human evolution, religion, sociology

Evolution is often perceive as an individual affair: Traits that are helpful to the individual get passed on and eventually spread throughout a population, while those that are unhelpful eventually die off along with those who have them.

While this simple model is useful, there are many things that it finds difficult to explain. Asexuality and same-sex relationships are prime examples. Religious celibacy is another. Found in cultures worldwide, it seems like the kind of thing that eventually would have disappeared if the simple model for evolution — in which selection acts primarily at the level of the individual — is a complete explanation. The desire to become a monk should vanish from a population.

Now, a new study examines the implications of sending a family member into the monastery and provides evidence that while celibacy might not be a great decision for that individual’s genetic lineage, it works wonders for that of the family.

The evolutionary benefits of celibacy

The study, published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B, focused on Amdo Tibetans living in the eastern part of the Tibetan plateau. This part of China endured many of the trials and tribulations as the rest of the nation over the past century, including a restriction on the number of children (they were allowed three, as opposed to one elsewhere in China), the shuttering of the monasteries during the Cultural Revolution (1966-1976), and shocks to family wealth and general food availability during the Great Leap Forward (1958-1962). The local economy remains based around agriculture, and compulsory school attendance only began in 2000.

Since the reopening of the monasteries around 1980, many families have returned to the traditional practice of sending young boys to take up the life of a monk. At one point, more than half of ethnic Tibetan males were ordained in some manner. According to the authors of the study, one in seven Tibetan boys would become monks, making the western part of the Gansu province an ideal location for their investigation into celibacy.

Subscribe for counterintuitive, surprising, and impactful stories delivered to your inbox every Thursday

The authors collected sociodemographic data in 2017 by going door to door in 21 villages. The authors interviewed the residents of 530 households, representing 3,591 living people, 268 of whom were monks and five of whom were nuns. The head of each household was asked for a family tree, the names of their relatives, the occupations of their family members, and other relevant information, such as finances. Genealogies were constructed around this data.

The team found that men with a monk brother had 1.75 times as many children as those without a sibling in the abbey, on par with the number of kids an only son could expect to have. These men are also wealthier than those without a monk in the family. The results were less substantial for women, who do not generally inherit family wealth in that part of China. Still, the sister-in-law of a monk can expect to have their first child earlier than a woman with no relation to a holy man.

The benefits also extend to grandparents. Men who send one of their sons into a monastery have 1.15 times as many grandchildren as men without monks as children. This held up even in the face of other variables, such as wealth or the number of children, suggesting that there are only evolutionary benefits, but no costs, to sending a child off to the monastery.

Why does the benefit exist? Much of it derives from the family not having to divide their wealth as many times as those families who lack monks. The increased wealth makes larger families easier to support for those who do have children.

Taking one for the team

So, while becoming a monk is bad news for the genes of the person entering the monastery, it is great news for the genes of the parents and grandparents, as well as those of siblings. “Taking one for the team” ends up being a great evolutionary strategy for the group as a whole — a concept known, perhaps unsurprisingly, as group selection. Selection doesn’t happen just at the level of the individual.


Manufacturing microscopic octopuses with a 3D printer

Smart polymers with “life-like” properties: due to dynamic chemical bonds the micrometric 3D structures can grow eight-fold in just a few hours and harden. Scale: 20 micrometers (µm). Credit: Christoph Spiegel (Heidelberg University). Adapted from Y. Jia et. al, Adv. Funct. Mater. 2022, 2207826 (CC BY 4.0) Although just ...

View more: Manufacturing microscopic octopuses with a 3D printer

Protein family shows how life adapted to oxygen

The catalytic fold of the ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) family is a unique 10-stranded ɑ/β barrel, consisting of 10 β-strands (light green) and 8 ɑ-helices (light blue). (A) Each half of the barrel contains a five-stranded parallel β-sheet (βA-βE and βF-βJ) that is arranged in anti-parallel orientation with respect to ...

View more: Protein family shows how life adapted to oxygen

Driving high? Chemists make strides toward marijuana breath analyzer

The researchers’ THC-powered fuel cell sensor, with its H-shaped glass chamber. Credit: Evan Darzi A UCLA chemist and colleagues are now a step closer to their goal of developing a handheld tool similar to an alcohol Breathalyzer that can detect THC on a person’s breath after they’ve smoked marijuana. ...

View more: Driving high? Chemists make strides toward marijuana breath analyzer

Alain Aspect, Nobel-winning father of quantum entanglement

Alain Aspect, one of three physics Nobel winners, helped pave the way for what he calls the ‘second quantum revolution’ Alain Aspect, who won a long-expected Nobel Physics Prize on Tuesday, not only helped prove the strange theory of quantum entanglement but also inspired a generation of physicists in ...

View more: Alain Aspect, Nobel-winning father of quantum entanglement

Reports say the CIA is trying to resurrect woolly mammoths

There is a lot of skepticism around the prospect of reviving extinct animals like the woolly mammoth. Despite the skepticism, though, it appears the CIA is going all in on investing in mammoth resurrection tech. With the ongoing changes happening around the globe due to climate change, bringing extinct ...

View more: Reports say the CIA is trying to resurrect woolly mammoths

The Mediterranean Sea Rising Temperatures Trigger the Formation of CO2-emitting Crystals

According to the United Nations Climate Action, as the ocean warms from the excess heat and energy, there are unmatched cascading effects, resulting in ice melting, sea level rise, marine heat waves, and ocean acidification. More concerning climate change indicators include the oceans’ inability to absorb heat generated by rising greenhouse ...

View more: The Mediterranean Sea Rising Temperatures Trigger the Formation of CO2-emitting Crystals

Ancient chemistry may explain why living things use ATP as the universal energy currency

Molecular dynamic simulation of ADP and acetyl phosphate. Credit: Aaron Halpern, UCL (CC-BY 4.0, A simple two-carbon compound may have been a crucial player in the evolution of metabolism before the advent of cells, according to a new study published October 4 in the open access journal PLOS ...

View more: Ancient chemistry may explain why living things use ATP as the universal energy currency

New book examines gender on legal response to domestic violence

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Over the past 40 years, considerable progress has been made in lowering rates of domestic violence (DV) in our communities. However, this progress has been uneven due to continuing misconceptions about the causes and dynamics of domestic violence. “Gender and Domestic Violence: Contemporary Legal Practice ...

View more: New book examines gender on legal response to domestic violence

Study: Black prosecutors are more punitive toward Black and Latinx defendants

Online fandom communities can facilitate state censorship, according to new research

Nirit Weiss-Blatt

How many innocent people is the plea bargain sending to prison?

Spectacular Planetary-Scale “Heat Wave” Discovered in Jupiter’s Atmosphere

Plastic gobbling enzymes in worm spit may help ease pollution

Holmes gets new hearing after disheveled gov’t witness shows up at her house

Both sides dig in as EPA's final decision on Pebble Mine nears

Quantum entanglement: the 'spooky' science behind physics Nobel

The Nobel winners who helped prove quantum 'spooky action'

Making tumor diagnosis kinder to kidneys

A quick look at the 2022 Nobel Prizes


Top Car News Car News