Montana Story is not a film about cowboys, cowgirls, shootouts, or the bloodied history of the American West. Instead, it’s a film about two estranged siblings who are brought back together when their father enters a coma and they are forced to begin saying goodbye to their family ranch. The kids are not ranchers, and neither was their father. As a matter of fact, one of the siblings even clarifies at one point in Montana Story that their father was never a rancher. He just bought the ranch because he liked the idea of it.

For those reasons, one may dispute Montana Story’s status as a contemporary Western. But the new film from writer-director duo Scott McGehee and David Siegel feels uniquely attuned to the draw and sorrow of the American West. The region’s history has been marred by bloodshed and thievery, but the expansive nature of Big Sky Country is still powerful enough to make it seem like the region’s forgotten promise of freedom is one that still exists.

That tension between the West’s unfortunate history and untethered, limitless rural sprawl is reflected in Montana Story. The film tells the story of Erin (Haley Lu Richardson) and Cal (Owen Teague) as they find themselves brought back together by their father’s impending death, but their reunion is weighed down by the violent tragedy that tore them apart in the first place. Like the very region they’ve found themselves in, Cal and Erin have to decide if they are going to come to grips with their tragic history and move on from it or let their reunion be the last chapter in their relationship.

Leaving the West behind

western, new movies, movie reviews, montana story, haley lu richardson

Bleecker Street, 2022

Once Montana Story actually forces Cal and Erin to begin reckoning with the fractured state of their relationship, the film manages to tell a largely compelling and emotionally engaging story. However, Siegel and McGehee’s script takes a bit too long to get going, with the duo prolonging Erin’s arrival in favor of establishing Cal’s various responsibilities and the instability of his father’s finances. Those early minutes are when the film’s attempts to tell a broader, socially relevant story are most clear, and they’re also when Montana Story’s languid pace is most evident.

Fortunately, Montana Story’s second half is considerably stronger than its first, and that’s thanks to the work done by Haley Lu Richardson and Owen Teague. The latter turns in a devastating, wounded performance as Cal. From the moment Richardson’s Erin shows up, Teague wears his character’s shame, regret, and loneliness on his sleeve, and during his inevitable disintegration in the film’s third act, Teague lays Cal’s self-loathing and desperation for forgiveness totally bare.

Opposite Teague, Richardson continues to prove herself to be one of cinema’s most luminous young performers. She turns in another stunningly assured performance as Erin, playing the character’s reservedness and anger with unwavering confidence right up until the moment when she is finally allowed to let her feelings of betrayal and sorrow spill out of her. Together, she and Teague manage to bring Montana Story’s tale of sibling estrangement to an emotionally satisfying and cathartic conclusion.

The film does take its time getting to that point though, and many may find its deliberately slow pace more frustrating than spell-binding. But Richardson and Teague’s uncompromising performances make up for many of the film’s pacing and plotting problems, and fans of the Western genre may find themselves surprised by Montana Story. It’s a film that, while lacking many of the genre’s visual symbols, is obsessed with many of the same themes that are at the center of some of cinema’s greatest Westerns — namely, the marks violence can leave not just on people, but also an entire region.

Montana Story hits theaters on Friday, May 13, 2022.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Kin’s Clare Dunne on Charlie Cox’s generosity & shooting during COVID

What would you do for your family? That’s the question asked repeatedly in the Irish crime drama Kin, and the answer is often accompanied by bursts of violence and dead bodies on the ground. Starring Daredevil‘s Charlie Cox as a recently released criminal hell-bent on revenge, the series stars some ...

View more: Kin’s Clare Dunne on Charlie Cox’s generosity & shooting during COVID

NASA captures ‘Sharkcano’ eruption where mutant sharks swim near an underwater volcano

You’ve probably heard of Sharknado, but have you heard of a Sharkcano? The Kavachi volcano in the Solomon Islands is an underwater volcano that was dubbed a sharkcano after a 2015 expedition discovered sharks living within it. Now, NASA has shared new satellite images of the latest sharkcano eruption, ...

View more: NASA captures ‘Sharkcano’ eruption where mutant sharks swim near an underwater volcano

This is the last selfie NASA’s InSight Lander will ever take

NASA’s Mars InSight Lander is counting down its final moments as dust continues to cover its solar panels. This week, the team behind InSight took the opportunity to capture one last InSight selfie. The resulting image is a stark contrast to the first or even second selfies that the lander ...

View more: This is the last selfie NASA’s InSight Lander will ever take

Thor: Love and Thunder trailer reveals Mjolnir’s new powers

The second Thor: Love and Thunder trailer is out, complete with a few exciting reveals. Trailer 2 gives us our first look at the Thor 4 villain, with Gorr the God Butcher (Christian Bale) showing up halfway through. We also get to see a few other gods and learn ...

View more: Thor: Love and Thunder trailer reveals Mjolnir’s new powers

Stranger Things 4 Volume 1 review: Changing up the formula

It’s beginning to feel like the residents of Hawkins, Indiana, just can’t catch a break. Over the course of three seasons of Stranger Things, the characters in the fictional town of Hawkins have dealt with child abductions, murders, and even a secret Soviet invasion — all while battling supernatural threats ...

View more: Stranger Things 4 Volume 1 review: Changing up the formula

How to watch Boeing Starliner return to Earth on Wednesday

After a successful launch and arrival at the International Space Station, Boeing’s Starliner is set to return to Earth this week. The capsule is expected to begin its descent back to Earth on Wednesday, May 25. If you’re interested in watching the action live, here’s what you need to ...

View more: How to watch Boeing Starliner return to Earth on Wednesday

5 suspenseful Netflix originals to stream now if you loved The Lincoln Lawyer

Ever since it hit Netflix two weeks ago, The Lincoln Lawyer has been dominating the charts. This original drama series is based on the same Michael Connelly novels as the 2011 movie starring Matthew McConaughey. David E. Kelley — creator of Ally McBeal, Boston Legal, and Big Little Lies ...

View more: 5 suspenseful Netflix originals to stream now if you loved The Lincoln Lawyer

Thor: Love and Thunder trailer 2 finally reveals Gorr the God Butcher

Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness had a somewhat annoying marketing campaign where Marvel tried to obfuscate the truth as much as possible. The trailers hid the villain in plain sight while also trying to conceal the reveal, and MCU fans who were oblivious to the leaks were ...

View more: Thor: Love and Thunder trailer 2 finally reveals Gorr the God Butcher

Waze finally adds Apple Music integration

Does Star Trek have a future on the big screen?

An asteroid 10 times taller than the Statue of Liberty is headed our way

Netflix unleashes an action-packed trailer for The Gray Man

How to Recover your Snapchat Streak

Take Your Tunes Anywhere With Over 50% Off the Oontz Angle Solo

Apple's Prehistoric Planet is everything I want Jurassic World Dominion to be (but never can be)

The Moon literally vanishes in this breathtaking lunar eclipse video

Noah Schnapp on Stranger Things and being an entrepreneur

The Gray Man trailer pits Gosling versus Evans in Netflix's thrilling spy movie

SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro Wireless review

Netflix can hold off Disney Plus until 2026, new research suggests

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News