acquisition, elon musk, social media

Elon Musk is buying Twitter for $44 billion.

Bloomberg

It looks as if Twitter Inc. will sell itself to Elon Musk for $43 billion, which would make the deal one of the largest leveraged buyouts in Wall Street history, and give Tesla Inc.’s steward a powerful social media perch.

The math is sketchy, however, as are Musk’s intentions. Both of those factors promise to make this deal a potential train wreck and will force investors, managers, users, and society to think more clearly and seriously about the role that social media companies play in an era scarred by viral propaganda and misinformation.

Leveraged buyouts (LBOs) typically involve taking publicly-traded companies private by piling debt on them, and using their cash flow to pay down those obligations. Along the way, the firms that take over the companies are meant to make their targets more competitive and innovative. That’s the theory, anyway. The buyout wave that began in the 1980s and crested in 2007 was littered with deals gone awry. The LBO landscape grew quieter after the 2008 financial crisis, but handsome returns for investors and low interest rates caused transactions to reach new heights in recent years. If Musk snares Twitter, it will inevitably become a marquee case study of the efficacy of LBOs.

Of course, Musk’s presence means the buyout isn’t just one thing, so let’s examine the math. Musk says he’s pledging $21 billion of his own money, and will presumably sell a chunk of Tesla stock to raise those funds. Banks are going to lend him $12.5 billion, secured by an additional $62.5 billion of his Tesla shares. The rest of the purchase price and other costs will be funded by $13 billion in debt that Twitter will take on. Read my colleague Matt Levine for a more detailed accounting, but at the end of the day Twitter will have about $1 billion in interest payments due annually.

Maybe that will be manageable? It’s a close call. Twitter’s cash flows (the money it hauls in before accounting for interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortisation) are projected to be about $1.43 billion this year, and $1.85 billion in 2023. So debt payments will consume a huge chunk of Twitter’s cash. Homeowners underwater on a big mortgage and related interest payments will be able to sympathise with the financial corner in which Musk may be putting Twitter. Musk is going to have about $1 billion in interest payments to make, too, and if Tesla’s shares hit rough waters he could get squeezed, but let’s leave his wallet out of the mix for now. Twitter itself is going to have to churn at full throttle to earn the kind of money it needs to be both profitable and self-sufficient.

So there’s going to be pressure on Musk to make the financials work. He is said to have grand plans for doing that, which thus far seems to amount to an undisclosed deck he recently showed his backers. But he also said he isn’t interested in Twitter for economic reasons, which gave some potential financiers pause. The deal “wouldn’t make much sense to most private equity investors,” according to Bloomberg News.

But Musk swayed Morgan Stanley, Bank of America Corp., Barclays Plc, and other big players, in part because of what Bloomberg News described as his “enthusiasm for the deal”. Enthusiasm only gets you so far, but big institutions such as Morgan Stanley have presumably done their due diligence. Or perhaps they also want to stay in Musk’s good graces so they can be well-positioned to get deal flow from Tesla? Maybe a bit of both? Time will tell. Investors expressed some optimism, lifting the stock price more than 3 percent on April 25, though it is still below the $54.20-a-share offer price.

Musk still hasn’t provided meaningful details about what, exactly, he will do to rev up Twitter’s engines. He has been an effective and bold leader at Tesla — but Tesla makes electric vehicles; it’s not a media company. Managerial prowess often doesn’t translate across different types of businesses. Media companies have found the digital era challenging, with advertising evaporating or finding new channels and subscription revenue difficult to corral.

Media companies also provide a public service. In an ideal world, responsible media companies keep users informed, monitor how power is used, how society evolves, and provide forums for ideas. Musk has used social media to play games with his business interests, troll those he doesn’t like, and run afoul of the law and regulators. None of that is a recipe for enlightened media management. As we’ve also learned from Facebook’s and Twitter’s myriad travails monitoring propaganda and disinformation, social media companies need to do a better job of vetting the information on their platforms. Musk shows no sign of being up to that task.

