Ralph Nader, a political and consumer advocate and former presidential candidate, has issued a statement calling Tesla’s “so-called” full self-driving (FSD) technology “one of the most dangerous and irresponsible actions by a car company in decades.”

Nader is calling on the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) to use its safety recall authority to order that FSD technology be removed in every Tesla. Per CEO Elon Musk’s recent statements, that’s about 100,000 vehicles.

The author of the bestselling book “Unsafe at Any Speed,” which criticized the American auto industry, cited research that found FSD malfunctions every eight minutes. That research was published in January by The Dawn Project, an organization aiming to ban unsafe software from safety-critical systems, which analyzed data from 21 YouTube videos of Tesla owners using FSD beta software.

“This nation should not allow this malfunctioning software which Tesla itself warns may do the ‘wrong thing at the worst time’ on the same streets where children walk to school,” wrote Nader. “Together we need to send an urgent message to the casualty-minded regulators that Americans must not be test dummies for a powerful, high-profile corporation and its celebrity CEO. No one is above the laws of manslaughter.”

Nader’s callout comes as Tesla is gearing up to release the next version of its FSD software, version 10.69, on August 20. Musk tweeted out the announcement, saying nothing about the next iteration’s capabilities other than: “This release will be big.” During Tesla’s Q2 earnings call, Musk also said Tesla would increase the price of the software and that the automaker was hoping to “solve full self-driving” by this year.

Really, Nader should be targeting Tesla’s Autopilot, as well. Tesla and Musk have been adamant in the past that FSD has not been responsible for any crashes or deaths. (However, a recent YouTube video from AI Addict shows a Tesla in FSD mode colliding with a bike lane barrier post.) Autopilot, on the other hand, has likely been the cause of several crashes. NHTSA is currently investigating 16 crashes in which Tesla owners were potentially engaging Autopilot and then crashed into stationary emergency vehicles, resulting in 15 injuries and one fatality. Since 2016, there have been 38 special investigations into crashes involving Tesla vehicles, of which 18 were fatal.

Other automakers have come out with similar ADAS technology, and based on NHTSA’s recent ADAS crash report, appear to have far fewer crashes. It’s difficult to compare how dangerous Tesla’s technology is in relation to its rivals, in part because there are far more ADAS-equipped Teslas on the road than any other vehicle.

NHTSA did not respond immediately for a request for comment.

In a pair of July 28 filings, the California Department of Motor Vehicles accused Tesla of false advertising to promote its Autopilot and FSD technologies — both of which are advanced driver assistance systems and do not provide full autonomous driving. While Tesla’s website states that “the currently enabled features require active driver supervision and do not make the vehicle autonomous,” the DMV told the Los Angeles Times that the disclaimer “contradicts the original untrue or misleading labels and claims, which is misleading, and does not cure the violation.”

The California DMV also said earlier this year that it was revisiting its approach to regulating Tesla’s autonomous vehicle technology, as the agency does with every other company that claims to pursue full self-driving and does public road testing. Tesla has gotten away without reporting crashes and system failures to the DMV for so long because its systems fall under the ADAS category, which requires a human driver must be present. However, after reviewing dozens of videos showing “dangerous use” of that technology — and such use is informed by the way Tesla and its CEO Elon Musk speak about the technology — the DMV decided to reevaluate.

This reevaluation is ongoing, and the DMV told TechCrunch it could not comment until it is complete. That said, based on the DMV’s most recent claims that Tesla is falsely advertising, Tesla could be facing revocation of its licenses to make or sell its cars in California, in the worst case. That probably won’t happen, but if it did, it would spell trouble for the EV maker. California is home to Tesla’s most loyal buyer base.

Musk has had a fraught relationship with the state ever since May 2020, when Alameda County ordered Tesla to shutter its Fremont factory to stop the spread of COVID. In October last year, Musk announced Tesla would be moving its headquarters to Austin, Texas.

The celebrity executive has also repeatedly underlined the importance of FSD to the company, saying in June that without it, Tesla is “worth basically zero.” It is likely based on the belief by many, including Nader, that FSD is not what it’s cracked up to be. Nader went on to tweet Wednesday that Tesla’s stock is vastly overvalued.

