English-only transcription service

TechRadar Verdict

It’s easy to use and if you’re American it is relatively cheap. But, it only transcribes English and the ai service isn’t the most accurate For those wondering if they can make money transcribing for Scribie, think again.

Pros

  • +

    Can be inexpensive

  • +

    Easy to use

Cons

  • No live transcription

  • Additional charges for accents other than American

  • Only English-speaking transcription

  • Not a way to make money

Those that need transcription services regularly are often looking for a probably impractical combination of high accuracy and low cost.

Scribie teases that possibility with a service that potentially offers a high degree of accuracy and one that is remarkably cost-effective.

Is Scribe just too good to be true?

    computing

    (Image credit: Mark Pickavance)

    Plans and pricing

    Scribie offers two transcribing options; one that’s delivered by AI and another where people are involved, and each is priced accordingly.

    The AI automated service costs 10 cents per minute, and for good audio quality promises between 80% and 95% accuracy. However, it downgrades that accuracy to 80% for accented speakers, 60% for noisy audio or poor quality recordings.

    The minimum bill is 1$ even if your recording is less than 10 minutes long and transcribed via AI.

    Recordings are processed within 30 minutes, do not include speaker tracking or time coding.

    The alternative is the manual process that predictably takes much longer, up to 36 hours, and costs $0.80 per minute.

    For eight times the cost they predict 99% accuracy, but you get slammed for an extra $0.50 each for strict verbatim, accented speakers, noisy audio, poor audio and subtitles files.

    And, critically, both services only process English speakers.

    All processing requires prior payment, and this uses a credit system that you must pre-load with funds beforehand. Credit can be added to the account from $10 to $15,000, and a common fund can be managed between multiple team members.

    As an interesting aside, when we first covered Scribie a couple of years ago the prices were the same as now. So factoring in inflation, this service is getting cheaper.

    computing

    (Image credit: Mark Pickavance)

    Design

    The mechanism for uploading audio files and retrieving the transcribed results is a simple web page linked to the user account for billing.

    Files can either be directly loaded from a computer or sourced from a wide range of cloud storage providers and Video sites, like YouTube and Vimeo.

    Once the files are uploaded or transferred to Scribie, then you are given a quote of the costs for transcribing a file.

    As part of our testing, we uploaded the start of a famous book spoken by an English actor and comedian. The clip ran for 2 minutes and 3 seconds, and the cost of transcribing this using AI was just $1, and to have it done manually was $1.64.

    AI processing was much faster than the 30 minutes that the system had allocated, and once the file is processed, Scribie provides an estimated accuracy.

    computing

    (Image credit: Mark Pickavance)

    You can download the text in a wide range of formats, or you can use a web-based editor to hear the audio back alongside the transcription.

    This online editor isn’t an impressive part of Scribie. The web page it spawns on has no horizontal scroll bar, and leave vast amounts of unused white space either side of the work area.

    For manual operations Scribie uses a four-step process to take raw recordings and transcribe them using home-based freelancers to perform the transcription and review stages, followed by an in-house quality assurance team to proofread and quality assure the work.

    The mechanisms for handling the work are identical to the AI pathway. The only differences being that it takes longer to happen, and it costs more to have it done that way.

    computing

    (Image credit: Mark Pickavance)

    Accuracy

    Assessing the accuracy of an AI system is one thing, but a solution that involves multiple humans is inherently flawed by definition. That said, Scribie has clearly created a tight loop mechanism in their workflow to get the best possible accuracy within the limitations of the audio provided.

    And, Scribie is sufficiently confident in this process that at no additional cost to the customer, they will re-review the transcript if the results are found to be unsatisfactory on delivery.

    That might not help someone working to tight timescales, but it demonstrates a high level of commitment to getting things right within the vagaries of human communication.

    If being super accurate is important to you we’d use the manual service, since in our tests the AI transcription has its limitations.

    One of the clearest speakers we could find was Mr Stephen Fry reading Harry Potter, and we unleashed Scribie on a small clip of that audio. For those curious, the book in question wasn’t written by JK rolling’, as Scribe interpreted it. But this was a slight improvement over its attempt from a couple of years ago.

    Then it made a complete mess of the opening chapter of the book calling the Dursley’s  ‘Dales’ and Dudley ‘double’. The latest effort changed those to Danes and deadly, though it got Dudley right on one occasion.

    In terms of accuracy, Scribie is getting better, but it isn’t anything we’d want to assume doesn’t need some considerable work to make perfect.

    Depending on the recording, irrespective of its clarity, results may vary.

    computing

    (Image credit: Mark Pickavance)

    Making money with Scribie

    One of the aspects of Scribie that’s different from many vendors is that those with English grammar and typing skills can sign up to transcribe with them and make some money.

    How much money?

    The payment rates range from $5 to $25 per audio hour. And, depending on where you live in the world, the lower remuneration would be considered below the minimum wage, and the upper amount hardly a king’s ransom.

    On the upside, for those that stick with the service for more than a few hours, Scribie pays some bonuses.

    However, what’s important to realise is that you can’t realistically transcribe an hour of audio in one actual hour. Transcription is performed in 6-minute-long blocks, and Scribie’s estimation is that the average speed is 45 minutes for that 6-minute section of audio.

    That speed correlates to 7.5 hours to complete an audio hour, or 66 cents an hour at the low rate, and $3.33 for those earning the most. Some freelancers working for Scribie can achieve 18 minutes per 6-minute block if they use the automated transcript, and then fix the problems afterwards.

