local stakeholder involvement key to understanding protection level of marine protected areas
Red pencil urchin at the Papahānaumokuākea MPA. Credit: James Watt, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service – Pacific Region, Wikimedia Commons.

Knowledge provided by local stakeholders such as non-governmental organizations, academics, civil servants, journalists, and fishers can be valuable for evaluating the effectiveness of countries’ marine protected areas (MPAs).

In a recent paper published in the journal Sustainability, researchers with The Sea Around Us initiative at the University of British Columbia’s Institute for the Oceans and Fisheries present a first-of-its-kind approach that involves incorporating qualitative information into a global, hard-data database to get a better understanding of the actual level of protection of each country’s MPAs.

Such qualitative information emerges from both scientific and gray literature and, especially, from the observations of over 800 stakeholders regarding at least one marine protected area in their respective country’s Exclusive Economic Zones.

“First, we bridged the detailed fisheries data in The Sea Around Us database and website with other MPA databases. Then, we enriched those data with information from peer-reviewed and other types of publications, as well as local stakeholders’ perceptions to get more rounded evidence on the level of protection of each MPA,” said Veronica Relano, a Ph.D. candidate with The Sea Around Us and lead author of the study. “Our objective was to get an initial look into what MPAs are effective and which are ‘paper parks,’ meaning legally designated but not effective.”

In response to more than 3,000 emails Relano and her co-authors sent out to stakeholders, 41% provided information on the level of protection in their respective countries’ MPAs. Of those, 814 were asked to answer a one-question questionnaire similar to the service satisfaction polls travelers get when passing through some airports. The goal was that each respondent, independently of origin or background, could answer what they thought was the fishing intensity in an MPA in their country, with possible responses being “no fishing,” “light fishing,” “moderate fishing” and “very intense fishing.”

“If within a no-take MPA in which no fishing should occur, most of the respondents from the different stakeholder groups reply ‘moderate’ or ‘very intense fishing,’ we might be dealing with a potential paper park,” Relano said. “In contrast, if for a no-take MPA most of the respondents reply ‘light fishing’ or ‘no fishing,’ the confidence of having a de facto MPA is quite high.”

Once all responses were analyzed, the resulting information was incorporated into the Sea Around Us website and presented as country-level MPA pages. For most countries, one major MPA is presented in terms of its area, official designation, and effectiveness, as assessed in the published literature and via the questionnaire sent to local stakeholders.

“The method that we used here is the very first step to identifying potential ‘paper parks,’ which then would need further research to confirm or not the conclusions drawn from the stakeholders’ statements,” said Daniel Pauly, co-author of the study and The Sea Around Us principal investigator. “For now, the new product we are presenting provides a more comprehensive understanding of the conservation status of our oceans.” More information: Veronica Relano et al, Stakeholder Perceptions Can Distinguish ‘Paper Parks’ from Marine Protected Areas, Sustainability (2022). DOI: 10.3390/su14159655 Provided by Sea Around Us Citation: Local stakeholder involvement key to understanding protection level of marine protected areas (2022, August 9) retrieved 9 August 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-08-local-stakeholder-involvement-key-marine.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Researchers highlight the critical role of Ontario’s primary care providers during the pandemic

Primary care providers have a critical role to play in the pandemic – and improving access to that care is key, say researchers from the Ontario COVID-19 Science Advisory Table. The researchers released a three-part brief ( part 1 ,  part 2  and  part 3 ) this week detailing the work ...

View more: Researchers highlight the critical role of Ontario’s primary care providers during the pandemic

Modeling The Growth Process of Neurons

Modeling the growth cycle of a neuron is tricky, as neurons are formed for vastly different functions all over the body. However, every neuron begins its life in about the same way and goes through five distinct stages of development. A multi-disciplinary team of Carnegie Mellon University engineers led by ...

View more: Modeling The Growth Process of Neurons

Jay Mart eyes B30bn M&A deals in drive for growth

Mr Adisak, right, and Ekachai Sukumvitaya, deputy chief executive of Jay Mart, are present at the unveiling of the firm’s new brand identity with world “Jai”, or heart. SET-listed Jay Mart, a holding firm engaged in IT retail, finance and technology, aims to reach a 500-billion-baht market capitalisation by ...

View more: Jay Mart eyes B30bn M&A deals in drive for growth

OnlyFans founder invests in FITFCK, a dating app for gym-goers

Fitness dating platform FITFCK has received an undisclosed investment from Tim Stokely, the founder of content subscription platform OnlyFans. FITFCK says that the OnlyFans founder’s investment puts the business at a valuation of more than £3m. Jamie Wykes-Hobday founded FITFCK – pronounced “Fit-eff-see-kay” – after he was dumped by ...

View more: OnlyFans founder invests in FITFCK, a dating app for gym-goers

Mastercard Introduces Its Crypto Secure Service: Here's What You Should Know

Cryptocurrency is taking the world by storm, especially since many innovations now allow people to pay without having physical money on their person. It is still undeniable that cryptocurrency still has a lot of risks, especially since it runs on blockchains that are basically untraceable and not reliant on ...

View more: Mastercard Introduces Its Crypto Secure Service: Here's What You Should Know

OnePlus Buds Pro 2 leaked specifications hint at new color variant

The OnePlus Buds Pro 2 TWS earbuds’ full specifications have been tipped by a reliable tipster ahead of their official unveiling. OnePlus is reportedly prepping to take the wraps off its new true wireless earbuds. The upcoming audio device is likely to carry the OnePlus Buds Pro 2 moniker. The ...

View more: OnePlus Buds Pro 2 leaked specifications hint at new color variant

Taiwan IC design houses upbeat about automotive ICs in 2023

With cars getting more and larger on-board displays, Taiwan-based IC design houses are generally optimistic about demand for display driver ICs (DDI), touch and display driver integration (TDDI) and other automotive ICs in 2023, according to industry sources. Automotive central information displays and dashboards are being developed with larger ...

View more: Taiwan IC design houses upbeat about automotive ICs in 2023

Dell launches new security resources to enhance zero-trust adoption, cyber resilience

Dell announces several new cyber security resources including a Zero Trust Center of Excellence.

View more: Dell launches new security resources to enhance zero-trust adoption, cyber resilience

VMware embraces DPUs to stretch the use of CPUs

Tesla Moves Away from Ultrasonic Sensors For Tesla Vision

SpaceX Crew-5: NASA to send first Native American woman to space

Tenable aims to unify cyber security with exposure management platform

HR platform Humaans raises £13m with backing from Slack CEO

Amazon Pulls the Plug on Kids Interactive Gadget Glow

Loretta Lynn, country music luminary and songwriting pioneer, dies at 90

Apple Accepts TSMC Chip Price Hike for iPhone 15: Report

Xiaomi Band 7 Pro Officially Drops in Europe for Less than $100: Is the Budget Smartwatch Worth It?

Disney+ for PS5 Now Supports 4K HDR — Here’s How to Update

Even Moderate Exercise Can Greatly Increase Brain Size

Samsung Galaxy S23 series battery & camera specifications tipped

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News