size matters for bee 'superorganism' colonies
Honey bees on comb with stored pollen. Credit: Heather Bell

Scientists have carefully studied the intricacies of how individual organisms live and act together in groups known as biological collectives. In “superorganisms” such as bee colonies, the interactions of the individual members add up to benefit the entire colony.

Details have been elusive on how colonies make decisions in the face of changing conditions that are vital to their survival. Now researchers at the University of California San Diego studying honey bees have published a research study indicating that colony size is a key factor. The findings—led by researchers from UC San Diego’s Division of Biological Sciences and Institute for Neural Computation, along with a researcher from the Westphalian University of Applied Sciences in Germany—are published Nov. 10 in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface.

Working at a UC San Diego apiary, the researchers collected data over several years on the behaviors of individuals in small and large honey bee colonies. Their efforts focused on communication signals that bees use to convey information. Honey bees use a vigorous “waggle dance” to let their hive mates know about an available food source beneficial to the colony. But when conditions of such food sources deteriorate, or when a fellow hive mate is threatened by a predator, bees then produce “stop” signals—which include transmitting vibrations and delivering head butts—that let waggle dancers know that the source is no longer a viable option.

The key determining factor, they uncovered, boils down to the size of the colony. Large, established colonies with comfortable levels of food stores were less likely to take chances with risky food sources. Alternately, smaller colonies pressed to locate adequate food to sustain themselves were much more willing to take risks and ignore warning signals.

“We created an artificial stop signal that, like natural stop signals, caused waggle dancers to briefly pause,” said lead author Heather Bell, Ph.D. (a summary of the study is available here). “We then used the artificial signal on waggle dancers from colonies of different sizes. By measuring how long waggle dances lasted, we found that bees from small colonies were indeed less likely to listen to the message from our artificial signal than those from large colonies.”

The results underscored the idea that a strategy that works to keep a small colony going is not necessarily the optimal strategy for a large colony.

“It all boils down to risk. Smaller colonies will take more risk because they need food,” said James Nieh, a professor in the Section of Ecology, Behavior and Evolution and senior author of the paper. “When a swarm starts a new colony, they are in a desperate situation and likely more willing to take chances.”

The researchers indicate that the behavior of such superorganisms is analogous to neural networks. In both colonies and nervous systems, information is processed by networks of individual components that need to exchange critical information for the biological collective to survive. Other systems where such behaviors are seen include human social groups such as small companies that may be less likely to heed new information that would cause them to change their planned course. The scientists also indicate that their results could have implications for the design of artificial computing networks. Like bee colonies, these networks need to perform well and remain robust as they grow or shrink in size.

size matters for bee 'superorganism' colonies
Foraging honey bee resting on a plant. Credit: Nieh Lab, UC San Diego

In the natural environment, Nieh says, the new study’s results help scientists understand how bees adapt to dynamic conditions, including climate change.

“Global climate change is shifting many things, including when flowers bloom, which in turn is likely shifting the habits of predators,” said Nieh. “Honey bees have an amazing resilience to these changes in part because of their intricate communication system, so this study helps us understand how they can adapt better. More information: Heather C. Bell et al, Responsiveness to inhibitory signals changes as a function of colony size in honeybees ( Apis mellifera ), Journal of The Royal Society Interface (2021). DOI: 10.1098/rsif.2021.0570 Journal information: Journal of the Royal Society Interface

Provided by University of California – San Diego Citation: Size matters for bee ‘superorganism’ colonies (2021, November 10) retrieved 10 November 2021 from This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


The new #1 movie on Netflix has a brutal twist that’s leaving viewers speechless

Jane Campion, the director behind Netflix’s sublimely good new original film The Power of the Dog, is one of the most admired and critically acclaimed filmmakers of the modern era. One of just seven women nominated for a Best Director Academy Award, she also was the first-ever female director ...

View more: The new #1 movie on Netflix has a brutal twist that’s leaving viewers speechless

How to keep up with retirement in the wake of job changes

Eric Siss, CFP at Wealthstream Advisors, talks about planning, saving, and re-thinking risk as workers change jobs and even careers during The Great Resignation.

View more: How to keep up with retirement in the wake of job changes

Govt must regulate online gaming industry: Sushil Kumar Modi

Voicing concern over children getting addicted to mobile games, Rajya Sabha member and senior BJP leader Sushil Kumar Modi on Friday demanded that the government should regulate the online gaming industry and impose a uniform tax on it. Raising the issue during the Zero Hour, he said these online ...

View more: Govt must regulate online gaming industry: Sushil Kumar Modi

Google Maps: How to Change Your Address

(Photo : Unsplash/ CardMapr) Google Maps Google Maps allows you to set a home address (and work address) so you can quickly find directions to and from your home. When you move, you should update it in Google Maps, too. We’ll show you how to do that. By keeping ...

View more: Google Maps: How to Change Your Address

YouTube Content ID Scam: Men Allegedly Stole $20M by Claiming Royalty Payments from Others’ Songs

YouTube Content ID scammers allegedly stole a whopping $20 million from royalty fees from the video-sharing giant by claiming rights to the songs of other artists. (Photo : Photo by KIRILL KUDRYAVTSEV/AFP via Getty Images)This picture taken in Moscow on October 12, 2021 shows the logo of Youtube social media ...

View more: YouTube Content ID Scam: Men Allegedly Stole $20M by Claiming Royalty Payments from Others’ Songs

Spider-Man: No Way Home trailer 3 won’t show Maguire and Garfield – here’s how we know

Two weeks. That’s how long we have to wait until Spider-Man: No Way Home hits theaters. It’s actually less than that, as the movie will start playing during Thursday night’s early screenings. Even still, Sony and Marvel have plenty of time to release the third trailer for the film. ...

View more: Spider-Man: No Way Home trailer 3 won’t show Maguire and Garfield – here’s how we know

Govt looking to add cryptocurrencies to tax law

Indians who trade or invest in cryptocurrencies on Indian platforms could come under the taxman’s lens, as might those who hold such coin outside the country. The government is looking to amend current income tax and disclosure norms in the upcoming budget to include terms such as cryptocurrency.The government wants ...

View more: Govt looking to add cryptocurrencies to tax law

U.S. labor movement's next frontier is the tech industry, AFL-CIO's Shuler says

Secretary-Treasurer of American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO) Liz Shuler speaks at the Lincoln Memorial during the 'Get Your Knee Off Our Necks' march in support of racial justice, in Washington, U.S., August 28, 2020. Olivier Douliery/Pool via REUTERS/Files Register now for FREE unlimited access ...

View more: U.S. labor movement's next frontier is the tech industry, AFL-CIO's Shuler says

Google Photos rolls out Locked Folder feature to more Android phones

Roadie Wins “Company of the Year – Medium” in 11th Annual Best in Biz Awards

Twitter says it mistakenly suspended accounts after new policy spurred 'malicious reports'

Bird Photographers: Two Lenses Here Might Really Appeal to You!

Omicron variant may have picked up a piece of common-cold virus

Netflix just released the final episodes of one of its most successful shows ever

Toyota EV Plan to Bring Zero-Emission Car Sales by 2035 as Part of European Green Deal! 50% by 2030

Netflix's most popular shows and movies, ranked (according to Netflix)

Why Does Cannabis Smell Skunky? New Compounds Detected With 2D Gas Chromatography

Bitcoin tumbles 5.5% to $53,436

Inside the Catena-X automotive industry consortium - the biggest story SAP isn't talking about (yet)

Facebook whistleblower says transparency needed to fix social media ills