Summary: Powerful hierarchical situations make it easier for individuals to commit harmful actions. The reason for this, researchers say, is because empathy and agency become split across multiple individuals.

Source: KNAW

Researchers from the Netherlands Institute for Neuroscience show that powerful hierarchical situations make it easier to commit harmful actions, as agency and empathy are split across multiple individuals.

There are numerous historical examples where horrific acts and mass destruction have occurred as a result of a hierarchical structure. A superior communicates a plan and a subordinate carries it out. The superior then bears responsibility for the decision but is distanced from the results, while the subordinate experiences authorship over the action but may experience reduced responsibility for its outcomes.  And in our daily lives too, hierarchy is acquired throughout our society.

In many organizations, orders are embedded in an even longer chain of commands in which a given commander often merely relays on the orders received from a superior. But what effect does this have on our actions?

A new study from the social brain lab looked at how your position within a hierarchical structure (commander or intermediary) influences the sense of agency and empathy for pain. The aim was to understand how these two different neurocognitive processes differ in commanders and intermediaries.

And guess what? Commanders and intermediaries show reduced activation in empathic brain regions when pain is inflicted on the victim compared to people who can decide and act for themselves.

The results were published in the journal eNeuro.

The team used functional MRI (fMRI) and electroencephalogram (EEG) techniques in order to perform their experiments. fMRI measures brain activity by tracking changes in blood flow over time. The changes visible on the scan are related to change in oxygen levels: when areas of the brain are active, they will need more oxygen, causing them to ‘light up’.

Using EEG, brain activity is measured electrically. During this test, small sensors are attached to the scalp to pick up the electrical signals produced by the brain.

Reduced empathy

The fMRI study shows that activity in empathy-related brain regions was low in both the commander and the intermediary, compared to someone who delivered the shock directly of their own free will.

During the both studies, pain was administered by a human or robot.

The EEG results show that the sense of agency did not differ between commanders and intermediaries, regardless of whether the execution was performed by a robot or a human. However, it turned out that the neural response to the pain of the victim were higher when participants commanded a robot compared to a human.

This suggests that when there is a second human involved, the responsibility tends to be diffused and commanders’ pain processing of the victim’s pain is reduced. Diffusing such responsibility onto a robot is perhaps more difficult.

Emilie Caspar (first co-author of the paper): “The law generally punished those who gave out orders more severely than those who carried out the orders. But what do people feel exactly in a hierarchical chain?

“Recently, Khieu Samphan, one of the main Khmer Rouge leaders, was sentenced to life imprisonment for crimes against humanity and genocide. Yet, he claimed that he did not know what was happening during the Khmer Rouge Era, where millions of Cambodians died of execution, starvation, and diseases.

“It seems that people commanding may not always experience the responsibility they should, an aspect which would nonetheless be crucial to avoid mass atrocities.

“This is why it is important to understand better their subjective experience and how their brain processes the consequences of their orders, to perhaps in the future offer interventions that would prevent a diminution of responsibility in hierarchical chain”

Kalliopi Ioumpa (first co-author of the paper): “These results complement previous research showing that hierarchy has a measurable effect on people’s behaviour and brain activation, making them less engaged in the harm they cause.

“This study can raise questions on how we can ensure that people feel responsibility despite being in a hierarchical chain. Is it easier for executors to take responsibility over their actions since they are the ones acting – or for commanders because they bear the responsibility of the order?

“We show how powerful hierarchical situations can facilitate committing actions that harm others, as agency and empathy are distributed across multiple individuals.”

What Is the Effect of Hierarchy on Moral Behavior?

Activation of empathy brain regions in the hierarchical chain. Credit: Kalliopi Ioumpa – Netherlands Institute for Neuroscience

Prof Dr Christian Keysers (One of the senior author of the study heading the lab in which it was performed): “Times are changing. The solder at the forefront, whose empathy sometimes prevented the worst atrocities, is increasingly replaced by drones that feel no empathy. Has this removed any empathy from the chain of command? Indeed, we find that merely commanding someone to deliver pain reduces how much your brain processes the pain you command compared to directly triggering the pain.

“What was really exciting to see, however, is that knowing that you command a machine, that you cannot defer the responsibility to, restores some of the reactions to the pain in commanders.

“Perhaps there is hope, after all, that the empathy we reduce at the forefront might be replaced – at least in part – by an increase is the sense of responsibility at higher levels in the hierarchy…”

Information about the authors:

The study was performed by Dr Emilie Caspar and PhD student Kalliopi Ioumpa under the supervision of Dr Christian Keysers and Dr Valeria Gazzola, who lead together the Social Brain Lab at the Netherlands Institute for Neuroscience, a research institute of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences. Dr Emilie Caspar has since become an associate professor at Ghent University.

About this morality and psychology research news

Author: Eline FeenstraSource: KNAWContact: Eline Feenstra – KNAW
Image: The image is credited to Kalliopi Ioumpa – Netherlands Institute for Neuroscience

Original Research: Closed access.
“Commanding or being a simple intermediary: how does it affect moral behavior and related brain mechanisms?” by Kalliopi Ioumpa et al. eNeuro


Abstract

Commanding or being a simple intermediary: how does it affect moral behavior and related brain mechanisms?

