wildfire smoke exposure hurts learning outcomes
Exposure to fine particle pollution from wildfire smoke during the school day affects average test scores. In this map of the predicted effect on average test scores by district in a relatively high-smoke year, 2016, darker shades indicate a stronger impact. Credit: Nature Sustainability (2022). DOI: 10.1038/s41893-022-00956-y

When wildfire smoke pollutes the air in schoolyards and classrooms, as it does with increasing frequency and severity across the country, it hurts not only children’s health but also their ability to learn and possibly their future earning power, according to new research from Stanford University.

The new analysis, published Sept. 29 in Nature Sustainability, draws on eight years of standardized test scores from nearly 11,700 public school districts across six grades, as well as estimates of daily smoke exposure derived from satellite measurements.

The researchers found test scores in English language arts and math dropped significantly during school years even at low levels of smoke exposure, and that test-score impacts grew as students’ smoke exposure worsened.

The impact on test scores nearly doubled when students were exposed to heavy smoke during the school day compared to the weekend. Underscoring previous studies suggesting that air pollution impacts are particularly harmful for younger students, the study also revealed greater impacts for third to fifth graders compared to sixth to eighth graders.

“Previous research suggests that the natural barriers in their lungs are still developing and they have a higher rate of breathing relative to their body size,” explained lead study author Jeff Wen, a Ph.D. student in Earth system science at the Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability. “This means that younger children may be more prone to smoke impacting their cognition in direct and indirect ways, such as increased asthma attacks that disrupt learning and lead to more school absences.”

Disproportionate impacts

The study builds on emerging evidence that exposure to air pollution can hurt cognition. “While test scores are an imperfect measure of student cognition, they are a common metric for evaluating student learning with relevance for long-term outcomes and opportunities,” the authors write. “This type of measurement allows us to compare test results in the same school district under different smoke conditions, and to do this for nearly all school districts in the U.S.,” Wen said.

Previous research has estimated a relationship between test score performance and future earnings. Based on those estimates, the authors estimate that American students’ exposure to wildfire smoke in just one year—2016—could lower cumulative future earnings nationwide by nearly $1.9 billion.

“The effects for any given student are pretty small, but once you start adding up the effects across hundreds of thousands of students who are exposed, they get pretty large,” said senior study author Marshall Burke, an associate professor of Earth system science at the Doerr School.

The new analysis shows that while all districts experience negative impacts per student, roughly 80% of the overall burden in terms of total lost earnings is borne by districts serving proportionately more students of color and more students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch.

This is because there are more total students in these districts and because impacts per student are somewhat higher—a finding that should be understood to reflect “the possible effect of racist and/or discriminatory policies or attitudes on outcomes,” the researchers write, such as students having to attend schools that have received less investment in filtration. The disparity suggests that in the absence of intervention, “additional increases in future wildfire smoke exposure due to climate change will likely disproportionately harm these communities.”

Rethinking costs and benefits

Quantifying previously overlooked social costs of wildfire smoke—a rapidly growing source of exposure to toxic particle pollution that is expected to worsen under a warming climate—is not only an academic exercise. Rather, revealing previously hidden long-term costs at the population scale can help to motivate and justify more ambitious action to reduce emissions, smoke exposure, or wildfire risk through fuel management or other techniques.

“Reducing the risk of extreme wildfires is an important but monumental task. It’s going to take billions of dollars of investment over a lot of years,” Burke said. But at the classroom, district, or community level, investments in air conditioning and portable air filters can help keep people safe and allow students to learn with cleaner air when smoke plumes drift in.

“When we think about the impacts of wildfire smoke exposure and climate change, we can’t just limit our attention to the most obvious places where impacts could occur. We really need to look across society and think about all the sectors that could be impacted,” Burke said. “That helps us answer questions about how much we should invest in mitigating extreme wildfires, or in measures to protect students in school from poor air quality—and whether these are good investments relative to other things we can spend our money on.” More information: Jeff Wen, Lower test scores from wildfire smoke exposure, Nature Sustainability (2022). DOI: 10.1038/s41893-022-00956-y Journal information: Nature Sustainability

Provided by Stanford University Citation: Wildfire smoke exposure hurts learning outcomes (2022, September 29) retrieved 29 September 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-09-wildfire-exposure-outcomes.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


Scoop: HUL, other FMCG majors in sale talks with nutrition firm Oziva

ETtechHindustan Unilever (HUL) has held talks to acquire plant-based supplement brand Oziva, multiple people in the know said, signalling the start of what could trigger a wave of consolidation in the direct-to-consumer (D2C) brand market.Oziva, which sells nutrition and fitness products across categories such as women’s health, skin, hair, men’s ...

