will twitter under elon musk be the ‘proverbial wild west’? users may have to fight bullying and misinformation on their own

Elon Musk’s vow to let everyone say whatever they want on Twitter after his takeover of the social media giant could put the onus on users to combat bullying and misinformation on the platform, experts say.

Details of Musk’s plans for Twitter were slim after his deal to buy the tech firm was announced on April 25, but the Tesla chief portrays himself as a free-speech absolutist.

The privatisation of Twitter with Musk as its master has raised concerns from analysts and activists that the site will be ruled capriciously by the world’s richest man, with more focus on attention and profit than on promoting healthy online conversations, which has been a priority at the service.

For Kyla Garrett Wagner, assistant professor of communications law at Syracuse University in the US state of New York, Musk’s takeover is not a victory for free-speech rights.

will twitter under elon musk be the ‘proverbial wild west’? users may have to fight bullying and misinformation on their own

Musk at an event in California in 2015. His deal to buy the tech firm was announced on April 25. Photo: Reuters

“What we have done is put even more power into fewer hands,” she says. “If Elon Musk decides tomorrow that he wants to shut Twitter down for a week, he can do that.”

She notes the US Constitution’s first amendment only bars governments from gagging what the country’s citizens say – leaving the billionaire entrepreneur the power to decide what can and cannot be posted on the private entity of Twitter.

“This is not the street corner,” Garrett Wagner says. “This is the proverbial Wild West but owned by a minority elite that doesn’t represent minority voices.”

Musk’s promised hands-off approach to content is a particularly thorny matter when it comes to high-profile cases like that of former US president Donald Trump, who was banned from Twitter after an assault on the US Capitol by his supporters.

“Musk says he is going to turn Twitter into a social media platform with no moderation; there have been several of those and they don’t work,” says analyst Rob Enderle of Enderle Group. “The trolls take over, they get too hostile and drive people away from the platform.”

will twitter under elon musk be the ‘proverbial wild west’? users may have to fight bullying and misinformation on their own

The privatisation of Twitter with Musk as its master has raised concerns from analysts and activists. Photo: EPA

Musk has said he is averse to banning people from Twitter because of misbehaviour, prompting speculation that he would lift Trump’s ban.

But Trump has said he would not be returning to Twitter even if his account were reinstated, saying he would stick to his own site, Truth Social.

If Musk pulls back on policing content at Twitter, advertisers would have to take the lead to ensure their messages were not associated with toxic content, according to advocates and academics.

“Accountability now rests with Twitter’s top advertisers, who need to make it clear that if Twitter becomes a free-for-all of hate, extremism and disinformation, they will walk,” says non-profit organisation Media Matters for America chief Angelo Carusone.

“It is also critical that Google and Apple hold Twitter to the same standards they applied to other apps like Parler,” he adds, referring to a social network popular among conservatives.

The tech giants would need to reiterate that “Twitter will not get special treatment and that a violation of their terms of service will result in the platform being removed from the app stores”, according to Carusone.

will twitter under elon musk be the ‘proverbial wild west’? users may have to fight bullying and misinformation on their own

Musk has said he is averse to banning people from Twitter because of misbehaviour. Photo: EPA

Musk will also face tough judgment in the court of public opinion, with Twitter users apt to turn away from the platform if it becomes hostile and flooded with misinformation, Garrett Wagner says.

Some of Musk’s own tweets have raised eyebrows; he once mocked a Tesla whistle-blower and in 2018 called a rescuer who criticised a plan to save children from a flooded cave in Thailand “a pedo guy”.

While Musk has talked about ridding Twitter of software “bots” that fire off spam, actually confirming that users are living people could prove challenging, Baird analyst Colin Sebastian told investors in a note.

Sebastian noted that Musk’s idea of charging for the coveted blue ticks that verify users’ identities is a “no-brainer”, but it is likely only a small minority of people would pay for the status.

Musk has also said he believes anyone should be able to scrutinise the software behind the service.

But that kind of transparency could come with the unintended consequence that it will just be exploited by “bad actors” who find ways to game the system to promote their posts, analysts warn.

“The rhetoric around transparency is that it will lead to an epiphany and people will change,” Garrett Wagner says. “It’s a misleading comfort to think everything will be OK if we know how it is working.”

