climate, cop26, climate change
Credit: Scharfsinn/Shutterstock

The three most prevalent myths about tackling climate change allege that transitioning to renewable energy jacks up household bills, requires massive amounts of government subsidy and creates mass unemployment. These concerns are all (thankfully) false.

With fellow academics, I studied instances from the past 30 years when governments succeeded in using public investment and regulation to rapidly scale up the deployment of renewable energy technologies like solar panels and wind turbines.

We found that the traditional approach to making energy policy—carrying out cost-benefit analyses, otherwise known as bean counting—tended to impede the roll-out of renewable energy because it misconceived the economy as something static which always operates in an optimal way. This perspective assumes that policy can do little to disrupt the structure of existing markets. The meteoric rise of entirely new sectors over the last decade, such as the global electric vehicle market and offshore wind, show that policy can in fact drive radical changes.

It’s time to debunk the myths which are holding back the transition from fossil fuels.

Myth one: Decarbonization will make electricity expensive

Subsidizing low-carbon technology is an investment, not a cost. A recent study suggested it is an opportunity for the global economy with a potential return of US$12 trillion.

Government policies, like offering research and development grants to companies experimenting with more capacious batteries or loan guarantees for firms developing riskier technologies such as concentrated solar power, create an incentive for private companies to invest in new ventures too.

Investment eventually creates a tipping point in the market when the natural choice for investors or consumers shifts from a dominant technology like fossil fuel to an upstart one, like renewable energy, because the latter is suddenly cheaper or more profitable than the former. Once this happens, there can be an exponential growth in the deployment of these new technologies. This has already happened: the plunging cost of generating electricity from solar and wind power caused rooftop solar panel installation rates to soar across Europe alongside investment in large offshore wind farms.

As more of these technologies are deployed worldwide, manufacturers can afford to build larger factories to service growing demand. Coupled with new supply chains, routes to market and the insight gained from making lots of a particular product, the costs of manufacturing drop dramatically. Making one solar panel or wind turbine becomes vastly cheaper over time, which in turn makes the production of a unit of electricity cheaper. These cost curves exist with most new technologies, but not mature ones (like coal power stations) which have been around for decades.

There is also a hefty cost attached to doing nothing about climate change. Recent estimates show a potential global economic loss of US$7 trillion tied to the continued pursuit of growth powered by fossil fuels.

Myth two: Renewables need massive subsidies

Renewables over the past three decades have already benefited from government subsidies like feed-in tariffs. These give an additional payment to power companies for the electricity they generate from wind, solar and other renewable sources.

Renewables now compete with and even beat the cost of generating power from fossil fuels. Offshore wind, for example, produces electricity at about a quarter of the current price charged to consumers in the U.K.—a price set by the wholesale cost of gas. Building new wind turbines no longer relies on subsidies.

Meanwhile the fossil fuel industry benefits enormously from subsidies, receiving almost US$700 billion in 2021 alone. These include governments setting and then subsidizing the price of petrol or cooking oil for consumers, giving tax incentives to companies importing or exporting fossil fuels and guaranteeing a minimum level of domestic purchase. These so-called brown subsidies lock countries into ever more expensive sources of energy, as fossil fuels are depleted and require ever more expensive methods such as deep ocean drilling or fracking to extract, which would require subsidies growing forever.

Myth three: Jobs will disappear

The transition from fossil fuels in energy systems will shed nearly 3 million jobs in mining, power plant construction and other sectors. But it is expected to create more than 12 million new ones in transport, renewable power generation and energy efficiency by 2030.

Research also suggests that unabated climate change will cause massive job losses on its own, especially in agriculture and construction where extreme weather is likely to wreak havoc. Climate change is already expected to cause US$1 trillion in losses to business over the next five years.

Plentiful green jobs aren’t inevitable, though. Governments must offer skills and employment support to help workers switch from drilling for oil and gas to deploying offshore wind turbines, for example. Such investment could support green jobs which pay 7% more than the average fossil fuel sector job.

The current approach to making climate policy is hindered by the prevalence of these myths. The truth is that investing in a green transition will lower electricity prices, free funding from entrenched fossil fuel subsidies and create new jobs all over the world.

