From Polestar 2 to Porsche Taycan, the cheapest, least powerful version is the one.

looking for a new ev? don’t get suckered by the top-of-the-line model

/ Our Creative Director didn’t know that I have a fondness for the Ford Ka and still miss the one I sold before moving to America, but I like that he chose one for this graphic. Aurich Lawson | Getty Images

As I look back on Ars’ automotive year and the new cars, crossovers, SUVs, and trucks that we drove in 2022, I have started coming to a conclusion of sorts. And it’s this: Forget the top-of-the-line, fully loaded, superduper electric vehicle; what you want is the least powerful, least expensive variant. And that’s true whether you want an EV because you want to drive something that’s very efficient or if you’re a driving enthusiast who’s going electric.

It’s a thought I’ve alluded to more than once this year, and the effect can be seen when you look at a pair of first drives that bookended this year: the Kia EV6 (which starts at $48,500 for the EV6 Wind) and the Kia EV6 GT (a hefty $61,400). The extra $12,900 buys you a much quicker 0–60 time, and a twin-motor, all-wheel drive powertrain with much more power. But the GT uses the same battery as the cheapest rear-wheel drive EV6, and with its bigger wheels it only has a range of 206 miles compared to the RWD EV6 Wind, which can do 310 miles on the same number of kWh.

OK, so score one for the hypermilers. And for the enthusiasts, I have to report that the cheaper car I drove in January was more fun on the back roads. Because it’s more fun to drive a slow car quickly than a quick car slowly.

A trip to learn about Porsche’s next EV platform also afforded us the opportunity to finally drive the base model Taycan. Better yet, I could drive it back to back with a Taycan Turbo over the same route. The base Taycan, which starts at a not-inconsiderable $86,700 for the 2023 model year makes do with just a single electric motor driving the rear wheels. With a nominal output of 321 hp (240 kW) and a peak output of 402 hp (300 kW), it still reaches 60 mph in 5.1 seconds.

By contrast, the Taycan Turbo starts at $153,300. That $66,600 premium boosts power to 616 hp (460 kW) or 670 hp (560 kW) when using launch control, and between the pair of electric motors that put down that power, there’s a larger 93.4 kWh battery pack versus the 78.2 kWh pack in the entry model. And the Turbo is blisteringly fast, with a top speed that’s 18 mph faster and a 0–60 time of just three seconds. But it’s also a far heavier car—5,119 lbs (2,322 kg) compared to the plain Taycan, which at 4,566 lbs (2,071 kg), is actually pretty light by EV standards.

It’s taken until now for me to get a chance to drive the entry-level Taycan and it was worth the wait. Jonathan Gitlin

The base Taycan makes do with a plastic dashboard, but it’s none the worse for that. Jonathan Gitlin

The Taycan Turbo is a devastatingly competent car, but does it really make you $66,600 happier than the plain one? Jonathan Gitlin

What you really notice driving the two cars back to back is the added mass over the front axle in the AWD Turbo, or conversely, the much lighter nose of the regular Taycan, the handling of which benefits as a result. It’s true that you don’t get as many luxurious trimmings in the cheaper car—the dash is made of unapologetic plastic, but plenty of Porsches have had unpretentious interiors. And the base model doesn’t come with an additional infotainment screen for the front seat passenger. Previously, I thought I’d be happy with a Taycan 4S, but now I know all I need is the single-motor version, and I’d be set. (And yes, I would take one over a 911 every day of the week now.)

Across OEMs, I keep finding the same pattern. At $48,400, the front-wheel drive Polestar 2 will deliver more smiles per dollar than one with two motors and the performance pack, which adds an extra $10,400 to the price tag. At least with Polestar’s business model, you won’t have to face an additional dealer markup on top of that.

This probably isn’t true for BMW EVs, but the truth is that the iX M60 that the company released this summer doesn’t really improve on the iX xDrive50. Even weighed down with a weekend’s glamping setup, the $84,100 iX xDrive50 is still too fast in sport mode if you have passengers on board who don’t appreciate having their heads slammed back into their headrests every time you crack the throttle. So the prospect of even more power and a more academic top speed (outside of Germany) doesn’t actually sound that appealing, particularly when it costs $108,900.

Or take Mercedes-Benz. Neither the EQS nor the EQE sedans are sports cars, and the less powerful versions are more efficient, cheaper, and don’t burden you with the garish hyperscreen—really three separate displays bonded under a single sheet of glass—when they can use Mercedes’ perfectly good 12.8-inch infotainment display instead. And while I’m at it, the smaller and lighter EQE would be my pick over the bigger, more powerful EQS.

