We previously reported a story about a rumor that claimed many of the bugs in Cyberpunk 2077 were the fault of an external QA partner. It’s alleged that third-party QA studio Quantic Lab used inexperienced testers and had quotas for them that caused them to forward thousands of minor bugs that took time away from fixing more important ones. Quantic Lab has responded to the accusations against it and says the YouTube video that made the allegations contains inaccurate statements.

Cyberpunk 2077 QA studio denies wrongdoings

Cyberpunk 2077 QA Studio Quantic Lab Denies Allegations of Mismanagement

Quantic Lab CEO Stefan Seicarescu issued a statement to Forbes in response to its article about the YouTube video from Upper Echelon Gaming that made the claims against the studio. In it, Seicarescu primarily addresses the claim that the Cyberpunk 2077 team was short-staffed. He also explains that they weren’t the only QA team to work on the game. Finally, he mentions that all customer agreements are confidential, which is likely why his statement is rather vague, given the severe nature of the allegations against the studio.

Upper Echelon Gamers made a second video to “clarify” that he didn’t mean to say that Quantic Lab had staffing issues on the Cyberpunk 2077 team and that the initial report misunderstood him. His words in the original video were, “Quantic Lab was already struggling to fully staff all their other projects, not just Cyberpunk 2077. So they were short on workers.” So, it’s easy to see how Forbes might have thought he was saying that Quantic Lab was struggling to fully staff the Cyberpunk 2077 team because that’s exactly what he said.


Above: CD Projekt Red processing its QA tickets.

Of course, the allegations don’t make a ton of sense. Upper Echelon Gaming claims that a neverending flood of bug reports from Quantic Lab prevented CD Projekt Red from fixing big issues because they had to work on all the small nitpicky ones. However, as funny as the mental image is, bug fixing doesn’t work like Lucille Ball at a chocolate factory. Bugs would be submitted as part of a priority system, and Upper Echelon Games even acknowledges this with the claim that CD Projekt Red asked Quantic Lab to stop putting low-priority tickets into the system at some point. Also, devs play the game as they build it, so they’re not blindly grasping at QA tickets to know what to fix.

Upper Echelon Gamers’ claims unravel a bit further when you do a small amount of research. For example, in his first video, he states, “Even the project leader had barely one year of experience.” Well, the credits for Cyberpunk 2077 list all of the QA team from Quantic Lab that worked on the game. That makes it simple to see how much experience they currently have by just searching on LinkedIn:

  • Senior Project Manager: Marius Popa – 15 years, 8 months with Quantic Lab
  • Project Manager: Hajnalka Szilágyi – 11 years, 1 month with Quantic Lab
  • Project Manager: Raluca Maria Fatol – 7 years with Quantic Lab

So, three of the four (credited) project leads were veterans when Quantic Lab started working on Cyberpunk 2077. The fourth didn’t have a LinkedIn, but I’m sure I could send them an email if I was in dire need of the info.

Cyberpunk 2077 QA Studio Quantic Lab Denies Allegations of Mismanagement

Addressing further claims of inexperience, QA Tester is an entry-level position with a high turnover rate. Those who do well at it are quickly promoted to leads and then managers if they’re working at a company full-time. This isn’t always the case with freelance QA (which is a whole other problem in the industry), but that doesn’t seem to be the issue here. So, saying that the testers on Cyberpunk 2077 were too inexperienced makes zero sense to anyone familiar with how the industry works.

Of course, Upper Echelon Gamers must have also missed the fact that CD Projekt Red’s internal QA team was just about equal in size to the team that Quantic Lab had on the game. The videos don’t address what part they played or the quality of their work, which seems like something you’d look at if you were prepared to make such strong accusations. Kind of a significant oversight for someone who claims all game journalists do is copy and paste other people’s articles.

Just before I published this, Upper Echelon put out another video detailing claims of poor business practices by Quantic Lab. I haven’t had the time to verify that information, and it’s beyond the scope of this article. However, I don’t really know why he would care when he made a video nitpicking the media’s reporting on crunch during Cyberpunk 2077 in October 2020. (And yes, it’s still crunch if it’s “voluntary.”)

