Trump Facebook ban, trump, Congress, google, Big Tech, Vanderbilt University, section 230, upheld the suspension of Trump

Lurking beneath Facebook’s decision on whether to continue Donald Trump’s suspension from its platform is a far more complex and consequential question: Do the protections carved out for companies when the internet was in its infancy 25 years ago make sense when some of them have become global powerhouses with almost unlimited reach?

The companies have provided a powerful megaphone for Trump, other world leaders and billions of users to air their grievances, even ones that are false or damaging to someone’s reputation, knowing that the platforms themselves were shielded from liability for content posted by users.

Now that shield is getting a critical look in the current climate of hostility toward Big Tech and the social environment of political polarization, hate speech and violence against minorities.

The debate is starting to take root in Congress, and the action this week by Facebook’s quasi-independent oversight board upholding the company’s suspension of Trump’s accounts could add momentum to that legislative effort.

Under the 1996 Communications Decency Act, digital platform companies have legal protection both for content they carry and for removing postings they deem offensive. The shelter from lawsuits and prosecution applies to social media posts, uploaded videos, user reviews of restaurants or doctors, classified ads _ or the doxing underworld of thousands of websites that profit from false and defamatory information on individuals.

Section 230 of the law, which outlines the shield, was enacted when many of the most powerful social media companies didn’t even exist. It allowed companies like Facebook, Twitter and Google to grow into the behemoths they are today.

Republicans accuse the social media platforms of suppressing conservative voices and giving a stage to foreign leaders branded as dictators, while Trump is barred. Democrats and civil rights groups decry the digital presence of far-right extremists and pin blame on the platforms for disseminating hate speech and stoking extremist violence.

“For too long, social media platforms have hidden behind Section 230 protections to censor content that deviates from their beliefs,” Sen. Roger Wicker of Mississippi, the senior Republican on the Senate Commerce Committee, has said.

On this, Trump and President Joe Biden apparently agree. Trump, while president, called for the repeal of Section 230, branding it “a serious threat to our national security and election integrity.” Biden said during his campaign that it “immediately should be revoked,” though he hasn’t spoken about the issue at length as president.

Facebook, with a strong lobbying presence in Washington and a desire to have an input into any changes, has stepped out in favor of revisions to Section 230. Congress should update the 1996 law “to make sure it’s working as intended,” CEO Mark Zuckerberg has said. And he’s offered a specific suggestion: Congress could require internet platforms to gain legal protection only by proving that their systems for identifying illegal content are up to snuff.

Some critics see a clever gambit in that, a requirement that could make it more difficult for smaller tech companies and startups to comply and would ultimately advantage Facebook over smaller competitors.

Spokespeople for Twitter and Google declined to comment on the prospects for legislative action on Section 230 following the Facebook board ruling; a spokesperson for Menlo Park, California-based Facebook had no immediate comment.

The decision announced by the Facebook oversight board upheld the suspension of Trump, an extremely rare move that was based on the company’s conclusion that he incited violence leading to the deadly Jan. 6 Capitol riot. But the overseers told Facebook to specify how long the suspension would last, saying its “indefinite” ban on the former president was unreasonable. The ruling, which gives Facebook six months to comply, effectively postpones any possible Trump reinstatement and puts the onus for that decision squarely back on the company.

Trump was permanently banned after the riot from Twitter, his favored bullhorn. But it was Facebook that played an integral role in both of Trump’s campaigns, not just as a way to speak to his more than 32 million followers but also as a fundraising juggernaut driving small-dollar contributions through highly targeted ads.

Critics of Facebook generally saw the oversight board’s ruling as positive. But some view the board as a distraction by Facebook to skirt its responsibility and to stave off action by Congress or the Biden administration. What must be addressed, critics insist, are the broader problems for society from the fearsome power, market dominance and underlying business model of Facebook and the other tech giants _ harvesting data from platform users and making it available to online advertisers so they can pinpoint consumers to target.

That’s where the debate over changes to Section 230 comes in, as a key area for new regulation of social media.

Gautam Hans, a technology law and free-speech expert and professor at Vanderbilt University, said he finds the board to be “a bit of a sideshow from the larger policy and social questions that we have about these companies.”


