Summary: Researchers explore the “red flags” we commonly associate with those who become mass killers, and how possible it is to identify the signs of problematic behaviors before a person commits a crime with multiple victims.

Source: The Conversation

After mass shootings, people naturally search for answers. We also want to find the root cause.

One subject that often arises is mental illness. People, and politicians, raise questions about “red flags,” or warning signs a person might commit a violent act, and whether someone could have intervened to stop a mass murderer.

Psychiatrist Arash Javanbakht answers some questions about mental illness, mass murder and whether it’s possible to prevent horrific shootings.

1. Is a person who commits mass murder mentally ill?

Not necessarily. In psychiatry, we do not have diagnostic criteria for a mass murderer, terrorist or violent person. There are psychiatric conditions that may include anger, aggression, impulsivity, violence, or lack of remorse or empathy among their symptoms. But there is no one illness that would be found in all mass murderers, or murderers in general.

On the top of the list of the conditions that may lead to violent acts are substance use and personality disorders, specifically antisocial personality disorder.

This condition, commonly known as “psychopathy” among the public, entails disrespect for social norms and law; deceitfulness; impulsivity; aggression; lack of responsibility; and remorse.

It is highly prevalent among the criminal and prison population, and less often treated in the psychiatric clinic. That is because no one comes to the clinic asking us to fix their “lack of conscientiousness.”

Another condition is when a psychotic person has paranoid or persecutory delusions with a conviction that others are there to harm them. These conditions are rare.

In general, most of the psychiatric conditions that affect nearly a fourth of the population, such as depression, anxiety, phobias, post-traumatic stress disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, hair picking, etc., do not increase the risk of violence toward others.

As I have noted before, only a small percentage of violent acts are committed by the mentally ill, and violent behavior does not have to necessarily be coming from mental illness.

Putting a label on something can only be helpful when we are able to treat it, or when it proves the person is not responsible for the act due to the illness.

Furthermore, there could always be coincidence: A person who commits violent acts could have depression, and he or she also could have eczema. But the correlation would not necessarily be causational.

2. What is the difference between extremism and mental illness?

Broadly, a mental illness is a diagnosable condition that significantly changes one’s emotions, thinking, or behavior, and that leads to dysfunction or distress. There are more than 200 of them listed in the diagnostic manual of psychiatry. The profession does not have psychiatric diagnoses for extremism or terrorism.

Can Experts Determine Who Might Be a Mass Killer?

The person who does commit a crime is an outlier from society in terms of their behavior. Image is in the public domain

The person who does commit a crime is an outlier from society in terms of their behavior. People who are overly suggestible, isolated and angry, based on their social and environmental circumstances may get attracted to dangerous ideologies, or join a criminal group or cult. That does not qualify them for a mental illness diagnosis.

I have previously discussed humans’ tribal nature, and that in the wrong context, especially when fear circuitry in a person’s brain is hijacked by the group leaders, people can be manipulated to heinous acts in service to the tribe’s ideology.

3. Are there ‘red flag’ behaviors that can indicate risk?

Yes. In general, a person’s previous actions are great predictors of their future actions: most often, history of violence predicts future violence. However, hindsight is 20/20.

We often hear retrospectively that people remember what was wrong with a person who committed a terrible crime, while others could never think “such a nice person” would do what they did.

But in general, history of violence or abuse, substance use and history of self-harm would be among the red flag signs that the person may act violently toward others or themselves. I could also add history of paranoid or persecutory delusions to that.

The good news is that, to prevent a violent person from access to firearms, we do not need an established diagnosis of a mental illness. The history of unreasonable violence itself is enough. These measures may not prevent some of the mass shootings, but they can help with a lot of murders and deaths by suicide.

About this crime and psychology research news

Author: Arash JavanbakhtSource: The ConversationContact: Arash Javanbakht – The Conversation
Image: The image is in the public domain


Hidden microbiome fortifies animals, plants too

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain The microbiome is the collection of microbes that colonize a habitat, human body or otherwise. Because of pioneering microbiome research at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, people around the world now understand much more about the fundamental role of gut microbes in ...

View more: Hidden microbiome fortifies animals, plants too

Baltic Sea pipeline leak damages marine life and climate

In this picture provided by Swedish Coast Guard, the gas leak in the Baltic Sea from Nord Stream photographed from the Coast Guard’s aircraft on Wednesday, Sept. 27, 2022. A fourth leak on the Nord Stream pipelines has been reported off southern Sweden. Earlier, three leaks had been reported ...

View more: Baltic Sea pipeline leak damages marine life and climate

Wave sensors deployed to improve hurricane forecasts

A “chute drop” of the microSWIFT technology, which aims the device directly down, during the Sept. 26 flight. Data from this instrument developed at the UW Applied Physics Laboratory will be combined with other observations to try and improve hurricane forecasts around the world. Credit: U.S. Navy/VXS-1 crew Researchers ...

View more: Wave sensors deployed to improve hurricane forecasts

Study offers new perspective on 2008 housing crash

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain It’s been 15 years since the 2008 housing bubble burst and sent the American economy into a tailspin, but pundits and academics are still trying to get a full picture of what caused the housing crash. With housing prices at new record highs, researchers at ...

View more: Study offers new perspective on 2008 housing crash

Scientists find link between fast-melting Arctic ice and ocean acidification

Researchers, including the University of Delaware’s Zhangxian Ouyang, traveled aboard the icebreaker R/V Xue Long into an active melting zone in the Arctic Ocean to get samples for analysis. Credit: Zhangxian Ouyang, Wei-Jun Cai and Liza Wright-Fairbanks/ University of Delaware An international team of researchers have sounded new alarm ...

View more: Scientists find link between fast-melting Arctic ice and ocean acidification

Team develops method for neural net computing in water

An ionic circuit comprising hundreds of ionic transistors. Credit: Woo-Bin Jung/Harvard SEAS Microprocessors in smartphones, computers, and data centers process information by manipulating electrons through solid semiconductors, but our brains have a different system. They rely on the manipulation of ions in liquid to process information. Inspired by the ...

View more: Team develops method for neural net computing in water

Room-temperature superconducting claim is retracted

The problem appears to be some data that's not being shared.

View more: Room-temperature superconducting claim is retracted

The share of female managers in finance has increased but their earnings are still lagging far behind male managers

Saara Vaahtoniemi will publicly defend her doctoral dissertation on Friday, Sept 30, at the University of Vaasa, Finland. Credit: Riikka Kalmi / University of Vaasa The share of women managers in finance has significantly increased in Finland, but their earnings have not caught up with those of men, shows ...

View more: The share of female managers in finance has increased but their earnings are still lagging far behind male managers

How Hurricane Ian compares to Florida's most destructive storms

iOS 16.1 Beta Brings Adaptive Transparency to Original AirPods Pro

Scientists use machine learning to help fight antibiotic resistance in farmed chickens

When air and road travel dropped during COVID, so did air pollution levels

What Is the Effect of Hierarchy on Moral Behavior?

Birth Weight Could Help Identify Children at Higher Risk of Psychological Issues

Metabolism Linked to Brain Health

Unreliable Neurons Improve Brain Functionalities

U.S. agency adopts new space junk rules to reduce exploration risks

Changes in marine ecosystems are going undetected

Agricultural rewilding can help restore the environment and support production of high-welfare food, researchers say

Taking a Dip in Cold Water May Cut “Bad” Body Fat


Top Car News Car News