Yes, it’s compelling to watch Musk do his thing and interesting (and often disturbing) to see how much he breaks along the way, but media companies matter. They shape public dialogue and private conversations. The price of buffoonery and delinquency is greater than $43 billion.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Bajaj Auto sales at 3,47,004 units in June

Bajaj Auto | CMP: Rs 3,780 | The scrip jumped 4 percent after the auto firm informed exchanges that the board of directors will meet on June 27 to further deliberate on the proposal for buyback of equity shares of the company. Bajaj Auto sales remained flat at 3,47,004 ...

View more: Bajaj Auto sales at 3,47,004 units in June

MG Motor India June retail sales rise 27% at 4,503 units

MG Motor India MG Motor India on Friday reported a 27 per cent growth in retail sales at 4,503 units in June. The company had clocked retail sales of 3,558 units in the same month last year. The momentum in sales (evident across all models) comes on the back ...

View more: MG Motor India June retail sales rise 27% at 4,503 units

Tribunal allows Hero MotoCorp to use 'Hero' trademark for its EVs

Hero MotoCorp The country’s largest two-wheeler maker Hero MotoCorp can use the ‘Hero’ trademark to sell its upcoming electric vehicles, as per a ruling by an arbitration tribunal. In a late night regulatory filing on Thursday, the two-wheeler major stated that the tribunal has ruled in its favour regarding ...

View more: Tribunal allows Hero MotoCorp to use 'Hero' trademark for its EVs

Instagram confirms it is working to turn video posts into Reels

APMeta-owned photo-sharing platform Instagram has confirmed that it is testing a change that turns video posts into Reels.According to TechCrunch, the company said the change, which is currently being tested with select users around the world, is part of Instagram’s plan to simplify video on the app.“We are testing this ...

View more: Instagram confirms it is working to turn video posts into Reels

Indian Bank raises MCLR rates by 0.15% across tenors

All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA) strongly condemned Indian Bank’s “anti-women” decision to not appoint selected women candidates who are more than 12 weeks pregnant. State-owned Indian Bank said it has raised the Marginal Cost of Funds based Lending Rates (MCLR) across tenors by 0.15 per cent with effect ...

View more: Indian Bank raises MCLR rates by 0.15% across tenors

Hindustan Copper to seek shareholders' nod to raise Rs 500 crore via debentures

Hindustan Copper Ltd. State-owned Hindustan Copper said that its board has suggested seeking shareholders’ approval to raise up to Rs 500 crore through debentures. The board has also recommended taking the approval of the shareholders in the ensuing annual general meeting for raising funds by issue of equity shares ...

View more: Hindustan Copper to seek shareholders' nod to raise Rs 500 crore via debentures

HSBC to relaunch India private banking business within a year: Executive

HSBC Holdings PLC plans to relaunch its India private banking business within a year, its India CEO told Reuters on Thursday, after the Asia-focused lender has identified the country as a key strategic market for growth. HSBC exited the Indian private banking business in 2015 as part of a ...

View more: HSBC to relaunch India private banking business within a year: Executive

Starlink Gets FCC Approval for Satellite Internet Use on Moving Vehicles, ‘Portability’ Coming

The famous global satellite internet service, Starlink, recently got its FCC approval that allows it to use the connection to mount on moving vehicles as part of one of its features and applications. The “Portability” feature got massive recognition from people that like to be on the move, and now, ...

View more: Starlink Gets FCC Approval for Satellite Internet Use on Moving Vehicles, ‘Portability’ Coming

Tesla Model S Plaid Runs at Breakneck Speed of More Than 200 mph With Only a Single Modification

Reports: FTX Targeting BlockFi Purchase At $25M

Your Facebook Groups Now Have Group Chats and Audio Calls

Elon Musk's Tesla Semi Truck Appears Once More to Deliver Superchargers to Seca Racetrack

Sanjiv Mehta appointed non-executive chairman of Unilever Indonesia

Metro Cash and Carry violated government norms: CAIT

Tesla Facing Bankruptcy?

PM Modi inaugurates Bosch India's 'smart' campus in Bengaluru

IOC to invest Rs 740 crore to raise Digboi refinery capacity

ReNew Power, UNEP, SEWA to jointly train women salt pan workers to be solar power technicians 

PGCIL board to consider proposals to raise Rs 11,000 crore on July 6

Seven states among top achievers in 'ease of doing business' ranking of states, UTs

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News