musk-ruled twitter: users left to fight trolls and misinformation?
Elon Musk’s deal to buy Twitter for $44 billion raises concerns the platform will be subject to the capricious rule of the world’s richest person.

Elon Musk’s vow to let everyone say whatever they want on Twitter after his takeover of the social media giant could put the onus on users to combat bullying and misinformation on the platform, experts say.

Details of Musk’s plans for Twitter were slim after his deal to buy the tech firm was announced Monday, but the Tesla chief portrays himself as a free-speech absolutist.

But the privatization of Twitter with Musk as its master has raised concerns from analysts and activists thatthe site will be capriciously ruled by the world’s richest man, with more focus on attention and profit than on promoting healthy online conversations, which has been a priority at the service.

For Syracuse University assistant professor of communications law Kyla Garrett-Wagner, Musk’s takeover of Twitter is not a free speech rights victory.

“What we have done is put even more power into fewer hands,” she told AFP.

“If Elon Musk decides tomorrow that he wants to shut Twitter down for a week, he can do that.”

She noted the US Constitution’s first amendment only bars governments from gagging what citizens say—leaving the billionaire entrepreneur the power to decide what can and cannot be posted on the private entity of Twitter.

“This is not the street corner,” Garrett-Wagner said. “This is the proverbial Wild West but owned by a minority elite that doesn’t represent minority voices.”

‘The trolls take over’

Musk’s promised hands-off approach to content is a particularly thorny matter when it comes to high-profile cases like that of former US president Donald Trump, who was banned from Twitter after an assault on the Capitol by his supporters.

“Musk says he is going to turn Twitter into a social media platform with no moderation; there have been several of those and they don’t work,” said analyst Rob Enderle of Enderle Group.

“The trolls take over, they get too hostile and drive people away from the platform.”

Musk has said he is averse to banning people from Twitter due to misbehavior, prompting speculation that he would lift Trump’s ban.

But Trump on Monday said he would not be returning to Twitter even if his account were reinstated, saying he would stick to his own site, Truth Social.

musk-ruled twitter: users left to fight trolls and misinformation?
Allowing anyone to say anything on Twitter would put pressure on users and advertisers to take stands against misinformation and bullying.

App store trouble?

If Musk pulls back on policing content at Twitter, advertisers would also have to take the lead to ensure their messages were not associated with toxic content, according to advocates and academics.

“Accountability now rests with Twitter’s top advertisers, who need to make it clear that if Twitter becomes a free-for-all of hate, extremism and disinformation, they will walk,” said Media Matters for America chief Angelo Carusone.

“It is also critical that Google and Apple hold Twitter to the same standards they applied to other apps like Parler,” he added, referring to a social network popular among conservatives.

The tech giants would need to reiterate that “Twitter will not get special treatment and that a violation of their terms of service will result in the platform being removed from the app stores,” according to Carusone.

Musk will also face tough judgement in the court of public opinion, with Twitter users apt to turn away from the platform if it becomes hostile and flooded with misinformation, Garrett-Wagner said.

Some of Musk’s own tweets have raised eyebrows, as he once mocked a Tesla whistleblower and in 2018 called a rescue worker who criticized a plan to save children from a flooded cave in Thailand “a pedo guy.”

While Musk has talked about ridding Twitter of software “bots” that fire off spam, actually confirming that users are living people could prove challenging, Baird analyst Colin Sebastian told investors in a note.

Sebastian noted that Musk’s idea of charging for coveted blue check marks that verify users’ identities is a “no-brainer,” but it is likely only a small minority of people would pay for the status.

Musk has also said he believes anyone should be able to scrutinize the software behind the service.

But that kind of transparency could come with the unintended consequence that it will just be exploited by “bad actors” who find ways to game the system to promote their posts, analysts have warned.

“The rhetoric around transparency is that it will lead to an epiphany and people will change,” Garrett-Wagner said.

“It’s a misleading comfort to think everything will be okay if we know how it is working.”

© 2022 AFP

Citation: Musk-ruled Twitter: users left to fight trolls and misinformation? (2022, April 26) retrieved 26 April 2022 from https://techxplore.com/news/2022-04-musk-ruled-twitter-users-left-trolls.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

TECH NEWS RELATED

When should I buy my kid a Nintendo Switch?