If we continue to fuss about the costs of action then by 2050 there won’t be very many beans left to count. Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Citation: ‘Decarbonization is too expensive’: How to sell climate change action to bean counters (2022, September 29) retrieved 29 September 2022 from This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


WhatsApp working on picture-in-picture for video calls

Representative image The reliable folks over at WABetaInfo have found traces of a new WhatsApp feature in the latest beta builds for the iOS version of the app. The new feature enables picture-in-picture mode for video calls on the platform. This will allow people to continue their video call ...

View more: WhatsApp working on picture-in-picture for video calls

A promising trial targets a genetic risk for Alzheimer’s

In a bold attempt to stop the progress of some cases of Alzheimer’s disease, a group of researchers is trying something new: injecting a protective gene into patients’ brains. The trial involved just five patients with a particular genetic risk for Alzheimer’s. They received a very low dose of ...

View more: A promising trial targets a genetic risk for Alzheimer’s

Xiaomi 13 Pro India launch tipped to take place soon after BIS spotting

Xiaomi is gearing up to launch its flagship smartphone series in China soon. The Xiaomi 13 series is expected to drop in China in the first half of December after the initial December 1 launch date was postponed. The Xiaomi 13 series line-up is expected to include two smartphones ...

View more: Xiaomi 13 Pro India launch tipped to take place soon after BIS spotting

How Did Ancient Fish Colonize the Deep Sea?

A lanternfish in the family Myctophidae, mesopelagic fishes that undergo daily vertical migrations. Credit: Steven Haddock/Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute The deep sea holds more than 90% of our oceans’ water, but only around one-third of all fish species. Scientists have long assumed that the reason was obvious: shallow ...

View more: How Did Ancient Fish Colonize the Deep Sea?

UK retail Christmas sales expected to hit £82.2 billion with brand success depending on consumers’ satisfaction with call centre experiences.

Infinity, the global call intelligence and speech analytics platform, today reveals that Infinity’s data sees significant year on year spikes in call volumes to retailers using its platform relating to customer service during Black Friday sales chaos. Infinity’s call data shows that there was a spike of up to ...

View more: UK retail Christmas sales expected to hit £82.2 billion with brand success depending on consumers’ satisfaction with call centre experiences.

7 Apps To Assist You With Everyday Tasks When You Feel Lazy

We’ve all had days when all we want to do is plant ourselves on the couch and binge on a new TV show. Luckily for lazy people, there are apps that can help you with tasks you don’t want to do. Here is a couple of them to help ...

View more: 7 Apps To Assist You With Everyday Tasks When You Feel Lazy

5 Great PDF-To-Speech Read-Aloud Apps For Android

If you are someone who regularly deals with excessive text files, or if you are someone who loves reading but does not have time, read-aloud apps might be for you. PDF-to-speech apps are also great aids to those with disabilities that make it difficult to read, which is why ...

View more: 5 Great PDF-To-Speech Read-Aloud Apps For Android

J&K to create pool of cybersecurity analysts to tackle cyber terrorism, internet crimes

ETtech The CSP, along with a digital vision document, was launched by Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha on the concluding day of the two-day national conference on e-governance in Katra on November 27 (Illustration: Rahul Awasthi) Jammu and Kashmir is planning to create a pool of cybersecurity analysts under the recently ...

View more: J&K to create pool of cybersecurity analysts to tackle cyber terrorism, internet crimes

SaaS firm Whatfix looks to expand presence in Australia, southeast Asia, France

IG International partners with agri-tech platfrorm Fyllo to enhance production

Apple supplier Foxconn maintains Covid-19 production measures in world’s largest iPhone factory to meet surge in holiday orders

Nutrition analysis startup Zoe Health extends Series B with £25m

Novel Research Demonstrates New Method of Spinal Cord Tissue Repair

Minor Facial Scars Do Not Have Negative Affects on First Impressions

Post-lockdown auto emissions can't hide in the grass

RULoans launches digital platform for partner on-boarding

Google opens London research centre for disability support tech

NetApp deepens APAC ties with new channel leader

Partech closes £103m seed fund, eyes UK startups

Loss of key Apple AirPods account causes GoerTek profits to fall by 50% – 60%


Top Car News Car News