nasa may unlock future james webb space telescope data
The Cosmic Cliffs in Carina Nebula captured by the James Webb Space Telescope. (Image credit: NASA, ESA, CSA, and STScI)

Someday, you may be able to see fresh data from the James Webb Space Telescope as soon as the scientists who proposed gathering it do.

The James Webb Space Telescope (Webb or JWST) stunned the world in July, when scientists released the first science-quality images from the observatory. For now, however, the public are only allowed to see a fraction of the data the telescope is gathering. It’s a hot competition to snag time using the observatory, and the winners are rewarded with both the observations and a one-year head start on analyzing them under the current system. But NASA is considering changing that policy and opening fresh data from the $10 billion observatory to the world at large, and scientists are divided.

“It’s a quite controversial subject,” Alessandra Aloisi, head of the Science Mission Office at the Space Telescope Science Institute (STScI) in Maryland, which operates both JWST and the Hubble Space Telescope, told “Because there are pros and cons of both solutions.”

The debate stems from a directive the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy released in August stating that, by the end of 2025, research published based on federally funded data must make that data freely available right away. NASA is considering going one step further and requiring that all the data it funds be opened to the public without delay, so STScI has asked scientists to share their thoughts on the issue.

Making JWST data immediately public would build on, for example, astronomers’ use of the preprint server, where the public can read the latest scientific research for free, without an expensive journal subscription. “The whole astronomical community is going more and more toward open access,” Aloisi said.

But despite the steady stream of headlines about JWST observations, only about a quarter of the telescope’s planned observations for its first year are being released immediately, according to the magazine Science, with the remaining 75% locked away.

UnlockingJWST’s data right away could open new science to researchers who don’t have the resources to apply for observing time themselves, Aloisi noted. And scientists developing plans for new observations would have more existing data to work from earlier, potentially speeding up the scientific process.

After all, although discoveries themselves rely on actual data, someone has to have the idea to gather that data — and scientists generally want credit for their ideas. The one-year exclusive access period on JWST data is meant to be enough of a head start that the research team behind the proposal becomes the research team that publishes its findings first.

“The idea is that the people that got the scientific idea and got the data were allowed to have a period of time when they didn’t have to worry about being scooped or somebody else stealing the data and stealing their idea,” Aloisi said.

That exclusive time also gives astronomers the breathing room to do their analysis more carefully, another potential casualty of changing the data policy. “Some people claim it may result in lower quality science because people will rush to get it published before they’re scooped by somebody else,” Aloisi said.

nasa may unlock future james webb space telescope data

The James Webb Space Telescope’s imagery of NGC 628 (the “Phantom Galaxy”) shows glowing dust in this citizen science image.  (Image credit: NASA/ESA/CSA/Judy Schmidt)

Changing culture 

JWST observers will retain their one-year exclusive access for at least the next year and a half of observations, Aloisi said, since STScI has already begun accepting proposals for JWST’s second year of science, which will begin next July. In addition, NASA already has written agreements with its partners on the mission, the European and Canadian space agencies, that specify a one-year exclusive period. Any change to JWST data-handling procedures would require those agreements to be adjusted.

“It’s not going to happen overnight,” Aloisi said, and eliminating exclusive access altogether likely won’t happen in one fell swoop either. “My guess is that for JWST, it will be something more gradual than from 12 months to zero.” 

And STScI has precedent for making such policy changes with success, she said.

In 2018, the institute tested making scientists’ proposals to use Hubble anonymous in hopes of increasing the diversity in selected observers, despite concerns that astronomers wouldn’t be able to emphasize their personal experience in proposals, or that someone unqualified might manage to win time.

“Dual anonymous reviews — they were very controversial at the beginning, but the institute stuck to it, we figured out a way to do it, we implemented it, and now it has become the standard in how to review proposals,” Aloisi said.

And the institute has also adjusted the exclusive period for Hubble observations. When the telescope launched in 1990, scientists who had won time to use Hubble had a one-year head start, like JWST observers today. But the institute decided to halve that period to six months for observations beginning in late 2017, raising concerns from astronomers.

“Now we have done the transition, nobody remembers that,” she said. “It all goes smoothly as before.” She also noted that, while there isn’t a formal process for astronomers to register complaints about being scooped, the institute hasn’t seen an increase in informal reports.

