A judge has ruled that Wolfire's amended antitrust suit can move ahead.

The antitrust lawsuit against Valve is back on

(Image credit: Valve)

The antitrust lawsuit between Valve and Wolfire Games is back on track. The suit was dismissed in November 2021 for failing to meet necessary standards, but without prejudice, meaning Wolfire had 30 days to amend the complaint and refile it. Somewhat unexpectedly, that’s what it did, and a judge has now ruled that the case can move forward.

The original lawsuit contended that Valve uses its dominance of the PC gaming market through Steam to suppress competition, while extracting “an extraordinarily high cut from nearly every sale that passes through its store.” That keeps game prices artificially high, according to Wolfire, the indie developer of games including Lugaru and Overgrowth and originator of the Humble Bundle. 

“In order to afford Valve’s 30 percent commission, game publishers must raise their prices to consumers and can afford to invest fewer resources in innovation and creation,” the lawsuit stated. “Gamers are injured by paying higher retail prices caused by Valve’s high commissions.”

And while the Epic Games Store has made previously unprecedented inroads into the digital PC market, it was actually cited as a failure in the suit because Epic was only able to do so by spending truckloads of cash on exclusive deals and giveaways.

Valve, naturally, defended its practices, saying its 30% cut “has become the ‘industry standard’,” and that it actually faces competition from some of the biggest companies in the business, including Microsoft, Epic, and Amazon. It also criticized Wolfire’s suit for a lack of specific claims: The claim that Valve forbids developers from selling discounted Steam keys through other distributors, for instance, arose from “a single anecdote” involving one unnamed developer, Valve said. The judge in the case apparently agreed with that assessment, saying in the dismissal that the lawsuit “does not articulate sufficient facts to plausibly allege an antitrust injury.”

The updated suit was enough to at least partially fill in those blanks. A ruling filed on May 9 and available via GameDiscoverCo noted that the amended filing doesn’t make any new claims, but instead “provides additional context” to the original allegations. One such example is a note about Valve’s acquisition of the World Opponent Network [WON] in 2001, which it shut down a few years later, “forcing gamers onto the Steam platform.”

“This denotes market power earlier on than described in the CAC [class action complaint],” the ruling states. “And while both complaints indicate that, in those early days, Defendant was competing against brick-and-mortar game distributors, the SAC [second amended class action complaint] makes it clear that Defendant did not need market power to charge a fee well above its cost structure because those brick-and-mortar competitors had a far higher cost structure.”

It’s not a clear-cut win for Wolfire. Four causes of action in the lawsuit, resting on the claim that the Steam platform and Steam storefront operate in separate markets, were dismissed, as was part of the seventh cause of action—and with prejudice this time, meaning the claims cannot be filed again. The remaining claims, however, which “rest on the theory that Defendant [Valve] competes in a single, integrated game platform and transaction market,” will be allowed to proceed.

As GameDiscoverCo points out, the ruling isn’t a judgment on any of the lawsuit’s claims, it simply grants Wolfire an opportunity to make its case, which is where things get both very complex and very expensive. A recent ruling in the Epic v. Apple case stating that Apple is “not a monopolist” (and that allows Apple to continue charging 30% fees on the App Store) could indicate that Wolfire has a tough road ahead, but at least now it’s got a shot.

I’ve reached out to Wolfire and Valve for comment on the ruling, and will update if I receive a reply.

TECH NEWS RELATED

V Rising is more than Valheim with vampires

But they're both adept at keeping me playing until dawn.

View more: V Rising is more than Valheim with vampires

Best Places to farm Copper Ore in V Rising

Image via Stunlock Studios Materials are required in V Rising to create new gear and to upgrade your castle. Copper is a hugely important resource in the early stages of the game as it is required to create copper ingots to make higher-quality weapons and castle walls. Here is ...

View more: Best Places to farm Copper Ore in V Rising

Pokemon Go To Receive New Social Features Niantic Has Been Testing In Ingress

Niantic has been testing new social features in its foundational AR game, Ingress, and is preparing to bring those features to Pokemon Go.

View more: Pokemon Go To Receive New Social Features Niantic Has Been Testing In Ingress

Mastercard will soon allow you to pay with a smile

Apple’s Apple Pay arrived and in a certain way has started a change in the way we perform payments. The company presented a cashless wallet that allows its users to simply pay without much hassle and without the need of carrying dozens of credit cards in a pocket. We saw ...

View more: Mastercard will soon allow you to pay with a smile

2023 BMW M4 CSL: A 543-HP Lightweight Tribute to M's Glory Days

The CSL name only goes on the most iconic BMWs. The new M4 CSL has a lot to live up to.

View more: 2023 BMW M4 CSL: A 543-HP Lightweight Tribute to M's Glory Days

BMW's M 1000 RR 50 Years M Superbike Has a Long Name and 212 HP

Yours for $32,495 as long as you’re okay with Sao Paulo yellow.

View more: BMW's M 1000 RR 50 Years M Superbike Has a Long Name and 212 HP

SsangYong Torres confirmed, planned for Australia

New SsangYong Torres teased ahead of its official reveal, and it’s on the cards to come to Australia. SsangYong’s forthcoming mid-size SUV has been christened the ‘Torres’. The car, which has had the codename ‘J100’ until now, gets its name from the Torres del Paine National Park in Patagonia. ...

View more: SsangYong Torres confirmed, planned for Australia

How to make and use Stone Dust in V Rising

Image via Stunlock Studios V Rising is a Survival game with a focus on crafting. You will need to gather materials and build your vampire castle from the ground up. Stone Dust is an important material and you will probably stumble upon some before you even really have a ...

View more: How to make and use Stone Dust in V Rising

Sniper Elite 5: Everything To Know

UnicornDAO Raises $4.5 Million to Support Women and LGBTQ+ Artists

Seek Inner Peace In Aka On Nintendo Switch

Pixel Pulp Mothmen 1966 Headed To Nintendo Switch

Netgear fixes bad Orbi firmware update that locked admin console

Best Finishers in WWE 2K22, Ranked

5 Letter Words with A and E as Second and Fourth Letters – Wordle Game Help

Epic Games kicks off its mega sale by offering Borderlands 3 for free

Battlefield 2042 Update 4.1 Removes 128 Player Breakthrough Mode on PS5

I'm still riding the high of unlocking Tunic's secret language

Borderlands 3 is free to download until next week

Sign at a light – Crossword clue help

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News