Source: iMore As a parent or guardian in this day and age, it’s likely that you will be asked at some point to buy your kid(s) a Nintendo Switch. And although Nintendo is known for its family-friendly games and kid-friendly systems, it still may be a tough choice to decide ...

View more: When should I buy my kid a Nintendo Switch?

Experts Provide Online Data Protection Advice Following Roe v. Wade Overturn

(Photo : Photo by OLIVIER DOULIERY/AFP via Getty Images) Legal and information technology (IT) experts are debating how state-wide reproductive control laws would affect personal information protection following the overturn of the landmark Roe v. Wade case. Digital Evidence Is Still The Primary Documentation Used By Prosecutors in Violations of Reproductive ...

View more: Experts Provide Online Data Protection Advice Following Roe v. Wade Overturn

Being mindful can improve your interactions with co-workers, new study finds

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Although mindfulness originates within an individual, a Virginia Commonwealth University researcher has found the benefits do not end with this person. The real payoffs emerge when an individual’s mindfulness is translated into mindful interactions and relationships. Such interactions—infused with intentionality, compassion and presence—can bring about ...

View more: Being mindful can improve your interactions with co-workers, new study finds

Cooking up a conductive alternative to copper with aluminum

Aluminum is just one-third the price and weight of copper, but it is only about 60% as conductive. Aluminum’s relatively low conductivity can be a limitation in some real-world applications. Credit: Shannon Colson | Pacific Northwest National Laboratory In the world of electricity, copper is king—for now. That could ...

View more: Cooking up a conductive alternative to copper with aluminum

Redmi Note 11 finally gets Android 12 update

The Redmi Note 11 was released earlier this year with compelling mid-range specs and a fancy design. The device brought up the most recent version of Xiaomi’s MIUI skin, the MIUI 13 version. However, there was a big catch in the release. Xiaomi was not able to provide Android 12 ...

View more: Redmi Note 11 finally gets Android 12 update

Choose Your Own EK-Quantum, The Surface S360 Or Surface X360M

Are You Looking For Something Thick, Or Something Thin? EK-Quantum have updated their line of radiators for 2022 with their new Surface line, the Surface X360M and Surface S360.  The coolers both make use of three 120mm fans, just like the name implies, but they are different beasts.  The ...

View more: Choose Your Own EK-Quantum, The Surface S360 Or Surface X360M

First national guidelines established for integrated student support programs in K-12 schools

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain The first national guidelines to help K-12 schools create successful, cost-effective approaches to deliver integrated student supports that address both in- and out-of-school barriers to learning—from hunger, to mental health, to basic needs—have been released by a national working group convened by Boston College. With ...

View more: First national guidelines established for integrated student support programs in K-12 schools

Shimano 105 Goes Electric, Possibly Their Biggest Revamp Ever

Shimano 105, the component giant’s renowned third-tier road group, is undergoing possibly its greatest revamp yet, switching from mechanical to electronic and adding a 12th cog to the cassette for good measure. Shimano 105 Offers The Biggest Revamp to Electric Technology The 105 has long symbolized superb shifting performance at a low price, ...

View more: Shimano 105 Goes Electric, Possibly Their Biggest Revamp Ever

SpaceX's Starlink Satellite Broadband Is Speeding Up, Ookla Says

You Can Finally Afford to Buy a GPU Again

How the world's rivers are changing

The evolution of evolutionary developmental biology

Pokémon Unite medals: What do the medals mean?

7 Best Discord Chrome Extensions to Supercharge Your Experience

Enzyme of bacterial origin promoted the evolution of longhorned beetles

One step closer to fire-safe, recyclable lithium-metal batteries

Research team captures an elusive shadow: State-by-state gun ownership

MicroStrategy Buys The Dip! Adds $10 Million More in Bitcoin to Their Crypto Portfolio

Pokémon GO creator Niantic cancels four upcoming games, to cut up to 90 jobs

Subway Surfers Tag and HEROish are July's Apple Arcade Originals

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News