logging down the value chain raises future forest sustainability concerns
Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain

Over a 50-year period, logging on British Columbia’s Central Coast preferentially targeted the highest value locations on the landscape, according to new research from Simon Fraser University. The systematic depletion of high-value components of the environment raises concerns about future sustainability and intergenerational access to natural resources.

Led by SFU Ph.D. graduate Jordan Benner and professor emeritus Ken Lertzman and published this week in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the research shows that, over time, harvesting operations moved to forest stands of increasingly lower productivity and accessibility, which they refer to as “harvesting down the value chain.”

“While the approach, sometimes known as ‘high grading,’ is economically efficient, it is contrary to many ideas about the stewardship ethics that are part of forest management,” says Benner. However, the cumulative effects of this historical pattern, combined with policy changes starting in the mid 1990s, led to shifts in the pattern of logging that reflect a more stewardship-oriented approach.

The research highlights the contrasting economic- and stewardship-oriented paradigms that are present in forest management—and how policy interventions to influence management play out on the landscape, and their importance for long-term sustainability.

“In forestry planning, it is important to understand and consider the unique attributes of residual high value old growth that represent increasingly rare ecological, economic, and cultural values,” says Benner. “We should be working to empower and support communities seeking equity and benefits from their landscapes, especially Indigenous communities that historically did not receive an equitable share of the value extracted from their territories.”

The patterns of forest management shown by Benner and Lertzman are similar to observations of serial depletion seen in fisheries and other natural resources, where lower-valued species replace those of higher value as they are used up.

“Humans have dramatically altered natural resources around the world through very specific patterns of consumption: we don’t harvest randomly, we tend to take first what is best or most economically efficient, leaving an ecosystem which is depleted in those components,” says Lertzman.

This has long-term consequences for landscapes and the people who depend on them. Benner notes that, “Indigenous communities are starting to gain a more meaningful role in forestry and natural resource decision making—a situation that is long overdue.

“But the long history of logging down the value chain has, in many areas, eliminated options for those decisions, for instance through the depletion of culturally important large cedar trees. If given a choice, I’m guessing that many of these communities would rather have the option to be making decisions about the higher value and more diverse cultural landscapes that existed in their territories before industrial exploitation.”

Productive, valley-bottom old growth forest plays special ecological and cultural roles in the landscape, Lertzman adds. “But in many areas, we lost most of this type of forest early on. One consequence is that our perception of what is the expected state has shifted—we tend to normalize this depleted condition in what is called a ‘shifting baseline’ phenomenon. However, we can’t understand the ecological context of our decisions today if we don’t recognize the history that led us here.” More information: Jordan Benner et al, Policy interventions and competing management paradigms shape the long-term distribution of forest harvesting across the landscape, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2022). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2208360119 Journal information: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Provided by Simon Fraser University Citation: Logging down the value chain raises future forest sustainability concerns (2022, October 5) retrieved 5 October 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-10-chain-future-forest-sustainability.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Disney Plus New Price, Pay More Or Deal With Ads

The global economic crisis keeps hitting every corner of the world. Almost everything is changing as far as price is concerned and Disney is no different from this. Watching videos on Disney plus will not be the same again. It is either you begin to see ads or you need ...

View more: Disney Plus New Price, Pay More Or Deal With Ads

These 2 Netflix series are dominating in the US today

It took a Netflix series documenting the lives of British royals to finally dethrone Wednesday, Netflix’s biggest hit of the year. Just 24 hours after the release of Part 1 of the highly anticipated docuseries Harry & Meghan — chock-a-block with fresh details about the relationship between the Duke and ...

View more: These 2 Netflix series are dominating in the US today

Air for disadvantaged LA residents is more polluted, more toxic

Graphical abstract. Credit: Environmental Science & Technology (2022). DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.2c02788 People dealing with the most socioeconomic disadvantages in greater Los Angeles also face higher levels of toxic air pollution, according to a new UCLA-led study. Researchers collected air samples from 54 locations over two-week periods in September 2019 and ...

View more: Air for disadvantaged LA residents is more polluted, more toxic

Structural studies offer 'how-to' guide for designing cancer drugs

By determining the three-dimensional structure of PI3Kα (shown), Scripps researchers paved the way toward drugs that target the protein in cancer cells. Credit: Scripps Research To design drugs that stall the growth of aggressive cancers, it helps to know the structures of the proteins that are revving the cancers’ ...

View more: Structural studies offer 'how-to' guide for designing cancer drugs

Surprise discovery set to improve drug development

Ketoprofen binding sites in HSA (PDB entry 7jwn). The 2mFo − DFc electron-density map (r.m.s.d. of 1.0 Å) is presented in blue and the mFo − DFc omit electron-density map (map calculated after ten REFMAC refinement cycles without the drug in the model, r.m.s.d. of 2.5 Å) is presented in green. ...

View more: Surprise discovery set to improve drug development

DT8 Pro is yet another smartwatch piece worth your attention

We have already seen quite some interesting smartwatch models from the DTNO.1 brand. And today we can take a look at yet another new piece from their collection. The DT8 Pro is situated a little lower than Ultra and Ultra+ siblings, but still it’s a very worthy watch for your ...

View more: DT8 Pro is yet another smartwatch piece worth your attention

A Schoolhouse Rock! tribute to honor the passing of its last surviving creator

George Newall, a former ad exec who co-created the influential series, has died at 88.

View more: A Schoolhouse Rock! tribute to honor the passing of its last surviving creator

BLUETTI Named As CES 2023 Innovation Awards Honoree

BLUETTI today announced that it has been named a CES® 2023 Innovation Awards Honoree for AC500 solar generator. This year’s CES Innovation Awards program received a record high number of over 2100 submissions. The announcement was made ahead of CES 2023, the world’s most influential technology event, happening Jan. 5-8 ...

View more: BLUETTI Named As CES 2023 Innovation Awards Honoree

Doogee S99 is Designed to Be the First Rugged Phone with 64MP Night Vision

What do we want of Playstation 6? Nothing less than a revolution!

A big step toward producing rhino gametes

Three techniques, three species, three different ways to fight drought

Experts urge COP15 policy makers to support research to find, catalogue, protect disappearing deep-sea species

New optical computing approach offers ultrafast processing

The New Moto G Play (2023) Packs a 90Hz Display for $169

Longitudinal field laser processing enabling high aspect ratio 10 nm features produced in sapphire

Satellite Reveals Larger Wheat Harvest in Ukraine Than Expected – And Barren Boundary of War

Parents: Don’t make your child the enemy. Build your relationship instead

Mint Mobile's Holiday Sale Scores You 3 Months of Service for Free

Greta Thunberg effect evident among Norwegian youth

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News