This site may earn affiliate commissions from the links on this page. Terms of use.

scotus takes case examining section 230 protection for youtube

(Photo: Adam Szuscik/Unsplash)The US Supreme Court has taken on a case that will test the true limitations of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. The case, Reynaldo Gonzalez et al v. Google, questions whether YouTube can be held responsible for hosting and recommending videos that recruit people into terrorist organizations and incite mass violence.

The case focuses on the death of an American woman named Nohemi Gonzalez, who was at a bistro in Paris when ISIS militants initiated a series of deadly attacks. ISIS killed Gonzalez and 19 other diners at the bistro alone; militants in other Paris restaurants, bars, and entertainment venues claimed the lives of an additional 111 people and injured at least 350 that same night. Gonzalez’s family asserts that online ISIS recruitment efforts were integral to carrying out these attacks, and that many of these efforts took place on YouTube. According to them, Google “knowingly permitted ISIS to post on YouTube hundreds of radicalizing videos inciting violence and recruiting potential supporters to join the ISIS forces” prior to Gonzelez’s death. Worse, YouTube allegedly recommended these videos to users, thus providing “material support” to ISIS.

scotus takes case examining section 230 protection for youtube

(Photo: Christian Wiediger/Unsplash)

“Google selected the users to whom it would recommend ISIS videos based on what Google knew about each of the millions of YouTube viewers, targeting users whose characteristics indicated that they would be interested in ISIS videos,” reads the lawsuit, which was recently bumped to the Supreme Court from San Francisco’s 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals. Thanks to these recommendations, users were allegedly able to locate other ISIS videos and channels they otherwise would not have seen, “even if they did not know the correct identifier or if the original YouTube account had been replaced.”

Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act typically shields sites like YouTube from liability regarding third-party (in this case, individual channels’) content. Back when the Sheriff of Cook County, Illinois sued Craigslist for allowing users to post “erotic” or “adult” content (which the Sheriff alleged facilitated prostitution), Section 230 protected the site from legal liability. Section 230 similarly prevented AOL from being held liable for hosting a defamatory website criticizing Matt Drudge. That said, the Ninth Circuit said in June 2021 that the US ought to reconsider “whether social media companies should continue to enjoy broad immunity for the third-party content they publish.” This revived Gonzalez et al v. Google and a few other cases accusing Google, Twitter, and Facebook of aiding and abetting terrorist organizations.

The Supreme Court has historically declined Section 230 cases. But Justice Clarence Thomas criticized this stance earlier this year, echoing the Ninth Circuit’s sentiment regarding the reconsideration of social media immunity. Now the Supreme Court is taking on Gonzalez’s family’s case, as well as a similar case involving Twitter and an “act of international terrorism.”

TECH NEWS RELATED

Ram electric truck teased ahead of Jan. 5 debut at CES

Ram on Tuesday teased its electric truck concept, which is scheduled to debut Jan. 5 at the 2023 Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas. The Ram 1500 Revolution BEV Concept was supposed to debut this fall, but in November parent company Stellantis announced that the reveal would be ...

View more: Ram electric truck teased ahead of Jan. 5 debut at CES

YouTube is bringing custom global emotes to live chats and comments

Toby Melville / reuters is rolling out Twitch-style custom global emotes for comments and live chats. created the first batch of emotes, which are focused on gaming, though it appears that they work on any type of channel. YouTube to develop emotes for other types of communities in the ...

View more: YouTube is bringing custom global emotes to live chats and comments

Watch Travis Pastrana hoon his 865-hp Subaru wagon in Gymkhana 2022

It’s been well over a decade since rally driver and entrepreneur Ken Block released his first Gymkhana video, which starred a rally-prepped 2006 Subaru Impreza WRX STI, and is still thourougly exciting despite the lack of flair found in later videos in the series. Block in 2018 finally decided ...

View more: Watch Travis Pastrana hoon his 865-hp Subaru wagon in Gymkhana 2022

German company builds stunning Audi Sport Quattro replicas

Audi’s short-wheelbase Sport Quattro of the 1980s has become the stuff of legend. Based on the earlier Quattro coupe, the Sport Quattro was developed as a homologation special for Group B rallying and as a result saw limited production. Just 214 were made over a two-year period, and many ...

View more: German company builds stunning Audi Sport Quattro replicas

'Roblox' Bomb Simulator Redeem Codes for December 2022: How to Get a YouTube Pet, Gem Boost, and More

New redeem codes have dropped for “Roblox” Bomb Simulator for December. Players can use these codes to claim different bonuses like a YouTube Pet, gem boosts, and more. “Roblox” has many unique games with different gameplays like Bomb Simulator. An article by Sportskeeda shares the different redeem codes players can ...

View more: 'Roblox' Bomb Simulator Redeem Codes for December 2022: How to Get a YouTube Pet, Gem Boost, and More

YouTuber Takes On Norwegian Trans Euro Trail Aboard Yamaha T7

Adventure traveler Runa sure lives up to the Off She Goes channel name.

View more: YouTuber Takes On Norwegian Trans Euro Trail Aboard Yamaha T7

Deep dive: Travis Pastrana's Subaru Family Huckster gymkhana car

Travis Pastrana’s “Family Huckster” packs the guts of a gymkhana car into the body of a 1983 Subaru GL wagon. Pastrana unveiled this unusual build earlier this year, and the wagon makes its gymkhana video debut on Dec. 6.  Inspired by Subaru GL wagons used as a marketing tie-in ...

View more: Deep dive: Travis Pastrana's Subaru Family Huckster gymkhana car

5 YouTube Traders Call IMPT Token The Best Crypto to Buy Now

Disclaimer: The Industry Talk section features insights by crypto industry players and is not a part of the editorial content of Cryptonews.com. Several top crypto influencers have tipped the IMPT presale as the best cryptocurrency to invest in right now before its presale concludes December 11th. This upcoming green ...

View more: 5 YouTube Traders Call IMPT Token The Best Crypto to Buy Now

How to Turn Off Restricted Mode on YouTube

Google terminates thousand of YouTube channels in China, Russia, Brazil

Random: YouTuber Ludwig Announces His Own Super Smash Bros. Tournament

How to post a Short on YouTube

The Annual Yogscast Jingle Jam Is Here!

Jay Leno drops top on a 1967 Ferrari 365 California Spyder

Check Out YouTube Music's Recap for 2022 Today

Google, YouTube to invest $13.2 million to help fight misinformation

Instructions on how to listen to music on Youtube when the screen is off on Iphone, Android smartphones

Google Details How It Handles Misinformation on YouTube

YouTube Music 2022 Recap now available, here are the highlights

Instructions on how to upload videos to youtube by phone quickly

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News