Loyal gamers extremely vulnerable to potential Microsoft monopoly, lawsuit says.


VIEW press / Contributor | Corbis News

About two weeks after the Federal Trade Commission filed a lawsuit to block Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision Blizzard, 10 gamers from California, New Jersey, and New Mexico have banded together to file a lawsuit against Microsoft.

Echoing many of the FTC’s concerns, the gamers are hoping to pressure and prevent Microsoft from closing “the largest tech deal ever in the video gaming market” and, thus, swallowing up its biggest competitor in the game industry.

In their complaint, plaintiffs describe Activision Blizzard as a crucial rival that drives industry-wide innovation and price competition. If the acquisition is allowed, the public could suffer loss and damages because Microsoft would supposedly wield more market power than it already has—suddenly granted “the ability to foreclose rivals, limit output, reduce consumer choice, raise prices, and further inhibit competition.”

Under the Clayton Antitrust Act, consumers have similar rights as industry competitors to oppose acquisitions like this one, allowing courts to weigh anti-competitive harms raised by consumers. The gamers are suing Microsoft for allegedly violating antitrust law, and are deeply worried that their favorite games could soon see prices spike, while games could decrease in overall quality. If the deal goes through, they allege that Microsoft would be positioned to hoard the best talent and most popular games to potentially gain “far-outsized market power.”

A Microsoft spokesperson told Ars that the gamers’ worst fears are not warranted.

“This deal will expand competition and create more opportunities for gamers and game developers as we seek to bring more games to more people,” a Microsoft spokesperson told Ars.

But the FTC seems to agree more with gamers, pointing in a press release to “Microsoft’s record of acquiring and using valuable gaming content to suppress competition from rival consoles.”

“Microsoft has already shown that it can and will withhold content from its gaming rivals,” Holly Vedova, the FTC’s Bureau of Competition director, warned in the press release.

Loyal gamers fear potential monopoly

The people suing bring a unique perspective to the debate over Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision, a deal that Microsoft hopes to close in 2023. In their complaint, they say that gamers are particularly vulnerable to price hikes because Microsoft knows that they’re unlikely to substitute other games for their favorites. That means Microsoft could take beloved titles— like Call of Duty games, which all plaintiffs play—and cut off access to platforms or services outside of Microsoft’s gaming ecosystem.

Microsoft already publicly stated that it would make Call of Duty available on rival consoles from Sony and Nintendo for the next 10 years. But like the FTC, plaintiffs say they’ve seen Microsoft make similar promises before, only to go back on their word once an acquisition is finalized, which it did with Starfield after acquiring ZeniMax Media in 2020.

Plaintiffs also argue that just because Microsoft promises to make a game available on other consoles or gaming systems, that doesn’t mean that it will be available at the same time, of the same quality, or have the same features and upgrades.

Consider, the complaint suggests, if Microsoft used popular Activision titles to boost its dominant position and push competitors out of the emerging cloud-based gaming market—essentially choking out competition in a market before it can even start to flourish. Likewise, any exclusive perks on massively popular games offered only within Microsoft’s gaming ecosystem could drive users away from competing platforms, with the complaint alleging that Microsoft could even “have the ability and incentive to engage in strategies to foreclose Sony.”

One way that game content quality could decrease, the complaint says, is through the gaming industry’s ongoing consolidations. The deal could place Microsoft in a position to attract all the best game developers, potentially starving independent game studios from accessing top talents. In this scenario, the complaint alleges that the industry could suffer from reduced wages, limited mobility, and worse working conditions—with Microsoft in a powerful position to set industry standards.

Ars could not immediately reach lawyers representing gamers suing, but the complaint says that plaintiffs believe that the better future for the gaming industry is one where Activision Blizzard continues existing as a separate market entity, stoking industry-wide competition as one of Microsoft’s only major rivals.

“The competition in the industry brought by Activision Blizzard must be preserved to ensure that the next generation of video game innovation and value are enhanced through competition, not stifled through consolidation,” their complaint states.

