climate, cop26, climate change
The study purports to review data on possible changes in the frequency or intensity of rainfall, cyclones, tornadoes, droughts and other extreme weather events.

A fundamentally flawed study claiming that scientific evidence of a climate crisis is lacking should be withdrawn from the peer-reviewed journal in which it was published, top climate scientists have told AFP.

Appearing earlier this year in The European Physical Journal Plus, published by Springer Nature journal, the study purports to review data on possible changes in the frequency or intensity of rainfall, cyclones, tornadoes, droughts and other extreme weather events.

It has been viewed thousands of times on social media and cited by some mainstream media, such as Sky News Australia.

“On the basis of observation data, the climate crisis that, according to many sources, we are experiencing today, in not evident,” reads the summary of the 20-page study.

Four prominent climate scientists contacted by AFP all said the study—of which they had been unaware—grossly manipulates data, cherry picking some facts and ignoring others that would contradict their discredited assertions.

“The paper gives the appearance of being specifically written to make the case that there is no climate crisis, rather than presenting an objective, comprehensive, up-to-date assessment,” said Richard Betts, Head of Climate Impacts Research at Britain’s Met Office.

The authors ignore the authoritative Intergovernmental Report on Climate Change (IPCC) report published a couple of months before their study was submitted to Springer Nature, Betts noted.

“Human-induced climate change is already affecting many weather and climate extremes in every region across the globe,” the IPCC concluded in that report.

“Evidence of observed changes in extremes such as heatwaves, heavy precipitation, droughts and tropical cyclones, and, in particular, their attribution to human influence, has strengthened” since the previous report eight years earlier, it said.

“They are writing this article in bad faith,” said Friederike Otto, a senior climatologist at the Grantham Institute for Climate Change and the Environment.

‘Climate sceptics’

“They do not have a section on heat waves”—mentioned only in passing—”where the observed trends are so incredibly obvious”, Otto said.

The peer-reviewed paper by four Italian scientists appeared in January 2022 in one of the more than 2,000 journals published by Springer Nature, one of the most prestigious science publishers in the world.

When asked to explain how a study so clearly at odds with current climate science could have passed peer review and been published, Springer Nature said: “We can’t comment at this time.”

Lead author Gianluca Alimonti is a physicist at a nuclear physics institute. The three co-authors are Luigi Mariani, an agricultural meteorologist, and the physicists Franco Prodi and Renato Angelo Ricci.

The study is written “by people not working in climatology and obviously unfamiliar with the topic and relevant data,” said Stefan Rahmstorf, Head of Earth Systems at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research.

“It is not published in a climate journal—this is a common avenue taken by ‘climate sceptics’ in order to avoid peer review by real experts in the field.”

“They simply ignore studies that don’t fit their narrative and have come to the opposite conclusion.”

All four of the experts consulted by AFP suggested that the study should never have been published in the first place, and two of them called for it to be withdrawn.

“I do not know this journal, but if it is a self-respecting one it should withdraw the article,” said Rahmstorf.

Peter Cox, a professor of climate system dynamics at the University of Exeter, said the study “isn’t good scientifically”, but feared that striking the article from the journal would “lead to further publicity and could be presented as censorship”.

Otto shared this concern, but said the study should be repudiated all the same.

“If the journal cares about science they should withdraw it loudly and publicly, saying that it should not have been published.”

Betts stopped short of calling for withdrawal, drawing a distinction between cherry-picking data and outright fraud.

© 2022 AFP

Citation: Scientists urge top publisher to withdraw faulty climate study (2022, September 27) retrieved 27 September 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-09-scientists-urge-publisher-faulty-climate.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Vivo Y02 India launch tipped, here’s when its coming

The highly anticipated Vivo Y02 smartphone could be headed to India after hitting store shelves in Indonesia last month. To those unaware, Vivo launched the Y02 smartphone in Indonesia on November 29. The budget smartphone will succeed the company’s well-received Vivo Y01. Regrettably, the company is still mum on its ...

View more: Vivo Y02 India launch tipped, here’s when its coming

OpenAI's new ChatGPT bot: 10 coolest things you can do with it

From precisely spotting security vulnerabilities in your code, to writing an essay or an entire block of functional code on a whim, to opening portals to another dimension, OpenAI’s newly launched ChatGPT is a game changer with its possibilities seeming limited only by your limitedness. Your wish is my ...

View more: OpenAI's new ChatGPT bot: 10 coolest things you can do with it

iQOO 11 series specifications, colors tipped via leaked poster

The upcoming iQOO 11 series smartphones’ key specifications have been revealed before launch, courtesy of a reliable tipster. To those unaware, iQOO recently postponed the iQOO 11 series launch to December 8. The iQOO 11 lineup will go official in China and Indonesia. The 11 series comprises two new premium ...

View more: iQOO 11 series specifications, colors tipped via leaked poster

Robot suppliers continue capacity expansions in China despite instability, says DIGITIMES Research

China remains the largest manufacturing industry in the world, making its industrial robot market a segment full of potential. Although around 70% of industrial robot suppliers in China are not domestic companies, they continue expanding capacities in the country despite concerns toward China’s instability amid geopolitical and trade issues, ...

View more: Robot suppliers continue capacity expansions in China despite instability, says DIGITIMES Research

GF and Intel semiconductor talent forgo are gifts to competitors

Intel is offering voluntary unpaid leave for thousands of employees while GlobalFoundries (GF) is laying off 6% of its global workforce to reduce short-term costs amid an industry down cycle. They are probably doing competitors such as TSMC, Samsung, UMC, and Foxconn a favor. Financial Times reported that Intel ...

View more: GF and Intel semiconductor talent forgo are gifts to competitors

Vingroup partners Google Cloud to modernize group-wide SAP applications, accelerate global growth ambitions

Vingroup, Vietnam’s largest private conglomerate, has on Monday announced a strategic collaboration with Google Cloud to modernize and connect its critical systems and data at a group-wide level. This reaffirms Vingroup’s commitment toward adopting best-in-class technologies to boost its production capabilities, improve product and service quality, enhance the customer ...

View more: Vingroup partners Google Cloud to modernize group-wide SAP applications, accelerate global growth ambitions

Where on Earth does the sun rise first?

Where does the first sunrise happen every day and which place sees the first sunrise of the New Year?

View more: Where on Earth does the sun rise first?

Climate change for food projects

Ehgartner report SCI Honorary Researcher Ulrike Ehgartner co-published the report ’Climate change for food projects: What it means and what to do about it’ for Food Research. Many people working in local or community food projects already know that they need to review how they operate in order to ...

View more: Climate change for food projects

Researchers harness bacteria-eating viruses to create powerful food decontamination spray

What does Polly say? Community science data reveal species differences in vocal learning by parrots

Volkswagen faces growing backlash in China over malfunctioning software in ID Series

Apple suppliers expand investment in India, look to dial down China operations

Putin ally Kudrin accepts tech giant Yandex's offer of advisory role

AirPods Pro 2 Deal at Amazon Brings Back Black Friday Pricing Ahead of the Holidays

Powerful New Weapon Against Contamination and Infection – Food Spray Deploys “Billions of Tiny Soldiers”

What Is DataOps?

Meta to jointly invest with Airtel in telecom infrastructure

iQOO 11 series launching in China on December 8 alongside iQOO Neo 7 SE

NASA Artemis I: Orion Spacecraft Experiencing Power Issues

The first complete picture of Arctic sea ice freeze-thaw cycle highlights sea ice response to climate change

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News