TECH NEWS RELATED

Marvel already confirmed Doctor Doom in the MCU, but we almost missed it

We’re nowhere near a Fantastic Four cast and release date announcement, especially considering that Marvel’s search for a new director might take some time. But we’re already getting the first MCU Fantastic Four teasers. We saw Mister Fantastic (John Krasinski) in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, a ...

View more: Marvel already confirmed Doctor Doom in the MCU, but we almost missed it

Industry minister to visit Czech Republic, Poland for nuclear energy sales

SEOUL, June 27 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s Industry Minister Lee Chang-yang will visit the Czech Republic and Poland this week to support local firms in winning contracts for building new power plants there, his office said Monday. Lee is scheduled to make a two-day trip to the Czech Republic from ...

View more: Industry minister to visit Czech Republic, Poland for nuclear energy sales

States race to woo Foxconn as EV, Chip fab plan take shape

ETtech Foxconn, the largest and globally most trusted electronics manufacturer in the world and 22nd in the list of Fortune 500 companies is expanding into Semiconductor Manufacturing and is exploring the South Asian market for its next venture to build for the world. A slew of Indian states are wooing ...

View more: States race to woo Foxconn as EV, Chip fab plan take shape

Payments Council seeks government help post RBI’s fintech order

The Payments Council of India (PCI) and several fintech firms have urged the government to step in to resolve the fallout from a recent directive by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) that barred payment companies from loading credit lines onto wallets and prepaid payment instruments (PPIs).The council – under ...

View more: Payments Council seeks government help post RBI’s fintech order

TCS eyes non-metro offices to move closer to tech talent

Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) will set up offices in small cities and non-metro regions including Guwahati, Nagpur and Goa to get employees back into offices. This is aimed at encouraging collaboration among staff members as many are reluctant to go back to their base locations after working out of home, ...

View more: TCS eyes non-metro offices to move closer to tech talent

Influencers cry foul over delayed pay at Trell; 100 more staff leave firm amid troubles

Mumbai: Influencer-led video commerce platform Trell has not paid its dues to a section of content creators for the last 6-7 months, three creators told ET.About 100 employees of Trell have also voluntarily left the company over the last two months, a source familiar with the developments said.Trell, which was ...

View more: Influencers cry foul over delayed pay at Trell; 100 more staff leave firm amid troubles

Reliance, PremjiInvest, CP Group, Swiggy look to bid for Metro India unit

Mumbai/New Delhi: Reliance Retail, Thailand’s largest conglomerate Charoen Pokphand (CP) Group and food and grocery delivery platform Swiggy are competing with PremjiInvest, the investment fund managed by the family office of Indian tech billionaire Azim Premji, to buy the Indian cash-and-carry operations of German retailer Metro AG, said multiple people ...

View more: Reliance, PremjiInvest, CP Group, Swiggy look to bid for Metro India unit

Tips For Hiring An IT Expert

The measures and means by which people work are constantly changing. As time has progressed, more jobs have become computer-based. Few industries are immune from digitisation either. The scale of the change has been rapid across multiple sectors, and firms resisting the evolution of things risk slipping into obscurity. ...

View more: Tips For Hiring An IT Expert

China questions the safety of open source code amid sanctions and tech dependency risks, but can it build a viable alternative?

All for pride, pride for all Pride Month in Thailand saw both advocates and opportunists waving rainbow flags, while a bill that can pave the way for same-sex marriage moved forward

Energetic eco An upgraded Almera provides a ride that belies its diminutive displacement

Maserati looks to the heavens with new convertible

NHL Stanley Cup Final Game 6: How to Watch Lightning vs. Avalanche Live

This red flag may tell you if someone hacked into your Facebook account

Google’s Pixel 7 Pro Screen Could Be a Lot Better Outdoors

The king is coming! Motorola Edge 30 Ultra passes by 3C certification

Cold War II? NASA to build a nuclear base in the moon before Russia and China

Huawei Mate 50 series launch date – HarmonyOS 3 global launch is here

Israeli Tech Start-up Camero-Tech's AI-Powered Xaver 1000 Allows Operators to See Through Walls

Weird Alibaba EV 2022: This Electric Van Has an Airport-Style Truck Design! Will You Buy It?

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News