examining the clash of masculine identities on an internet hate site
Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain

As a biracial woman, it wasn’t easy for Jillian Sunderland to spend countless hours studying a website devoted to racism, misogyny and hate.

But she persevered with her research on the internet hate site Stormfront.org, which promotes white nationalism and the alt-right movement. Created by former Alabama Ku Klux Klan leader and long-time white supremacist Don Black in 1995, the site’s 300,000 members openly share their racist, violent and misogynistic views.

“It’s the longest running white nationalist forum for hate, and originally, I wanted to look at the common ideology of the people in this white supremacist forum,” says Sunderland, a Ph.D. student in the University of Toronto’s department of sociology in the Faculty of Arts & Science.

“But what I found were two groups: one prioritizing the hatred of women and one prioritizing the hatred of non-white people—and a lot of disagreements that led to a fracture within the movement. I wasn’t expecting to find this at all.”

Her work—”Fighting for Masculine Hegemony: Contestation Between Alt-Right and White Nationalist Masculinities on Stormfront.org”—was recently published in the journal Men and Masculinities. “It felt really, really great—and it was a long time coming,” says Sunderland of learning that her first peer-reviewed paper had been accepted.

Sunderland says she was fascinated by her findings in what she described as a relatively understudied area, noting they could be used to help disrupt hate movements. But she adds that her long engagement with the platform affected her on a personal level.

“Spending hours a day reading hateful comments was sometimes very upsetting,” she says, adding that she relied on support from her academic supervisors and from fellow academics studying the same field.

“I’m one of the people the forum targets in terms of saying horrible things about Black women, Black men and how biracial people are abominations,” she says. “And I couldn’t believe the level of hatred of women. There was a lot of racism but the way they talked about women was shocking.”

Sunderland used the label “alt-misogynists” for the group of Stormfront.org users who formed their identities around the opposition to women. Men in this group, she says, were usually under 40, though some were much younger. Many were single and opposed marriage.

“They see women as representing the breakdown of civilization,” says Sunderland. “In their minds, women are irresponsible, opportunistic, as well as promiscuous, continually seeking to take advantage of, and exploit, men.”

The other group Sunderland called “Aryan men.” Defining themselves through race, not gender, they were often older, more established and had families.

“They identify as defending themselves against Black men, Jewish men and other groups,” says Sunderland, adding that they portray themselves as superior to other cultures and races with respect to raising families and possessing traditional family values.

Sunderland was shocked to see just how much “alt-misogynists” and “Aryan men” quarreled on the site.

“In my paper, I show fighting between these two groups where they try to invalidate and criticize each other,” she says. “The ‘alt-misogynists’ were often critical of the older members, accusing them of being out of touch with contemporary society. The fighting got so bad on some occasions, the ‘alt-misogynists’ would leave the platform altogether.”

Often that fighting centered around women and their role in society.

“The older ‘Aryan’ members have established gender norms that men and women are complementary—that the man takes care of the woman,” says Sunderland. “Their base idea is to create a white homeland with growing white families.”

The “alt-misogynists,” by contrast, have vastly different views on gender—and many of them expressed their belief and support for a society that’s based on the total domination of women.

“They’re very different from the traditional white nationalists who see women as a part of their movement,” says Sunderland. “A lot of the older white nationalist members found these views offensive.”

Sunderland says she was jarred by the number of posts devoted to victimization.

“A big part of the far-right is the sense of superiority, but also this deep sense that society is no longer set up in their favor,” she says.

Any kind of boost in diversity or a shift in equity was regarded as a threat to their way of life.

“They were referencing divorce rates, declining marriage rates, declining fertility—and they viewed these things as examples of a society that was now gynocentric, dominated by women and feminism. And that it’s actively disadvantaging them.

“There’s this phrase that ‘equality feels like oppression when you’re used to having more privileges.’ So, they see themselves as victims.”

Sunderland says she would sometimes step back and totally disengage from the site and her paper for a week or two to clear her head and then return with a renewed sense of purpose.

“My goal is to better understand these movements to help disrupt them, so that kept me level-headed,” she says. “But studying the extreme right is not for everyone; it’s studying people who literally advocate for a genocide of non-white people. That’s why it’s very understudied.”

Her paper concluded with the idea that this split between these two groups could offer an opportunity to further impede the wave of hate.

“Within social movements, if it’s a successful movement, there tends to be a unification within a masculine or feminine strategy,” she says.

“But on this site, that didn’t happen. It’s a more fractured movement and I think acknowledging their internal dynamics can provide an entry point in how people desist, leave—or migrate to and from—the far-right.”

But to pursue this idea, much more research is needed, Sunderland says.