The question of how much Quantic Lab contributed to the poor state of Cyberpunk 2077’s launch is still in question. I haven’t seen the documentation that Upper Echelon claims to have, and it’s possible that Quantic Lab did a horrific job QA testing the game. However, I do know enough about the game after years of covering it that you can’t lay the blame at one particular person or department’s feet. Overemphasizing Quantic Lab’s effect on Cyberpunk 2077’s development doesn’t do anyone any favors.

TECH NEWS RELATED

How to romance The Spirit in Hooked on You: A DBD Dating Sim

Screenshot by Pro Game Guides Hooked on You is a dream come true for anyone into Dead by Daylight and dating sims. It’s as if Behaviour Interactive crafted this game just for us. Stuck on a tropical island paradise, it falls to you to win the heart of one ...

View more: How to romance The Spirit in Hooked on You: A DBD Dating Sim

CryptoDickbutts Ethereum NFTs Surge 690% in Daily Sales Volume

The floor price of Series 3 CryptoDickButts climbed as prominent influencers shilled their Dickbutt bags and praised the CDB community.

View more: CryptoDickbutts Ethereum NFTs Surge 690% in Daily Sales Volume

After more than 20 years, a new Fatal Fury/Garou game has been greenlit

Image via SNK SNK Corporation surprised long-time fighting games fans with a new announcement about the Fatal Fury franchise during EVO 2022. SNK has greenlit a new entry of the Fatal Fury/Garou franchise. SNK shared the news with a new image of Rock Howard in a dark alleyway with ...

View more: After more than 20 years, a new Fatal Fury/Garou game has been greenlit

Strangers of Paradise's DLC is a lesson for how not to design DLC for your game

How do you design a DLC for a game? With Stranger of Paradise: Final Fantasy Origin, it feels like that should have been an easy task; some additional story, some new levels inspired by other Final Fantasy games of the past (perhaps some spinoffs, this time around?) alongside a ...

View more: Strangers of Paradise's DLC is a lesson for how not to design DLC for your game

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 multiplayer reveal September 15, beta begins September 16

Image via @CallofDuty The next generation of Call of Duty is almost in players’ hands. The official Call of Duty website announced today that the Call of Duty Next event explaining details about Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 will air, featuring a full reveal of the multiplayer, Warzone ...

View more: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 multiplayer reveal September 15, beta begins September 16

Call of Duty: Warzone 2 reveal set for September

As well as Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II's multiplayer, Call of Duty: Warzone for mobile and a couple of surprises.

View more: Call of Duty: Warzone 2 reveal set for September

Warzone 2 and Modern Warfare 2 multiplayer to headline big Call of Duty September event

Call of Duty Next is a new event unveiling the "imminent future" of the franchise

View more: Warzone 2 and Modern Warfare 2 multiplayer to headline big Call of Duty September event

New Fatal Fury Game Announced; The King of Fighters XV Reveals Team Samurai & More

Today during the grand finals of the King of Fighters XV tournament at EVO 2022, SNK announced the fourth team coming within Team Pass 2 and much more. The new team was announced by chief producer Yasuyuki Oda and it’s Team Samurai, bringing forth three characters from Samurai Shodown. The ...

View more: New Fatal Fury Game Announced; The King of Fighters XV Reveals Team Samurai & More

Full Modern Warfare 2 Multiplayer Reveal Coming Next Month

EVO 2022: SNK Announces Development of New Fatal Fury Game

When is Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II's open beta?

Modern Warfare 2 Multiplayer Reveal Happening at Call of Duty: Next

Go listen to the first-ever gaming concert at the BBC Proms, a landmark event

Dragon Ball FighterZ Getting PS5, Xbox Series X|S Versions, & Rollback Netcode

Wayne Taylor Racing Acura Wins Road America, MSR Acura Crashes

Modern Warfare 2 beta dates confirmed

2022 iPad Pro could include pair of mystery ports

House of the Dragon: Matt Smith Thinks There Are Too Many Sex Scenes

Apple will announce iPhone 14 via another prerecorded video message

This Cube Used to Be a 1967 Shelby Mustang GT500

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News