It’s almost bushfire season. Yes, even though floods are still racing through parts of eastern Australia. Fire conditions are above average including in inland New South Wales and Queensland.

When we switch back to a neutral or El Niño climate cycle, our fire risk will likely intensify, given the huge vegetation growth during these rainy years.

As we prepare for the next major fire season, it’s vital we take a close look at our laws. Why? Because these laws can clash in ways that make it harder for us to prepare.

Governments have always struggled to balance laws protecting nature with laws protecting us from bushfire.

In recent years, planning laws have been changed to make it easier to fell trees and clear vegetation to keep our homes safe. Some of these came out of the review of Victoria’s catastrophic 2009 Black Saturday fires, where many houses nestled in bush burned. But these changes to the rules about clearing native vegetation can also make it harder for us to preserve habitat – and can give us a false sense of security, encouraging us to settle deeper and deeper into the fire-prone bush.

clashing laws need to be fixed if we want to live in bushfire-prone  areas

Many people love living in the bush – but it comes with risks. Our bushfire laws are aimed at reducing risk to us – sometimes at the expense of nature. Shutterstock

Why do laws matter for bushfire preparation?

My colleagues and I recently mapped out Australia’s legal “anatomy” for fire. By anatomy, we mean all the different parts of the legal framework, including those that affect fire preparation.

Why? To optimise our system of laws to be ready for the ever-more-intense fires expected as the world heats up.

Here’s what a clash looks like. It’s now common to undertake prescribed burns and burn vegetation to reduce fuel loads and reduce the chances of a major bushfire.

But prescribed fires cause smoke. Fire agencies must comply with smoke pollution laws designed to keep vulnerable people safe. These two different risks – bushfire, and smoke-related illness – are managed under two different areas of law. Finding the balance is really hard.


We already know our environmental laws are failing to adequately protect nature.

Bushfires add to this as a serious and growing threat to our distinctive wildlife and ecosystems. The Black Summer megafires of 2019–20 killed huge numbers of animals and pushed many species closer to extinction, including mountain pygmy possums, native bees and rare frogs.

As fire seasons worsen and get longer over coming decades, fire agencies and local governments will be called on to clear and manage fuel loads – essentially, trees, plants and leaf litter – close to communities in the bush.

clashing laws need to be fixed if we want to live in bushfire-prone  areas

Leaf litter and fallen trees are fire hazards – and habitat. Shutterstock

You can see the issue. Bushfire fuel is also habitat. Our international and domestic obligations to protect threatened species and habitats will come into increasing conflict with the need to preserve our settlements and farms.

Better, clearer laws would help balance these issues. Last year, the Victorian government announced plans to make bushfire planning provisions clearer and more understandable. Reviews like this should clarify where homes can and can’t be safely built, as well as preventing development in sensitive habitat.

Laws around fire need to be considered separately

Emergency planners often group floods, storms and bushfires under the blanket term “all hazards”. This is done to help emergency services to plan efficient and coordinated responses to all kinds of extreme events.

We believe laws about fire also deserve specific attention, particularly in Australia, where many of our ecosystems have evolved alongside fire. Not all fire is equal and not all fires are emergencies.

In fact, laws governing protected areas in some states actually require parks agencies to use fire as a conservation tool. Using fire carefully is front and centre in the new plan to look after Tasmania’s Wilderness World Heritage Area.

Not only that, but some areas need small fires lit in a mosaic pattern. Why? To encourage moorland plants to put out the flowers and seeds the critically endangered orange-bellied parrot relies on.


Or take the growing importance of cultural fire management and traditional land management. Victoria’s cultural fire strategy describes cultural burning as a “responsibility” and an example of “living knowledge”, but not as an emergency.

Some laws, like arson, only apply to fire. There’s no equivalent crime for floods. Improving arson prevention could help cut the estimated A$1.6 billion in damages annually from fires being lit deliberately.

While arson is not as common as it used to be, cutting arson further will reduce the number of fires Australian firefighters have to respond to.

clashing laws need to be fixed if we want to live in bushfire-prone  areas

Low intensity cultural burning is growing in importance to fend off megafires, as in this image near Aurukun in Queensland. Jono Searle/AAP

We have to make laws intersect better

In the wake of destructive and lethal fires come the reviews and inquiries, which often recommend changes to emergency management laws.

These post-disaster inquiries also often recommend streamlining rules around native vegetation, to let landholders clear more trees and shrubs around their houses. That’s understandable, because these inquiries are intended to find lessons.

But if we look across the whole range of laws governing or touching on fire, we might find new ways to help us adapt.

Over the last century, Australian governments have launched hundreds of inquiries and commissions after major bushfires.

We don’t need to wait for the next fire and inquiry. We can find ways of optimising our web of intersecting laws right now – and prepare ourselves and nature for what is to come.


My co-authors Professors Jan McDonald and David Bowman, Associate Professor Michael Eburn, Dr Stuart Little and Dr Rebecca Harris contributed to the research on which this article is based.