Japan travel news, japan travel guides, japan holiday destinations and japan reviews

LATEST NEWS

NEWS RELATED

Google-Jio and Google's smartphone -'JioPhone Next' to launch on September 10

Reliance Jio will launch its Android-based smartphone called Jio Phone Next, a result of its partnership with Google, on September 10. “JioPhone Next is a fully featured smartphone, supporting the entire suite of applications from both Google and Jio as well as the android smartphone through which users will have…

Read more: Google-Jio and Google's smartphone -'JioPhone Next' to launch on September 10

What Google CEO Sundar Pichai said about JioPhone Next

Reliance Jio announced its first smartphone JioPhone Next at its annual general meeting today. The smartphone — developed in partnership with Google — will be available starting September 10. Google CEO Sundar Pichai spoke at the meeting about the JioPhone. Pichai said, “our vision was to bring affordable access to…

Read more: What Google CEO Sundar Pichai said about JioPhone Next

Reliance AGM 2021: JioPhone Next launched as world's most affordable 4G smartphone

Google and Jio teams have jointly developed the JioPhone Next, which is a fully-featured 4G smartphone supporting the entire suite of applications from both Google and Jio. Reliance Jio on June 24 launched a new affordable 4G smartphone at the RIL 44th AGM. With Google, Reliance Jio has developed the JioPhone…

Read more: Reliance AGM 2021: JioPhone Next launched as world's most affordable 4G smartphone

Ambani announces JioPhone Next, the 'most affordable smartphone in the world'; powered by Google

Mukesh Ambani announced a new JioPhone, the JioPhone Next – ‘the most affordable smartphone not only in India, but also worldwide’. It will be available in the market from Ganesh Chaturthi, 10th September. “Our vision was to bring affordable access to information for Indians in their own language, to build…

Read more: Ambani announces JioPhone Next, the 'most affordable smartphone in the world'; powered by Google

Reliance Jio to partner Google Cloud for 5G, says Thomas Kurian

New Delhi: Credited with turning around Google Cloud within two years of taking over at the helm, the Indian origin CEO of Google Cloud, Thomas Kurian, says that the partnership with Reliance Jio is “marque” and one which will help the company get scale quickly and eventually lead to profitability.…

Read more: Reliance Jio to partner Google Cloud for 5G, says Thomas Kurian

Reliance announces JioPhone Next with Google’s 'light' Android OS

Reliance Industries Limited chairman and managing director Mukesh D Ambani at the 44th Annual General Meeting announced a new affordable smartphone called JioPhone Next. Reliance has partnered with Google for this affordable smartphone aimed at helping 2G feature phone users to upgrade to an Android smartphone. The JioPhone Next uses…

Read more: Reliance announces JioPhone Next with Google’s 'light' Android OS

Deutsche Bank partners with Oracle to simplify its IT systems, cut costs

Deutsche Bank has tapped software firm Oracle to simplify its information technology systems, enabling Germany’s top lender to cut costs by several hundred million euros, a Deutsche Bank board member said. Deutsche Bank has spent years modernising its computer systems that have repeatedly caused headaches and which former CEO John…

Read more: Deutsche Bank partners with Oracle to simplify its IT systems, cut costs

Brave browser takes aim at Google with its own search engine

Brave, a rival to Google Chrome in the browsing space, is gearing up to take on the tech behemoth in another area — search engine. Brave has announced Brave Search’s public beta, which is now available to users across the world. The browser has been focusing on privacy and Brave…

Read more: Brave browser takes aim at Google with its own search engine

Google removes Bolo Indya from Playstore on copyright complaint from T-Series

Google drops engineering residency after protests over 'inequities'

RIL 2021 AGM today: Timings and what shareholders may want Mukesh Ambani to talk in his speech

Google is making these YouTube videos private next month: What this means for users and creators

US House panel approves increase in antitrust enforcement budgets as Microsoft dodges the worst of Big Tech scrutiny

AI tackles workload management challenges in the data centre

US House floats antitrust bills aimed at Big Tech

US House panel to take up Big Tech antitrust bills amid vociferous criticism

OTHER NEWS