group buying, Chinese Communist Party, bike-sharing, Nice Tuan, e-commerce, Alibaba Group Holding, has ceased operations in multiple cities, it filed for bankruptcy, Meituan, Pinduoduo, Didi Chuxing, Tencent Holdings, warn them about certain practices, for price dumping and fraud

China’s state media has denounced the group buying industry’s cash burn strategy as a number of start-ups have either filed for bankruptcy or reduced operations amid the financial hardship caused by their “subsidy wars” to seize market share.

“Burning cash has not only failed to create a prosperous market, but has resulted in a series of chaos,” said a commentary published on Wednesday by the Economic Daily, a newspaper directly under the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party.

The commentary blamed some community group buying operators for abusing their platforms’ power to disrupt the market, including dumping low-priced goods, as well as illegally collecting and using consumers’ personal information.

It also indicated that group buying operators’ subsidy wars only provided a sense of “false prosperity”, a lesson that should have been learned from what has happened before in the country’s bike-sharing and ride-hailing industries.

group buying, Chinese Communist Party, bike-sharing, Nice Tuan, e-commerce, Alibaba Group Holding, has ceased operations in multiple cities, it filed for bankruptcy, Meituan, Pinduoduo, Didi Chuxing, Tencent Holdings, warn them about certain practices, for price dumping and fraud

Community group buying platform Nice Tuan, which is backed by Alibaba Group Holding, has ceased operations in multiple cities across mainland China and laid off employees. Photo: Handout

The Economic Daily’s commentary followed news that community group buying provider Nice Tuan, which is backed by e-commerce giant Alibaba Group Holding, has ceased operations in multiple cities in August. Alibaba owns the South China Morning Post.

“This field, which should have entered a stage of benign development, is now in an unhealthy state because of the subsidy wars,” said Chen Ying, founder of Nice Tuan, in an internal letter on Saturday.

In July, once-rising community group buying start-up Tongcheng Life became the sector’s first big casualty when it filed for bankruptcy because of “poor management and a tough business environment”.

Those setbacks signal that the Chinese internet industry’s once-foolproof formula – achieve explosive growth on the back of subsidies and later raise prices to generate profit, while collecting massive amounts of user data – is no longer viable.

“No one can make a profit in the short term,” said Zhuang Shuai, founder of Bailian Consulting. “Service and innovation have stagnated, which has resulted in serious internal discord in the entire industry.”

Many of China’s technology giants have squeezed into the group buying market since the coronavirus pandemic started, acquiring new users with the lure of low-priced goods and providing community leaders with high commission fees, according to Zhuang. Group buying provided a way to cut out the middleman by connecting food suppliers directly with end customers.

This market is forecast to be worth about 104 billion yuan (US$16 billion) this year, up 38 per cent from 2020, according to consultancy China E-commerce Research Centre. Big Tech companies like Meituan, Pinduoduo and Didi Chuxing have doubled down on this sector, competing against start-ups like Nice Tuan.

That situation has made community group buying a target for Beijing, which has increased regulatory scrutiny of Big Tech firms. Community group buying, according to some state media reports, put local food merchants and traditional wet markets at a disadvantage against Big Tech companies with their economies of scale.

In December, China’s State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR) and the Ministry of Commerce summoned Alibaba, Tencent Holdings, JD.com, Meituan, Pinduoduo and Didi to warn them about certain practices. “It is strictly prohibited to sell products below cost with the purpose of squeezing out competitors or seeking monopoly positions,” SAMR said in a statement at the time.

In March, SAMR fined the group buying platforms of Didi, Meituan, and Pinduoduo as well as Alibaba-backed Nice Tuan, for price dumping and fraud.

“Burning cash for community group buying operators is not a long-term thing,” said He Yixuan, an analyst at research firm Analysys. “Operators need to invest a lot in obtaining new users and improving their supply chain.”

