[News Focus] Legal risks persist at Samsung as Lee’s trial continues

Samsung Electronics Vice Chairman Lee Jae-yong checks the company’s chip plant in Xian, China, in 2020. (Samsung Electronics)
Samsung Group’s de facto chief Lee Jae-yong attended a court hearing on Thursday as part of an ongoing trial on alleged irregularities surrounding his ascension to the helm of the South Korean tech conglomerate.

As always, the tycoon, who is serving a 2 1/2-year jail term over a previous bribery conviction, didn’t utter a single word throughout the full-day session held at the Seoul Central District Court, as his attorneys fought hard to fend off additional convictions. The charges brought against him include stock market manipulation, accounting fraud and breach of trust.

South Korean leaders have been mulling ways to release him early from jail. Samsung, whose exports of chips, display panels and tech products buttress the local economy, needs him back at its helm to navigate through a new global economic war raging over chip leadership, those calling for his early release say.

“A public consensus seems to be building on the need for Lee’s release,” Rep. Song Young-gil, leader of the ruling Democratic Party said recently, heightening the expectation for Lee’s release. The politician suggested granting him parole, if not a presidential pardon, to let him out.

While the right to grant a pardon lies solely with the president, a parole can be decided by the justice minister.

Pardoned or paroled, Lee won’t be completely free of legal risks.

He now faces potential imprisonment stemming from the suspicion that his inheritance of control over Samsung from his late father Chairman Lee Kun-hee was paved with illegality. Samsung has undertaken a series of equity transactions and activities after the senior Lee collapsed in 2014. This organizational scheme is known as Project G.

Thursday’s hearing, the fifth since the trial began on April 22, saw Samsung lawyers question the first witness, a former leader of Samsung Securities’ corporate M&A advisory team. The prosecutors had questioned the witness for the past two sessions last month.

The witness was involved in Project G at requests of Samsung’s former control tower Future Strategy Office, which included the controversial mergers of Samsung Everland with Cheil Industries in 2014 and Samsung C&T with Cheil Industries in 2015.

The prosecutors claim that the witness was deeply involved in the project and had been aware of the purposes of the mergers, which were planned entirely in the interest of facilitating Lee’s power inheritance.

Some emails written by the witness in 2014 and 2015 and some sent by former officials at Future Strategy Office, which were submitted to the court as evidence, showed that the former Samsung officials meticulously gauged the timing of business activities related to the transactions. The missives also detailed efforts that induced the 1:0.35 merger ratio for the Cheil and C&T merger.

The prosecutors asserted that all of the circumstances seem to be made with an ultimate goal of reinforcing the junior Lee’s grip on the Samsung empire.

Samsung’s legal representatives, on the other side of the fence, focused on inducing testimonies that the project was created for the overall stability of Samsung Group.

Regarding the Project G document submitted by prosecutors as a key piece of evidence, the witness said, “The report was written for the purpose of contributing to maintaining the overall competitiveness of Samsung Group.”

Mulling measures to maintain and stabilize the owner family’s leadership, including possible inheritance of the chairman’s stake in Samsung affiliates to the heirs, was only supplementary, he said.

To the question of “What did the word inheritance mean to you at the time?” the witness said, “It meant to me maintaining the group’s overall management rights of the large shareholders. And I did not think about issues of individual shareholders.”

Even if Lee is released, some say it is likely in August, either on a special pardon or parole, Samsung will still face leadership uncertainty stemming from Lee’s ongoing trial, industry watchers say.

Among others, the controversy over Lee’s employment status would continue, if he is released on the condition of parole.

Due to the bribery conviction, Lee is legally banned from being employed by the company in relation to his conviction for five years, according to the country’s Act on Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes.

If the Samsung leader is pardoned, he will not be restricted to the employment ban. 

[News Focus] Legal risks persist at Samsung as Lee’s trial continues

Lee checks out at products at Samsung’s plant in Vietnam in 2020. (Samsung Electronics)
Legal experts forecast that the ongoing trial on the leadership inheritance allegations would take three to five years for the court to make its first ruling.

Both sides have requested more than 250 witnesses for testimonies.

“It is difficult to say all of the legal risks on Samsung would disappear, if Lee is released,” said an industry source. “However, the current trial is about an issue that involves complex corporate financial affairs and business activities, which can be interpreted from multiple different perspectives, so there is room for contention.”