“Future research can lead to more clarity when attempting to deradicalize or prevent radicalization from happening, and I hope my paper offers a way for experts to really grapple with the complexity of hate/far-right movements.” More information: Jillian Sunderland, Fighting for Masculine Hegemony: Contestation Between Alt-Right and White Nationalist Masculinities on Stormfront.org, Men and Masculinities (2022). DOI: 10.1177/1097184X221120664 Provided by University of Toronto Citation: Examining the clash of masculine identities on an internet hate site (2022, September 27) retrieved 27 September 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-09-clash-masculine-identities-internet-site.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Respiratory illnesses slam US: “Perfect storm for a terrible holiday season”

Respiratory illnesses are slamming the US, and things could get worse.

View more: Respiratory illnesses slam US: “Perfect storm for a terrible holiday season”

AI-designed structured material creates super-resolution images using a low-resolution display

Super-resolution image display using diffractive decoders. Credit: Ozcan Lab @ UCLA. One of the promising technologies being developed for next-generation augmented/virtual reality (AR/VR) systems is holographic image displays that use coherent light illumination to emulate the 3D optical waves representing, for example, the objects within a scene. These holographic ...

View more: AI-designed structured material creates super-resolution images using a low-resolution display

Improving precision of pressure determination in nanosecond X-ray diffraction experiments

Optical photograph taken during a laser-driven compression and nanosecond X-ray diffraction experiment at the Omega Laser Facility. The inset illustrates the specific target configuration used in this study, where multiple samples were simultaneously compressed along a quasi-isentropic path. Graphic credit: Kowaluk/LLE and Coppari/LLNL X-ray diffraction measurements under laser-driven dynamic ...

View more: Improving precision of pressure determination in nanosecond X-ray diffraction experiments

December serving up baked Alaska and warming most of Arctic

Waves from the Bering Sea splash up on a jetty on Sept. 16, 2022, in Nome, Alaska. Much of the Arctic is in a burst of freak December 2022 warming. Scientists say some of it is random weather from storms and some of it is from low sea ice. ...

View more: December serving up baked Alaska and warming most of Arctic

A journey across generations: Inheritance of the plant microbiome via seed

A conceptual figure depicting the process of microbial inheritance in plants. The process encompasses three stages as indicated at the top of the figure: (1) from plant to seed, (2) dormancy, and (3) from seed to seedling. The first stage involves both sexual and asexual transmission. Processes highlighted are ...

View more: A journey across generations: Inheritance of the plant microbiome via seed

Understanding the cryptic role fungi play in ecosystems

Fruiting bodies of shaggy scalycap (Pholiota sp.) on a log just off the Appalachian Trail in Hanover, New Hampshire. Credit: Bala Chaudhary When you say “fungi,” most people think of mushrooms, showy fruiting bodies, but most fungi do not produce mushrooms. It is estimated that there are approximately 3 ...

View more: Understanding the cryptic role fungi play in ecosystems

Shhhh … speaking more quietly in restaurants means everyone can be heard

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain In a crowded restaurant, diners usually talk with their companions at their own table. But the sound of their conversations bounces off walls and reflects to other patrons, creating background noise. Each individual speaker wants to be heard over that noise, so they end up ...

View more: Shhhh … speaking more quietly in restaurants means everyone can be heard

Religious violence increases anxiety among Muslims and Jews, even if they have never been personally targeted

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain Fear of hate crime looms especially large in the minds of Jews and Muslims, even if they have never been personally targeted, according to a new study from Rice University and West Virginia University. “Fear of Religious Hate Crime Victimization and the Residual Effects of ...

View more: Religious violence increases anxiety among Muslims and Jews, even if they have never been personally targeted

Good Food Movement on how FoodTech innovations promote better lifestyles and sustainable business returns [ORIGIN Innovation Awards Q&A]

Telkomsel's Jockie Heruseon on the relevance of the digital economy in supporting sunstainable innovation [ORIGIN Innovation Awards Q&A]

Men are slowly losing their Y chromosome, but a new sex gene discovery in spiny rats brings hope for humanity

MacGregor House gains a well-being graduate resident advisor

Companies spy on your email with invisible images – here’s how to stop them

Sale jumpstarts floating, offshore wind power in U.S. waters

More flexible than we thought: Worms provide new insights into the evolution and diversification of TGF-ß signaling

New research develops a model that optimizes political fairness for political redistricting

New instrument measures supercurrent flow; data has applications in quantum computing

Study shows the majority of California's coastal airports are vulnerable to increased flooding caused by climate change

New study finds that 70% of Florida's coral reefs are eroding

Boosted by government programs, cover cropping is increasing across the US Midwest

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News