Pakistan's draconian proposed press law stirs controversy

ANKARA — Pakistan is trying to push through a new law intended to centralize government oversight of the media, fueling concerns about further deterioration of press freedom in the South Asian country.

According to the World Press Freedom Index compiled annually by Reporters Without Borders in France, Pakistan’s ranking has dropped since Prime Minister Imran Khan came into office from 139 in 2018 to 145 in 2021.

Pakistan’s media already face major financial pressures, including salary cuts, late payments and redundancy. Critical journalists continue to be censored, harassed, trolled, prosecuted on flimsy grounds and even physically assaulted.

The government recently proposed the Pakistan Media Development Authority (PMDA) as a regulator to oversee print, electronic and digital media that are currently under the purviews of over a dozen government bodies and subject to myriad laws and regulations.

At present, the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority oversees electronic media while the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority and Pakistan Federal Investigation Agency take care of social media and cyber crime.

In a May 19 document, the government termed the existing framework “fragmented” and “fractured.” It said a “new arrangement has become necessary,” and called for an authority with the power to make its own rules and regulations and to prosecute alleged violators. All existing media laws will be subject to review and possible consolidation.

Press associations, rights organizations, media groups and political parties have condemned the proposed body on the grounds that it would institutionalize censorship and undermine independent reporting.

Pakistan's draconian proposed press law stirs controversy

Journalist Asad Ali Toor spoke out over violence against his profession at the May 28 demonstration in Islamabad after being the recent victim of an assault by three unidentified men. There was speculation that the attack stemmed from his reports on Pakistan’s powerful military. © AP

In a joint statement on May 28, the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ), the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, and the Pakistan Bar Council described the proposed law as “draconian.” They said it was “nothing less than imposing media martial law,” and will “destroy all public media as it exists in Pakistan today.”

Among others, the All Pakistan Newspapers Society, the Pakistan Broadcasters Association, and the Council of Pakistan Newspaper Editors “totally rejected” the “unconstitutional” law put forward, saying that it “has no place in a democratically elected dispensation.”

In a shared statement, they said the proposed regulator is “intended to hinder media freedoms.” They predicted the move will be resisted at all levels including in court, and said protests and advertising campaigns will be used to raise public awareness.

According to a draft of the proposed ordinance — a legislative order that can be implemented by the president for 120 days and extended only once for the same period — the consolidated media authority will regulate the establishment and operation of all branches of media, including print, digital, electronic and film. Media organizations will all need licenses to operate.

The authority will not be required to give prior notice of its actions, and have the power to suspend any platform with content deemed to be “against the ideology of Pakistan,” or likely to create hatred among the people, disturb peace and tranquility, endanger national security, or that is deemed “obscene, vulgar or pornographic.” It will also be able to seize studio equipment and inspect and seal media premises.

Convictions come with jail terms of up to three years and fines reaching 25 million Pakistan rupees ($160,000), or both.

There is scope for appeal to a tribunal, but only the supreme court will be empowered to rule on the legality of decisions taken under the law. A Media Complaints Council will also be established to review public complaints against media platforms.

Aftab Alam, the executive director of the Islamabad-based Institute of Research Advocacy and Development, said restructuring the entire sector without involving parliament and consulting other stakeholders “is ultra vires to the fundamentals of democratic process.” He strongly objected to the government having arbitrary powers to appoint or remove members of any regulator, tribunal or complaints commission.

“The government must not assume the role of judge, jury and executioner,” he told Nikkei Asia. “An independent regulator consisting of sector experts, human rights champions, literary personalities and technical experts must perform in a participatory, transparent and fair manner.”

Usama Khilji, the director of Bolo Bhi, a digital rights advocacy group, called the proposed ordinance “anti-democratic and unconstitutional by virtue of undermining press freedom and the right to information of citizens.”

“This signifies the intent of the state to clamp down on freedom of expression, especially on the internet to control criticism,” Khilji said.

For Nighat Dad, head of the Digital Rights Foundation, the new licensing regime will have a chilling effect on the budding digital media economy. “Digital media outlets lack the resources of major newspapers and electronic media channels, and cannot be subject to the same onerous requirements as the others,” she said.

The government remains resolute but has also shown some willingness to engage with stakeholders. In a press encounter on June 5, Chaudhry Fawad Hussain, the minister for information and broadcasting, said any new media law will be introduced in consultation with both the opposition and representatives of the media.

Pakistan's draconian proposed press law stirs controversy

Chaudhry Fawad Hussain, Pakistan’s minister for information and broadcasting, makes his case to reporters on June 5 in Lahore. (Photo courtesy of Press Information Department)

“There is a consensus over the need to amend the existing laws and regulate social media,” he said in Lahore after meeting with officials of the Council of Pakistan Newspaper Editors. “We do not want to compromise on the rights of media workers.”

Farrukh Habib, the junior minister of state for information and broadcasting, said in a recent TV interview that the new regulatory structure would provide greater job security to journalists and safeguard press freedom. He said the coming of the digital media era has made new forms of regulation necessary. “It’s not coming through an ordinance — I am very clear on that,” he said of the PMDA proposal.