Psychology and neuroscience research have shown that fractioning operations between several individuals along a hierarchical chain allows diffusing responsibility between components of the chain, which has the potential to disinhibit antisocial actions.

Here, we present two studies, one using fMRI (Study 1) and one using EEG (Study 2), designed to help understand how commanding or being in an intermediary position impacts the sense of agency and empathy for pain. In the age of military drones, we also explored whether commanding a human or robot agent influences these measures.

This was done within a single behavioral paradigm in which participants could freely decide whether or not to send painful shocks to another participant in exchange for money.

In Study 1, fMRI reveals that activation in social cognition and empathy-related brain regions was equally low when witnessing a victim receive a painful shock while participants were either commander or simple intermediary transmitting an order, compared to being the agent directly delivering the shock.

In Study 2, results indicated that the sense of agency did not differ between commanders and intermediary, no matter if the executing agent was a robot or a human. However, we observed that the neural response over P3 was higher when the executing agent was a robot compared to a human.

Source reconstruction of the EEG signal revealed that this effect was mediated by areas including the insula and ACC. Results are discussed regarding the interplay between the sense of agency and empathy for pain for decision-making.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Orion captured a magnificent photo of the Moon and Earth

Since Artemis I’s launch earlier in November, the Orion capsule has been making its trek to the Moon, where it has taken part in a retrograde orbit. During this time, the Orion has had some fantastic views of the Moon and the Earth, including a photo that NASA recently ...

View more: Orion captured a magnificent photo of the Moon and Earth

China's Air Pollution Causes 64,000 Stillborn Babies a Year, Study Finds

A study finds remnants of air pollutants as the cause of thousands of stillborn babies. While air pollution has long been linked to many health concerns, it is only recently that an alarming figure of around 64,000 stillborn babies a year has been estimated, according to Wion. Over the years, the ...

View more: China's Air Pollution Causes 64,000 Stillborn Babies a Year, Study Finds

Could letting social media users rank accuracy help stop misinformation?

When fighting the spread of misinformation, social media platforms typically place most users in the passenger seat. Platforms often use machine-learning algorithms or human fact-checkers to flag false or misinforming content for users. “Just because this is the status quo doesn’t mean it is the correct way or the ...

View more: Could letting social media users rank accuracy help stop misinformation?

Defying Extinction – Asian Animals Found Thriving Near Humans

Sumatra tiger on the forest’s edge. Credit: UQ/Matthew Luskin Some of Asia’s largest animals, including tigers and elephants, are defying 12,000 years of extinction trends by coexisting with people, according to research led by the University of Queensland. Researchers combed through paleontological records to compare the past distribution of ...

View more: Defying Extinction – Asian Animals Found Thriving Near Humans

Stanford Researchers Find COVID-19 Pandemic Stress Physically Aged Teens’ Brains

The brains of adolescents who were assessed after the pandemic shutdowns ended appeared several years older than those of teens who were assessed before the pandemic. The brains of adolescents who were assessed after the COVID pandemic shutdowns ended appeared several years older than those of teens who were ...

View more: Stanford Researchers Find COVID-19 Pandemic Stress Physically Aged Teens’ Brains

“Time inequality” is the world’s real problem, not income inequality

According to the United Nations, the birth of the eight billionth person happened on November 15, 2022. Should we celebrate or mourn that milestone? Many see the expansion of the human enterprise as a calamity. Thinkers from Thomas Malthus and Paul Ehrlich to celebrities from Bill Maher to Tucker ...

View more: “Time inequality” is the world’s real problem, not income inequality

The key to curing cancer in humans may be discovered in dogs

The key to curing cancer may be hidden within the genetic differences between humans and dogs. According to scientists working with the National Institutes of Health, dogs get the same diseases that we do, and they have many of the same genes that we do, too. However, in the last ...

View more: The key to curing cancer in humans may be discovered in dogs

Good Sleep Can Increase Women’s Ambitions

On days after a night of bad sleep, women indicated reduced aspirations to achieve higher status at work. Sleep quality impacts women’s daily intentions to pursue workplace status. Women may wish to lay down for a full night’s sleep before leaning into work. Research from Washington State University found ...

View more: Good Sleep Can Increase Women’s Ambitions

Psychologist debunks 8 myths of mass scale - Big Think

Mauna Loa Awakens – Satellites View World’s Largest Active Volcano

Resurrecting Billon-Year-Old Enzymes – Scientists Reveal New Key Information About Photosynthesis

As the Arctic warms, beavers are moving in

Does Marine Conservation Mitigate Climate Change?

Scientists call for action to help sunflower sea stars

Strong quake shakes main Indonesia island, no major damage

Indonesia villagers race to escape eruption as sky turns black

Making science more accessible to people with disabilities

Scientific Weight Loss Study: Green Mediterranean Diet Reduces Twice As Much Visceral Fat

NASA Astronauts Complete New Solar Array Installation on International Space Station

New toothy diving dinosaur discovered

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News