There are exceptions to this theory. The Ford Mustang Mach-E comes immediately to mind here, because that car’s character was only properly unlocked in the Mach-E GT Performance Edition. The $75,895 Mach-E is so much better to drive largely because of its magnetorheological dampers, which finally imbue the car with some of the suppleness that characterized Ford’s best drivers’ cars, and Pirelli P-Zero tires that transform the feedback you get through the steering wheel. You could save enough to buy another car if you just went with the $46,895 entry Mustang Mach-E, but make that extra car a Mazda MX-5, because you’ll want something fun to drive to go with the EV.

Now that I’ve got that off my chest, it’s time to start persuading the product planners at basically every automaker that we don’t need to make full-length glass roofs a mandatory thing for the North American market, and it’s actually fine to have a metal roof that doesn’t let in the sunshine and cook the occupants during summer. But I fear that’s an uphill struggle.


3 Most Reliable Lexus Models

While there are a few automotive brands out there known for being reliable, one of the top companies with several durable models in its lineup is Lexus. Which vehicles are the top three for being reliable rides? Why does reliability matter? Lexus logo | Getty Images When you buy a ...

View more: 3 Most Reliable Lexus Models

The Cheapest New Dodge Charger Is a Versatile Sedan Option With One Big Issue

The Dodge Charger offers everything from a sensible V6 and all-wheel drive to supercharged tail-happy sports sedans. Better yet, the cheapest offering in the model’s lineup, the SXT, is versatile and well-suited for daily driving. However, the 2023 Dodge Charger SXT has one glaring issue: it’ll be the last car ...

View more: The Cheapest New Dodge Charger Is a Versatile Sedan Option With One Big Issue

Cheapest New Audi Is 1 of the Best Small Luxury Cars, Says Car and Driver

Audi has a solid lineup of luxury vehicles — with their good driving dynamics, premium features, and attractive designs. Also, compared to some other luxury brands, Audi models are relatively affordable. This includes the 2023 Audi A3 subcompact sports sedan, which is the cheapest new Audi car. Also, according to ...

View more: Cheapest New Audi Is 1 of the Best Small Luxury Cars, Says Car and Driver

GM Just Announced An All-New Small-Block V8 Is Coming

The electrification zeitgeist is in full swing, but gasoline-powered engines won’t disappear overnight. Nor will V8 power, as GM just confirmed a new small-block V8 engine is coming soon. This will be the sixth generation of the legendary small-block V8 that has powered so many Chevy and GM products since ...

View more: GM Just Announced An All-New Small-Block V8 Is Coming

Best car tool kits 2023

Whether you're looking for an emergency set of basic tools or something more comprehensive, a good tool kit can save you lots of stress – but who makes the best?...

View more: Best car tool kits 2023

The Lectron Adapter Will Let You Charge a Ford Lighting at a Tesla Station

Electric vehicle charging ports are mess. Some use one type developed in Europe, others use a Japanese system, and then Teslas use their own. But, what about those who have access to a Tesla charger, but want to charge something else, like a Ford F-150 Lightning? The Ford F-150 Lightning ...

View more: The Lectron Adapter Will Let You Charge a Ford Lighting at a Tesla Station

How Much Does a Nissan Tune-up Cost, and What Do They Do?

Keeping up with your Nissan‘s regular maintenance means you get optimal performance and fewer chances of major breakdowns. With that, you save on fuel costs and significant repairs and avoid the inconvenience of your car breaking down or stalling in the middle of the road. Naturally, tune-ups are a considerable ...

View more: How Much Does a Nissan Tune-up Cost, and What Do They Do?

How Does the New Corvette E-Ray Stack Up Against Hybrid Hypercars?

The new 2024 Chevrolet Corvette E-Ray isn’t just the latest stage in the Corvette’s evolution into a world-class supercar. Instead, it’s a reminder that the latest generation of plastic fantastic can punch well above its weight class. For instance, the new hybrid Corvette is quick enough to compete with several ...

View more: How Does the New Corvette E-Ray Stack Up Against Hybrid Hypercars?

4 Snow Plow Safety Tips When Encountering These Vehicles on the Road

Alpine is Coming to the U.S, but it’s Not Bringing the Goods

What’s the Toyota Highlander Hybrid Towing Capacity?

1990s GMC Typhoon: There’s Never Been an SUV That Can Beat It

Your 2022 Ford Maverick Might Have Faulty Airbags

This Older Porsche Infotainment Upgrade Helps Modernize Your 911 and Cayenne

Only 1 Type of Buyer Should Even Consider the 2022 Jeep Compass

3 Most Common GMC Sierra 1500 Problems Reported by Hundreds of Real Owners

5 Used Cars with the Biggest Price Drops

Incredibly Rare and Awesome Pontiac GTO Judge Sold for $1.5 Million

Is the 2023 Toyota RAV4 Too Old to Keep Up?

Carroll Shelby’s 100th Birthday Honored by Centennial Edition Mustang


Top Car News Car News