Javed Jabbar, a former information minister, agreed that there is a need for content regulation to keep pace with technological advances and to counter the proliferation of false information, but said this should not be done through a government-sanctioned media authority.

“There should be state regulation, self-regulation and social regulation,” Jabbar said, noting that at least 64 media-related laws are in place, some of which predate Pakistan’s independence in 1947. “They need to be updated and modernized after a review,” he said.

Mazhar Abbas, a senior journalist and former PFUJ office bearer, said it will be difficult for the government to move ahead after being rejected so unanimously. “I think they will defer it for now,” he said, expressing doubts about the underlying rationale. “If each media type is governed by separate laws, why do we need centralized control?” he asked.


Japan travel news, japan travel guides, japan holiday destinations and japan reviews

LATEST NEWS

NEWS RELATED

1More ComfoBuds Pro earbuds review: Good audio offering in its price range

1MORE ComfoBuds Pro One of the main issues many users have with true wireless earbuds is that they are uncomfortable to wear for long hours. Unfortunately, only a handful of brands work towards providing a comfortable fit without sacrificing the audio quality or features. 1More is one of those brands,…

Read more: 1More ComfoBuds Pro earbuds review: Good audio offering in its price range

S. Korea to develop over 100 mini satellites by 2031

SEOUL, June 18 (Yonhap) — South Korea said Friday it will develop over 100 miniature satellites over the next decade with the aim of establishing a national security monitoring system and testing next generation network communications in its latest push to strengthen its space industry. The Ministry of Science and…

Read more: S. Korea to develop over 100 mini satellites by 2031

China's Realme to expand India production despite COVID surge

TAIPEI — Chinese smartphone maker Realme is expanding production in India despite a surge in COVID-19 cases there in an effort to capture local demand and extend its supply chain outside its home market. Realme plans to begin assembling wireless earbuds in the South Asian country in the next three…

Read more: China's Realme to expand India production despite COVID surge

Meet Satya Nadella, Chairman and CEO, Microsoft: 10 things about his rise from a young engineer to chairman

Satya Nadella, who was named the chairman of Microsoft on June 16, was born in Hyderabad on August 19, 1967. He graduated from Manipal Institute of Technology, Karnataka in 1988 as an electrical engineer. He then earned his master’s degree in Computer Science at the University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee, the US…

Read more: Meet Satya Nadella, Chairman and CEO, Microsoft: 10 things about his rise from a young engineer to chairman

Tencent-backed Zhuanzhuan nets $100m from Xiaomi, Shunwei, others

Photo: Pixabay Zhuanzhuan, backed by New York-listed Chinese online classifieds marketplace 58.com, has secured a total of $100 million in its Series D1 round of funding led by Chinese smartphone conglomerate Xiaomi.  Zhuanzhuan, headquartered in Beijing, is an online marketplace on which users can buy and sell second-hand goods. It…

Read more: Tencent-backed Zhuanzhuan nets $100m from Xiaomi, Shunwei, others

Hanwha, SPC to co-develop biodegradable plastic packing material

Hanwha Compound CEO Oh Sae-won (right) and SPC Pack CEO Kim Chang-dae sign an agreement to co-develop biodegrable plastic packing material at Hanwha Solutions Chemical Division Research and Development center on Thursday. (Hanwha Solutions) Hanwha Solutions said Friday that its wholly-owned subsidiary Hanwha Compound has signed an agreement with SPC…

Read more: Hanwha, SPC to co-develop biodegradable plastic packing material

LG Electronics’ US headquarters receives highest grade for green building

LG Electronics’ North American headquarters in New Jersey was certified as green building by the US Green Building Council (LG Electronics)LG Electronics’ North American headquarters in New Jersey has been granted an eco-friendly certification from the US Green Building Council, according to the company’s newsroom Friday. At the USGBC Leadership…

Read more: LG Electronics’ US headquarters receives highest grade for green building

Mitsubishi unit expands US logistics reach in $2.9bn deal

TOKYO — Mitsubishi HC Capital is to buy U.S. transportation finance company CAI International in a $2.9 billion deal. “We have decided to make this acquisition in order to strengthen our ‘global assets’ which are one of our focus areas,” said MHC in a statement issued on Friday. MHC will…

Read more: Mitsubishi unit expands US logistics reach in $2.9bn deal

S.Korea to accelerate carbon-neutral efforts through smart water management

India: Max Financial promoters sell shares worth $105m

Chinese apps could face subpoenas or bans under Joe Biden order: Sources

US FCC votes to advance proposed ban on Huawei, ZTE equipment approvals

Google CEO Sundar Pichai surprises Doodle for Google contest winner with a video call; rewards $30,000 prize

Kakao T officially registered as transportation operator

Apple awards grants for computer chip courses to historically Black schools

Apple gains market share in China as smartphone market declines

OTHER NEWS