Aloisi also believes that STScI can build a middle ground between a one-year exclusive period and immediate access, like developing a way astronomers can note in their proposal that they want to retain the exclusive period or instituting a policy that requires scientists publishing based on fresh data to offer the original proposal co-author status.

But the bigger need, she said, is to change the way astronomers behave.

“We need to create a culture where if we move toward open access data, that the members of the astronomical community are respectful of each other and don’t try to do the exact same science that other people are doing and they got the data to do,” she said.

Email Meghan Bartels at or follow her on Twitter @meghanbartels. Follow us on Twitter @Spacedotcom and on Facebook. 


Power on the Moon. What Will it Take to Survive the Lunar Night?

With the help of international and commercial partners, NASA is sending astronauts back to the Moon for the first time in over fifty years. In addition to sending crewed missions to the lunar surface, the long-term objective of the Artemis Program is to create the necessary infrastructure for a ...

View more: Power on the Moon. What Will it Take to Survive the Lunar Night?

Iwan Rhys Morus

Iwan Rhys Morus holds PhDs in the history and philosophy of science from the University of Cambridge. He has spent much of his career working on the history of science during the nineteenth century, including the development of new electrical technologies, the popular culture of science, and the history ...

View more: Iwan Rhys Morus

How do lie detectors work?

This article was first published on Big Think in October 2020. It was updated in December 2022. We all lie. Some might argue it’s human nature. In a 2002 study, 60% of people were found to lie at least once during a 10-minute conversation, with most people telling an ...

View more: How do lie detectors work?

How electricity stormed past steam and became the power of the future

Excerpted from HOW THE VICTORIANS TOOK US TO THE MOON, written by Dr. Iwan Rhys Morus and published by Pegasus Books. None of this happened by accident – and none of it happened as the result of acts of individual genius either. The business of electrification was a business, ...

View more: How electricity stormed past steam and became the power of the future

What is the true nature of our quantum reality?

When it comes to understanding the Universe, scientists have traditionally taken two approaches in tandem with one another. On the one hand, we perform experiments and make measurements and observations of what the results are; we obtain a suite of data. On the other hand, we construct theories and ...

View more: What is the true nature of our quantum reality?

Planetary Interiors in TRAPPIST-1 System Could be Affected by Solar Flares

In a recent study published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters, an international team of researchers led by the University of Cologne in Germany examined how solar flares erupted by the TRAPPIST-1 star could affect the interior heating of its orbiting exoplanets. This study holds the potential to help us ...

View more: Planetary Interiors in TRAPPIST-1 System Could be Affected by Solar Flares

SpaceX’s last Starlink launch of 2022 is a bit of a mystery

In a strange twist, SpaceX says that its next Starlink mission will launch 54 satellites into low Earth orbit (LEO), implying that they’re roughly the same size as the V1.5 satellites it’s already launching – not the larger V2 or V2 Mini satellites hinted in recent FCC filings. However, ...

View more: SpaceX’s last Starlink launch of 2022 is a bit of a mystery

Is Mining in Space Socially Acceptable?

Traditional mining has been subject to a negative stigma for some time. People, especially in developed countries, have a relatively negative view of this necessary economic activity. Primarily that is due to its environmental impacts – greenhouse gas emissions and habitat destruction are some of the effects that give ...

View more: Is Mining in Space Socially Acceptable?

“Mad honey”: The rare hallucinogen from the mountains of Nepal

Fred Hogge

The history of ice, one of the first luxuries

Astronomy 2023: Top Sky Watching Highlights for the Coming Year

Are humans wired for conflict? Charles Darwin vs. "Lord of the Flies" - Big Think

What was the biggest explosion in the Universe?

Canada takes boldest stance on electric vehicles yet

Despite the low air Pressure, Wind Turbines Might Actually Work on Mars

NASA Makes Asteroid Defense a Priority, Moving its NEO Surveyor Mission Into the Development Phase

Lightweight Picogram-Scale Probes Could be the Best way to Explore Other Star Systems

World’s biggest cultivated meat factory is being built in the U.S.

Ndidi Akahara


Top Car News Car News