Lightyear. In response, reactionaries are rehashing moral panics from previous decades, based around the idea that homosexuality is the result of nurture rather than nature, a “corruption” brought about by a gay “ideology” pushed by the left.

While this might feel like moralistic madness unique to a social media-fueled culture war, it really isn’t. The last 100 years are littered with similar spasms of reactionary panic directed at adolescent entertainment, usually with an emphasis on sexuality.

The culture war

The late 1990s and early 2000s saw its own culture war battle over kids’ entertainment. Teletubbies — specifically, Tinky Winky, who was male but liked to wear dresses and carried a handbag — drew the ire of preacher Jerry Falwell. His war on this supposed agent of the gay agenda led to headlines and news reports across the country.

books, culture, film & tv, history, sociology

In an article by Fallwell titled “Parents Alert: Tinky Winky Comes Out Of The Closet,” he cited damning evidence: “He is purple — the gay-pride color — and his antenna is shaped like a triangle — the gay-pride symbol.”

Bert and Ernie of Sesame Street were accused of being a gay couple around the same time, as well as SpongeBob of SpongeBob SquarePants, which first aired in 1999. In more recent years, the creator of Sesame Street has admitted that Bert and Ernie were in fact modeled on his same-sex relationship, and Nickelodeon implied SpongeBob was part of the LGBTQ community.

books, culture, film & tv, history, sociology

Harry Potter and the Order of Satan Worshipers

While Pokémon, another popular franchise at the time, was not accused of being part of the “gay agenda,” it was accused of being demonic and satanic by preacher Phil Arms in a sermon that would go viral more than once online. His book, released around the same time, Pokemon & Harry Potter: A Fatal Attraction, also accused Harry Potter of promoting satanism.

Preacher sounds warning about Pokemon “Pokemon world is the world of the demonic” https://t.co/JxlkzcPv8Z pic.twitter.com/lAFO7eKP34

— Pessimists Archive (@PessimistsArc) July 12, 2016

Eventually, however, both franchises would be accused of promoting homosexuality. In 2007, J.K. Rowling announced Dumbledore was gay — riling some existing critics of the series — and in 2015, Pokémon was blamed by another preacher for a rise in homosexuality among Millennials.

Subscribe for counterintuitive, surprising, and impactful stories delivered to your inbox every Thursday

Where DC Comics today features a bisexual Superman, as recently as 1989, the company specifically prohibited any reference to homosexuality. Why? Because it broke the rules of the “Comics Code Authority” by which it agreed to adhere in the 1950s. The guidelines were created in the aftermath of the infamous comic book moral panic, which mirrors what we see today. This episode was triggered and led by Fredric Wertham, a psychologist, after he published his book Seduction of the Innocent.

books, culture, film & tv, history, sociology

The book would lead to Senate hearings, where Wertham would make an appearance and comic book industry executives would be grilled. One of his arguments contained within: Batman and Robin were clearly a gay couple, and Catwoman a lesbian with a penchant for S&M.

books, culture, film & tv, history, sociology

The book claimed:

“One young homosexual during psychotherapy brought us a copy of Detective Comics, with a Batman story. He pointed out a picture of “The Home of Bruce and Dick” a house beautifully landscaped, warmly lighted and showing the devoted pair side by side, looking out a picture window.”

This had apparently infected the boy with a serious case of gayness.

Before cartoons, it was teddy bears

Going back even further, to the first decade of the 1900s, it was teddy bears that were supposedly warping the sexuality of future adults. It was posited, by Reverend F.G. Esper, that replacing baby dolls with bears would mean young girls growing up without any maternal desire. (This topic was explored in more depth here for Big Think.)

books, culture, film & tv, history, sociology

While these concerns were not homophobic in nature, they managed to be explicitly sexist (by treating young girls as having a single purpose) and racist (by positing that suppressing maternal instincts would accelerate “race suicide,” what today is referred to as “The Great Replacement” theory).

Manipulating parental anxiety

Treating kids’ entertainment as a Trojan horse is an old trope that manipulates parental anxiety and maternal instincts. Often, the arguments are so silly that socially liberal media amplifies it, accidentally giving it legitimacy and reach. Like a needy child, whining and crying for attention, the best thing to do is ignore it.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Scientist admits 'space telescope' photo is actually chorizo in tasty Twitter prank

No, it was not a James Webb Space Telescope photo of Proxima Centari, the scientist confesses.

View more: Scientist admits 'space telescope' photo is actually chorizo in tasty Twitter prank

Sturgeon Supermoon: August's Sturgeon Full Moon will be the last of 4 in a row

The Sturgeon supermoon won't be welcomed by all this year.

View more: Sturgeon Supermoon: August's Sturgeon Full Moon will be the last of 4 in a row

The unexpected evolutionary benefits of celibacy

Evolution is often perceive as an individual affair: Traits that are helpful to the individual get passed on and eventually spread throughout a population, while those that are unhelpful eventually die off along with those who have them. While this simple model is useful, there are many things that ...

View more: The unexpected evolutionary benefits of celibacy

How To Follow the Next Steps of NASA’s Webb Space Telescope

The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is the next of NASA’s Great Observatories; following in the line of the Hubble Space Telescope, the Compton Gamma-ray Observatory, the Chandra X-ray Observatory, and the Spitzer Space Telescope. JWST combines qualities of two of its predecessors, observing in infrared light, like Spitzer, ...

View more: How To Follow the Next Steps of NASA’s Webb Space Telescope

Rare jellyfish with pulsing body captured on video for the first time in history

The Chirodectes maculatus jellyfish is elusive. So far, there have only been two documented sightings of this particular jellyfish. Now, a group of divers from Scuba Kavieng have managed to capture this rare jellyfish on video. Many believe this video could be the first documented video recording of the ...

View more: Rare jellyfish with pulsing body captured on video for the first time in history

Explore a mysterious exoplanet in new video game 'Earth's Shadow'

Descend into an atmospheric alien landscape in search of priceless cosmic relics.

View more: Explore a mysterious exoplanet in new video game 'Earth's Shadow'

NASA, private companies count on market demand for future space stations after ISS

The International Space Station will be replaced by a range of private outposts.

View more: NASA, private companies count on market demand for future space stations after ISS

Buzz Lightyear blasts from 'Infinity to Forever' with these cool new U.S. Postal Service stamps

The beloved Space Ranger scores a commemorative stamp edition emblazoned with his charismatic likeness

View more: Buzz Lightyear blasts from 'Infinity to Forever' with these cool new U.S. Postal Service stamps

No Reason for Panic: Why Declaring Monkeypox a Global Health Emergency Is a Preventative Step

Cancer Breakthrough: Unexpected Link Discovered Between Most Common Cancer Drivers

Identity theft rises as fraudsters find new ways to deceive clients

China mulls using lunar satellites to probe the cosmic dark ages

NASA’s Curiosity Mars Rover Still Going 10 Years After Landing – What It’s Learned

Austrian scientists race to reveal melting glaciers' secrets

New Pompeii finds highlight middle-class life in doomed city

Receding floodwater lets police evacuate people trapped in US Death Valley

France to give vitamins to beluga stranded in the Seine

Vietnamese open to learning digital skills: survey

Don’t Use Booze To Help You Snooze: Why Alcohol Isn’t a Good Choice for Insomnia, Sleep Problems

Viettel Telecom introduces tracking device vTag

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News