Gamers suing have asked a US federal court to declare that Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision Blizzard violates antitrust law. Following in the footsteps of the FTC, they’re fighting to ensure that the merger will be permanently blocked.


OPPO to walk in Samsung’s footsteps, develop its own smartphone processors

Apple, Huawei, and Samsung were the only smartphone brands that had their own mobile processors. Recently, Google started developing its own smartphone chipsets in partnership with Samsung’s System LSI division. While LG and Xiaomi did some work in the area, they never shipped mass-market products with their in-house processors. Now, ...

View more: OPPO to walk in Samsung’s footsteps, develop its own smartphone processors

Oppo Reno 8 review

A solid but uninspiring mid-ranger

View more: Oppo Reno 8 review

Oppo Reno 10 Pro+ to debut new design language

Oppo took years to change the design of the Oppo Reno series, but we finally saw a change with the Oppo Reno 8 series. After years of sticking with the same design of the Oppo Reno4, the company decided to change the look of its phones. In a world of ...

View more: Oppo Reno 10 Pro+ to debut new design language

Oppo Reno 10 Pro Plus might get a new camera module layout & upgraded display panel: Read on to know more

Tech giant Oppo recently launched its flagship Oppo Reno 9 Series in China. The series has 3 smartphones- Oppo Reno 9, Oppo Reno 9 Pro, and Oppo Reno 9 Pro+. While the brand is gearing up to launch the Reno 9 Series in India soon, the buzz around next ...

View more: Oppo Reno 10 Pro Plus might get a new camera module layout & upgraded display panel: Read on to know more

IC design houses cautious about Android smartphone shipments in 2023

With Samsung Electronics likely to adjust downward its smartphone sales goal for 2023, Oppo, Vivo and other China-based brand vendors are also expected to see their Android smartphone shipments disappoint next year, according to sources at Taiwan-based IC design houses. Samsung has already slashed orders for its Galaxy A-series ...

View more: IC design houses cautious about Android smartphone shipments in 2023

Oppo Find N2 Flip Global Spotted on FCC & Bluetooth SIG

After its Chinese release, the Oppo Find N2 series is inching closer to its global launch. It is evident thanks to the many certifications that it has gained recently including Bluetooth SIG and FCC among others. The Oppo Find N2 Flip recently made its appearance on the certification sites ...

View more: Oppo Find N2 Flip Global Spotted on FCC & Bluetooth SIG

Oppo Find N2 Flip global variant could launch pretty soon

Oppo dropped the Find N2 series in an event in China pretty soon consisting of Oppo Find N2 and Find N2 Flip. Now it is being said that Oppo is preparing to launch the Oppo find N2 Flip in the global markets too. The exact launch date of the ...

View more: Oppo Find N2 Flip global variant could launch pretty soon

OPPO K10 5G Starts Android 13 Public Beta Recruitment

The new Oppo Android skin based on Android 13, ColorOS 13.0 is already here. In order to meet the needs of more users for early adopters, OPPO K10 5G ColorOS 13.0 upgrade public beta version user recruitment is now open. The OPPO K10 uses a 6.59-inch 2412×1080 LCD screen with a ...

View more: OPPO K10 5G Starts Android 13 Public Beta Recruitment

After Samsung and OPPO, Huawei announces a cross patent deal with Nokia

Madison Square Garden uses facial recognition against legal opponent

OPPO phones will have better Bluetooth performance than Samsung’s

Samsung’s smartphone revenue witnesses a dip in Q3 2022

Oppo promises 4 OS and 5 years of security updates

OPPO will offer four Android updates to 2023 flagship smartphones

After OnePlus, Now Oppo Promises 4 Years of Software Updates

Samsung just got more competition in the software update game

OPPO to invest ~RM6.35 billion into OnePlus in new strategic partnership

After Samsung, OnePlus and OPPO are optimizing costs by working together

Oppo Find X6: what we want to see

OPPO Find X6 expected to feature triple 50MP cameras


Top Car News Car News