“Tesla and @elonmusk exposed the technological stagnation of the auto companies and broke ground with EVs and other climate-benign technologies,” tweeted Nader. “However, a fast moving company can not obscure wildly speculative stock valuation on top of a general stock market bubble that could implode on pension and mutual fund savings of millions of Americans. Fundamentals can’t be ignored.” 

TECH NEWS RELATED

Tata Safari Storme 1 lakh km service: 2 important updates

I lubed everything while putting everything back, every bolt every contact, but I’m sure it will have to be opened once again in my ownership. BHPian viXit recently shared this with other enthusiasts. The first two jobs are done on the car after crossing 1L km Wiper linkage service ...

View more: Tata Safari Storme 1 lakh km service: 2 important updates

Car Sales Sep 2022 – Maruti, Hyundai, Tata, Mahindra, Kia, VW, Skoda

Maruti Suzuki takes the lead like clockwork and registers triple digit growth YoY with the highest share of the market New Mahindra Scorpio Car Sales Sep 2022 shed light as to how a manufacturer fares in the segment when compared to other manufacturers. Being the largest PV maker of the ...

View more: Car Sales Sep 2022 – Maruti, Hyundai, Tata, Mahindra, Kia, VW, Skoda

Alfa's new baby! 2023 Alfa Romeo Tonale price and specs: New small SUV to rival Audi Q3, Volvo XC40 and Mercedes-Benz GLA

The Alfa Tonale is set to go head to head with small SUVs like the Audi Q3, Volvo XC40, and Mercedes GLA. Alfa Romeo’s long-awaited new SUV, the Tonale, is now available to order in Australia with pricing for its two-variant range now confirmed. Set to arrive in Australian ...

View more: Alfa's new baby! 2023 Alfa Romeo Tonale price and specs: New small SUV to rival Audi Q3, Volvo XC40 and Mercedes-Benz GLA

CarSifu Auto Show is back with the latest and greatest

File pic of CarSifu Auto Show. Check out some of the most popular cars on sale in one spot, starting tomorrow. Vroom power: Visitors to the auto show beginning tomorrow can get up close with some of the latest additions to the line-up of Volvo, Toyota, Subaru, Proton, Honda, ...

View more: CarSifu Auto Show is back with the latest and greatest

Maserati unveils new GranTurismo, its first fully-electric model

The electric GranTurismo. MILAN: Maserati, the luxury brand of carmaker Stellantis, unveiled on Monday its new GranTurismo model ahead of an official launch scheduled next year for the brand’s first car available in a fully-electric version. Maserati, which returned to an operating profit last year, has promised fully-electric – ...

View more: Maserati unveils new GranTurismo, its first fully-electric model

SpaceX has spent ~$80M on Starlink support for Ukraine thus far

SpaceX has spent about $80 million on Starlink support in Ukraine since it started helping the country in its war with Russia.  The SpaceX CEO has received backlash recently for his Ukraine-Russia peace plan. Elon Musk tweeted the monetary value SpaceX has provided to Ukraine to reaffirm his company’s— ...

View more: SpaceX has spent ~$80M on Starlink support for Ukraine thus far

Market Insight: Ute underdogs crack top ten

Doing Great: GWM has quickly secured a share of Australia's second-most popular new-vehicle segment – 4x4 utes.

View more: Market Insight: Ute underdogs crack top ten

2023 Ford E-Transit electric van review: First drive

7.8/10Score Score breakdown 7.5 Comfort and space 7.5 Engine and gearbox 8.0 Ride and handling 8.0 Technology Things we like Excellent drivability and ride, uncompromised load space Clever range boosting features Uncompromised load space Not so much Load test will have to wait It all comes down to the numbers… ...

View more: 2023 Ford E-Transit electric van review: First drive

3 Jeep Wrangler Alternatives That Aren’t a Ford Bronco

Tata Motors launches Tiago electric hatch priced at $16,000

BYD hits new production record as Atto 3 prices rise, for some

Ford E-Transit 2023 review

Ford Bronco Raptor 2023 review

Maserati gives the lowdown on all-electric Gran Turismo Folgore

How to watch the 2022 Bathurst 1000

Alfa Romeo Tonale arrives from $49,900

5 Steps to Take When Your Car Is Totaled

Extended Suzuka FP2 for Pirelli F1 tyre test

Here’s What You’ll Pay for the 2023 Hyundai Tucson Hybrid

Jangan Elak Bayar Tol Kalau Anda Tak Nak Menyesal

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News