The problem extends further beyond Samsung. South Korean family-run conglomerates all face similar risks stemming from their owner family, experts said.

“Due to the prominent ownership-centered corporate governance in Korea, it is hard to block owners’ risks on their companies in general,” said Ahn Sang-hee, head of corporate governance team at Daishin Economic Research Institute. “Existence of owners is crucial for companies’ future business plans and strategies, although they do not actually play a role in everyday business activities.”

On the Samsung issue, Ahn said: “Because the semiconductor business is cycle-based, the owner’s role would be limited, but a long period of owner’s absence could be another risk for Samsung for its long-term business.”

By Song Su-hyun (song@heraldcorp.com)


Japan travel news, japan travel guides, japan holiday destinations and japan reviews

LATEST NEWS

NEWS RELATED

Windows 11 rumors flare anew with Windows 10 'retirement' set for 2025

October, 2025, will be the end of the line for Windows 10.

Read more: Windows 11 rumors flare anew with Windows 10 'retirement' set for 2025

Gamer nations: Apps cash in on country-sized player populations

TOKYO — More than 10 video game titles boast at least 100 million users worldwide, opening up lucrative secondary markets for in-game purchases that are larger than most nations. E3, one of the world’s biggest gaming conferences hosted in the U.S., opened this weekend as a virtual event after cancelling…

Read more: Gamer nations: Apps cash in on country-sized player populations

Japan to probe Apple, Google in antitrust discussions

Tokyo, Apple is set to face more scrutiny of its business practices as the Japanese government is said to be preparing another antitrust probe into both tech giants Apple and Google, the media reported.According to AppleInsider, Apple has been the subject of multiple antitrust probes alongside other tech giants, including…

Read more: Japan to probe Apple, Google in antitrust discussions

Nigeria's Twitter ban leaves some businesses in the lurch

LAGOS: Lagos-based entrepreneur Ogechi Egemonu was selling more than 500,000 naira ($1,219) worth of watches, shoes and handbags on Twitter per week. Now, with the site suspended by the Nigerian government, Egemonu does not know how she will cope. “Social media is where I eat,” she told Reuters. “I depend…

Read more: Nigeria's Twitter ban leaves some businesses in the lurch

Google opens up Workspace to consumers, announces new Spaces chat

Spaces looks a lot like, well, Teams and Slack.

Read more: Google opens up Workspace to consumers, announces new Spaces chat

Apple takes on AirPods Pro with $150 Beats Studio Buds noise-canceling earbuds

The newest Beats buds are smaller and cheaper versions of the AirPods Pro.

Read more: Apple takes on AirPods Pro with $150 Beats Studio Buds noise-canceling earbuds

Video game fest E3 shows off Starfield, Elden Ring teasers

LOS ANGELES (BLOOMBERG) – The annual video game trade show, the Electronic Entertainment Expo (E3), kicked off over the weekend with big announcements from Microsoft, Ubisoft Entertainment and Square Enix. The highlights included first looks at an upcoming Ubisoft game based on James Cameron’s Avatar movies and science-fiction game Starfield…

Read more: Video game fest E3 shows off Starfield, Elden Ring teasers

Social audio is set to have its YouTube moment, Clubhouse founders say

Mumbai: Clubhouse, an invite-only audio chat app launched on Android in India on May 21, has crossed the one million-downloads mark. On Monday, ET Now’s Nayantara Rai spoke with Clubhouse founders Paul Davison and Rohan Seth in their first TV interview together. Edited excerpts: ClubHouse became a global sensation after…

Read more: Social audio is set to have its YouTube moment, Clubhouse founders say

US Supreme Court revives LinkedIn bid to shield personal data

Japan vows at G-7 to cut off overseas coal financing this year

Convosight raises $9 million in funding from Qualgro, others

Covid-19 vaccine: C-CAMP partners Hitachi ABB for cold chain solutions

Global captives expected to ramp up hiring in small towns

Amazon India vendor Cloudtail faces Rs 56 crore tax demand: Report

iQOO Fold, iQOO Roll, iQOO Slide reportedly listed on Chinese trademark site

Carlos Ghosn pledges lengthy fight to clear his name

OTHER NEWS