    However it is that you achieve these tasks, employment isn’t guaranteed, and pay is low for work that requires not insignificant skills. Unless you are working in a criminally run business, jobs in natively English-speaking countries, however basic, pay more than this.

    Cash earned is paid via PayPal, and you must compete with others for the average 492 new files that are on average added to the system for transcription each day.

    In short, unless you have infinite amounts of spare time and wish to develop carpal tunnel issues rapidly, this isn’t a career path we’d recommend.

    computing

    (Image credit: Mark Pickavance)

    Security

    Scribie uses industry-standard 256-bit SSL encryption on its website, making all the communication between servers and browsers encrypted.

    In addition, all transcribers are bound by a confidentiality clause about what they transcribe, and as they only get 6-minute chunks of the audio, they never have enough content to see the entirety of what they are transcribing.

    Files that are deleted by users are permanently removed from the servers, and the account can also be purged if deleted.

    The business will also enter into business-specific confidentiality agreements if required, but the service isn’t HIPAA compliant.

    Final verdict

    Scribie is a service that initially seems cheap, and it is if you exclusively use the AI options. But for those wanting more accurate transcriptions, the manual option could be less of a bargain if they have a poor recording of an Australian giving an open-air presentation at an airport.

    The American focused nature of this solution demonstrates that most of those who are employed to transcribe for Scribie are from North America, and as such find the regional accents of English speakers from other nations, including England ironically, a challenge.

    While Scribie claims to have expertise in British, Australian, Indian, African, various European and Asian accents, there are additional costs and longer timescales for those.

    Because of the extra cost and time, we’d suggest that the service is probably only appropriate for those based in the US. UK residents, for example, should be able to find local transcription services that don’t add additional charges for their local dialects.

    For those in the USA, this solution seems highly affordable, especially if you have good enough recordings to achieve acceptable accuracy from its AI solution.

    Those that require the highest levels of accuracy can use the manual service, which is again relatively inexpensive if you don’t incur any additional charges.

    There are better services, but not many this cheap.

    TECH NEWS RELATED

    Galaxy M13 5G support page goes live in the UK

    Samsung is working hard to fill its 2022 portfolio with mid-range smartphones and budget devices. We all got used to seeing new Samsung smartphones being released the entire year. Now, it seems that an entry-level smartphone will come from a Korean firm. The device in question is the Samsung Galaxy ...

    View more: Galaxy M13 5G support page goes live in the UK

    BMW M4 CSL Adds Power, Drops Weight, Costs a Lot

    What’s happening BMW is building a harder-core, limited-production version of its M4 coupe, priced from $140,895 including $995 for destination. Why it matters The CSL has more power, less weight and stiffer internal components than the standard M4. What’s next Production starts in July and only 1,000 will be sold ...

    View more: BMW M4 CSL Adds Power, Drops Weight, Costs a Lot

    Mercedes-AMG EV supercar concept revealed

    Stunning Vision AMG four-door coupe previews performance brand’s EV future from 2025

    View more: Mercedes-AMG EV supercar concept revealed

    How to Split Screen on Android

    If you need to multitask on your phone, there’s an easier way than swiping between apps. Learn how to split screen on Android instead. If you’re an Android owner and multitasker, something you can do is split the screen on your Android device. The split-screen feature on Android allows ...

    View more: How to Split Screen on Android

    Destiny 2's Solstice Summer Event Getting Seals, Title, And New Rewards

    A new "Event Card" system will streamline progression with new challenges and rewards, and some will spawn multiple seasonal events.

    View more: Destiny 2's Solstice Summer Event Getting Seals, Title, And New Rewards

    Evil Dead: The Game Review - Somewhat Groovy

    In a long line of Evil Dead video games, this latest effort may be the most faithful of all, but sometimes it's loyal to a fault.

    View more: Evil Dead: The Game Review - Somewhat Groovy

    Apple executives show VR/AR headset to board, signaling advanced progress

    In brief: Reports of Apple’s work on virtual reality hardware go back several years. However, the latest information suggests that the company is close to having a tangible product to compete with offerings from Valve, HTC, Meta, and Sony. On Thursday, anonymous sources told Bloomberg that Apple executives recently demonstrated ...

    View more: Apple executives show VR/AR headset to board, signaling advanced progress

    Mercedes Announces Maybach SL, 'Mythos' SL Speedster

    What’s happening Mercedes teased a Maybach version of the SL roadster. Why it matters It will be the first ever Maybach SL. What’s next The Maybach SL should be revealed within the next year. Mercedes-Benz wants to move upmarket, announcing on Thursday that it’s planning to cut the number of ...

    View more: Mercedes Announces Maybach SL, 'Mythos' SL Speedster

    Vampire: The Masquerade - Swansong Oedipus Puzzle Guide

    Vivo S15 and S15 Pro launched with Snapdragon 870 and Dimensity 8100

    How to Quickly Lock Your Windows 11/10 PC

    Apple seriously violates labour laws surveilling employees

    This is the brand new BMW M4 CSL

    Witcher 3 For PS5 & Xbox Series X|S Consoles Release Window Confirmed | GameSpot News

    Fortnite Week 9 Challenges: Crashed IO Airships, Ascenders, And More

    Star Citizen Reveals Anvil Legionnaire Boarding Ship as Crowdfunding Passes $460 Million

    Stranger Things Season 4 Details Leaked in Monopoly Set, Creators Are Unhappy

    OnePlus Nord 2T launched with Dimensity 1300 SoC

    New Justice Department guidelines promise not to prosecute security researchers under anti-hacking laws

    Chip manufacturer TSMC plans to open Singapore plant to tackle chip shortage

    OTHER TECH NEWS

    Top Car News Car News