“For the tech giants, their money doesn’t grow on trees,” He said. “If there is no good profit in the short term, they also face financial pressure.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network


LATEST NEWS

NEWS RELATED

Singapore narrows gap with Hong Kong in terms of prime office rents and prices, as Chinese tech giants expand in Lion City

Singapore’s office property market is gradually catching up with that of Hong Kong, the Lion City’s rival business hub, in terms of rents and prices, with Chinese technology giants such as Alibaba Group Holding, Tencent Holdings and ByteDance expanding in the city state. The gap peaked in 2017, when Hong…

Read more: Singapore narrows gap with Hong Kong in terms of prime office rents and prices, as Chinese tech giants expand in Lion City

Alibaba-backed community group buying start-up Nice Tuan ceases operations in some cities, lays off workers

Community group buying platform Nice Tuan, backed by Alibaba Group Holding, has ceased operations in multiple cities and laid off staff, becoming the latest firm to face setbacks in the highly competitive industry once considered the future of retailing in China. The 3-year-old company, once a rising star in the…

Read more: Alibaba-backed community group buying start-up Nice Tuan ceases operations in some cities, lays off workers

Alibaba Cloud data leak ‘violated Cybersecurity Law’ in 2019 and must rectify, local Chinese telecoms regulator says

The telecoms authority of China’s eastern Zhejiang province has told the cloud computing unit of Alibaba Group Holding that it violated the country’s Cybersecurity Law and should make rectifications following a complaint about a 2019 information leak. In a letter dated July 5, the Zhejiang Communications Administration (ZCA) said it…

Read more: Alibaba Cloud data leak ‘violated Cybersecurity Law’ in 2019 and must rectify, local Chinese telecoms regulator says

E-commerce firm JD.com beats second-quarter revenue estimates on boost from partnership deals

JD.com on Monday beat analysts’ second-quarter revenue expectation, as its partnership with global brands such as Louis Vuitton owner LVMH helped attract more shoppers to its Chinese e-commerce platform. The results come amid a crackdown on the country’s Big Tech companies by Chinese regulators that has led to an upheaval…

Read more: E-commerce firm JD.com beats second-quarter revenue estimates on boost from partnership deals

Court gives police three weeks to conclude Paytm ownership probe

In July, Paytm had filed the draft red herring prospectus (DRHP) for its Rs 16,600 crore IPO, which is expected to be India’s biggest public issue so far. Court on Monday has given police three weeks to conclude an investigation into claims from a former Paytm director who said he…

Read more: Court gives police three weeks to conclude Paytm ownership probe

Shenzhen tells local ‘made in China, sold on Amazon’ vendors it will stay neutral in their disputes with the US e-commerce giant

The government of Shenzhen, the southern Chinese tech hub where many cross-border online merchants are based, told the local “made in China, sold on Amazon” community that it will not intervene in their disputes with the US e-commerce giant, according to sources briefed about the decision. An official from Shenzhen’s…

Read more: Shenzhen tells local ‘made in China, sold on Amazon’ vendors it will stay neutral in their disputes with the US e-commerce giant

SenseTime parlays academic bona fides into world’s largest platform for artificial intelligence, facial recognition, image processing

Wang Xiaogang’s first encounter with a thinking machine two decades ago set him on a career path that would turn him into one of China’s foremost experts on artificial intelligence (AI). A masters student in electronic engineering in 2001, Wang was visiting a laboratory at the Chinese University of Hong…

Read more: SenseTime parlays academic bona fides into world’s largest platform for artificial intelligence, facial recognition, image processing

Explainer: what is Syngenta and why is it set to be this year’s biggest initial public offering?

Syngenta Group, the Swiss agrichemicals giant owned by state-backed China National Chemical Corporation (ChemChina), is going public on the Shanghai Stock Exchange’s Nasdaq-like Star Market in a transaction that could value it at US$60 billion, including debt. The company, which is based in Basel, expects to raise up to US$10…

Read more: Explainer: what is Syngenta and why is it set to be this year’s biggest initial public offering?

AI firm Yitu considers shifting initial public offering to Hong Kong as fundraising stalls on Shanghai Star market

The lone bear on Alibaba and Tencent says Chinese tech stocks’ rout to persist until China can enunciate end of crackdown

Chinese AI start-up SenseTime hires HSBC as it pursues US$2 billion Hong Kong IPO

China’s Big Tech crackdown: Beijing’s targets ‘unfair competition’ online with new rules challenging internet platforms

Alibaba’s new blockchain auction platform is selling Star Wars art on a ledger run by Sichuan’s government

Hong Kong stocks drop as China crackdown concerns linger before economic data signalling weakening recovery

Hints by SoftBank’s Masayoshi Son at pause from China tech investment stirs unease in the industry

Weibo public relations executive arrested on bribery charges as China takes aim at online opinion manipulation

OTHER NEWS