View more: Scoop: HUL, other FMCG majors in sale talks with nutrition firm Oziva

Exclusive: Swiggy may fire 250 employees in December, more layoffs possible in coming months

ETtechFood and grocery delivery company Swiggy is laying off up to 250 employees this month, which is about 3-5% of its workforce, five people aware of the development told ET.Two of the sources said the layoffs could go beyond 250 in coming months while another said people across supply chain, ...

View more: Exclusive: Swiggy may fire 250 employees in December, more layoffs possible in coming months

Social platforms flag age-gating fears in MeitY’s IT rules meet

ETtechSome social media and internet platforms have expressed concerns to the ministry of electronics and IT on certain provisions of the draft Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Bill which includes age-gating, sources said. The Bill has defined a child as a person who is below the age of 18 and ...

View more: Social platforms flag age-gating fears in MeitY’s IT rules meet

Spice Money to offer B2B transactions on ONDC next quarter

ETtechSpice Money (a bootstrapped subsidiary of DiGiSPICE Technologies), one of the five buyer applications on the government-backed e-commerce platform the Open Network for Digital Commerce (ONDC) is going to foray into B2B business on the network next quarter with the electronics category.So far, the transactions on the network have been ...

View more: Spice Money to offer B2B transactions on ONDC next quarter

iPhone 14’s Emergency SOS via satellite feature may launch in the UK next week

Apple has promised that its Emergency SOS via satellite feature, an exclusive safety feature for the iPhone 14 and iPhone 14 Pro, would launch in four more countries by the end of the year. It seems we may have a launch date for one of those countries. As reported ...

View more: iPhone 14’s Emergency SOS via satellite feature may launch in the UK next week

New kilonova has astronomers rethinking what we know about gamma-ray bursts

Long gamma-ray burst stems from neutron star merger, not usual supernova explosion.

View more: New kilonova has astronomers rethinking what we know about gamma-ray bursts

Tecno MegaBook S1 brings 15.6″ 120Hz display and 12th Gen Core i7

Today was a big day for Tecno as the company presented its very first flagship phones – Tecno Phantom X2 and Phantom X2 Pro. These devices come with compelling specs such as Dimensity 9000, 120 Hz OLED displays, and capable cameras. The Pro has the first retractable portrait camera on ...

View more: Tecno MegaBook S1 brings 15.6″ 120Hz display and 12th Gen Core i7

Mars is hiding exciting mysteries beneath its surface 

A group of scientists from the University of Arizona has challenged the current views on the evolution of Martian geodynamics. A new report from the researchers suggests that Mars’ interior is far more active than previously believed, and that a giant mantle plume is currently lifting the surface upward, causing ...

View more: Mars is hiding exciting mysteries beneath its surface 

Dyson's noise-cancelling, air-purifying headphones are finally coming to Singapore

SpaceX announces Starshield, a new satellite service for governments

Microsoft Teams launches Communities feature to take on Discord

US state of Indiana sues TikTok, alleging Chinese access to user data

Redmi K60 with SD8 Gen 2, Pro with SD8+ Gen 1, seriously?

Cleaning Up Toxic “Protein Clumps” Could Prevent Dementia

Ex-Theranos exec Sunny Balwani sentenced to nearly 13 years in prison

New bot ChatGPT will force colleges to get creative to prevent cheating, experts say

OpenAI’s latest chatbot is sending Chinese users into a frenzy even though it is officially unavailable in the country

Oppo Find N2 and N2 Flip to come on December 15

Invisible skin mites called Demodex almost certainly live on your face – but what about your mascara?

Can machines invent things without human help? These AI examples show the answer is ‘yes’


Top Car News Car News