Top 10 tips to keep cool this summer while protecting your health and your budget

4 facts about seagulls that will make you love these relentless chip thieves

4 creepy crawlies you’ll see more of this wet summer – and one iconic beetle you’ll probably miss

The lie of aqua nullius, ‘nobody’s water’, prevails in Australia. Indigenous water reserves are not enough to deliver justice

Antarctica’s emperor penguins could be extinct by 2100 – and other species may follow if we don’t act

Palm kernel product imported for use on dairy farms may actually be harmful to cows

Why electric vehicles won’t be enough to rein in transport emissions any time soon

Every Australian will be touched by climate change. So let’s start a national conversation about how we’ll cope

Global coal use in 2022 is reaching an all-time high, but Australia is bucking the trend

Five ways you can help stop biodiversity loss in your area – and around the world

Five options for restoring global biodiversity after the UN agreement

For Australia to lead the way on green hydrogen, first we must find enough water

The historic COP15 outcome is an imperfect game-changer for saving nature. Here’s why Australia did us proud

How closely monitoring households’ energy data can unleash their solar outputs and (possibly) make them more money

Clearer rules on reporting companies’ climate risks could soon put us on a path to decarbonising corporate Australia

Holiday foods can be toxic to pets – a veterinarian explains which, and what to do if Rover or Kitty eats them

TECH NEWS RELATED

Birdsong isn’t just competition for mates or territory. Zebra finches sing to bond

When you hear beautiful birdsong, such as the warbling of the Australasian magpie, you might believe it’s a sign of intense competition for territory or showing off to attract a mate. After all, that’s the way birdsong is often thought of – a way for male birds to compete with each ...

View more: Birdsong isn’t just competition for mates or territory. Zebra finches sing to bond

The A$30 billion Sun Cable crash is a setback but doesn’t spell the end of Australia’s renewable energy export dreams

Sun Cable – considered to be the world’s biggest renewable energy export project – announced this week it had entered voluntary administration following “the absence of alignment” with shareholders. Sun Cable is expected to cost over A$30 billion. It proposes to build an enormous, 12,000 hectare solar farm in the ...

View more: The A$30 billion Sun Cable crash is a setback but doesn’t spell the end of Australia’s renewable energy export dreams

6 reasons 2023 could be a very good year for climate action

Many people think of the annual UN climate talks as talkfests which achieve only incremental change, at best. Activist Greta Thunberg has described them as “blah blah blah” moments – grossly inadequate and too often hijacked by fossil fuel producers who would like the world to keep buying their main ...

View more: 6 reasons 2023 could be a very good year for climate action

‘More potent than cyanide’: how to stay safe from blue-ringed octopus this summer

As an octopus biologist, I get a call from the media every summer because someone has had an encounter with a blue-ringed octopus. Thankfully, everyone has been OK. Blue-ringed octopus are famed for being one of the most venomous animals on the planet, and the symptoms from a bite are ...

View more: ‘More potent than cyanide’: how to stay safe from blue-ringed octopus this summer

New report shows alarming changes in the entire global water cycle

In 2022, a third La Niña year brought much rain to Australia and Southeast Asia and dry conditions to the other side of the Pacific. These patterns were expected, but behind these variations there are troubling signs the entire global water cycle is changing. Our research team watches the global ...

View more: New report shows alarming changes in the entire global water cycle

Are stingrays actually dangerous? 3 reasons you shouldn’t fear these sea pancakes

To beat the summer heat, many of us in the Southern Hemisphere are hitting the beach – and this raises our chances of encountering potentially dangerous marine life beneath the waves. So should we be worried about stingrays? You might still think so, even if it’s been 16 years since ...

View more: Are stingrays actually dangerous? 3 reasons you shouldn’t fear these sea pancakes

Why do our dogs and cats bring us dead animals?

What do a little penguin, a baby rabbit, a black rat and a Krefft’s glider have in common? They’ve all been presented to me (when dead) by my animal companions. Chances are, if you live with a cat or dog, you’ve also been brought something similar. So, is it a ...

View more: Why do our dogs and cats bring us dead animals?

Labor’s scheme to cut industrial emissions is worryingly flexible

The federal government today proposed new rules to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from Australia’s polluting industrial sector. The rule changes apply to a measure known as the “safeguard mechanism”, and are supposed to stop Australia’s top 215 emitters, such as new coal, oil and gas projects, from emitting over certain ...

View more: Labor’s scheme to cut industrial emissions is worryingly flexible

Why Pacific Islanders are staying put even as rising seas flood their homes and crops

Chubb review of Australia’s carbon credit scheme falls short – and problems will continue to fester

Meet the eastern bristlebird: tragically under-appreciated , and one fire away from local extinction

Climate change is leaving African elephants desperate for water

Insects and spiders make up more than half NZ’s animal biodiversity – time to celebrate these spineless creatures

More than 100,000 tourists will head to Antarctica this summer. Should we worry about damage to the ice and its ecosystems?

How to feed your garden birds if you want to attract and support native species

Australians pay $163 a month on average to store all the stuff we buy – how can we stop overconsuming?

Green streets: why protecting urban parks and bush is vital as our cities grow and become denser

When we swim in the ocean, we enter another animal’s home. Here’s how to keep us all safe

22 predictions we made in 2022, and the 6 we got wrong

What risks could pet hamsters and gerbils pose in Australia?

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News