cities, communication, ethics, psychology, sociology

Geo-tracking apps such as Find My Kids, Google Family Linkand Apple’s FindMy are fast growing in popularity, handing parents unprecedented powers to monitor their offspring. But how are the latter experiencing what previous generations might have labelled as an intrusion into their privacy? Could these devices even hurt youths’ sense of independence?

We set out to answer these questions and more in our research project, which involved a series of one-on-one interviews with 16 parents who geo-tracked their children, and 16 teenagers who were geo-tracked (some of whom were the children of the parents interviewed).

Keeping them safe

Overall, the parents who took part in our survey claimed they were driven to use these apps not by nosiness, but a sense of care in the face of what they perceived as potentially dangerous or, at the very least, uncertain environments.

This is coherent with the profile of our subjects, who lived exclusively in urban areas and therefore tended to be sensitive to the hazards inherent to city living. “When I see what goes on in some neighbourhoods, I’m very happy for my daughter to call me when she leaves the house,” Virginie, a 38-year-old schoolteacher, explains. This feeling was also echoed by 46-year-old salesman Stéphane:

“When you look at what happened in Nice [where a terrorist ran down dozens of people with a truck in 2016], I think you’d have to be irresponsible not to want to know where your children are.”

Virginie only occasionally tracks her daughter, usually preferring to wait for her to call. Stéphane, meanwhile, takes a more insistent approach. Since the tool is already available, he believes it is every parent’s responsibility to use it. Of course, knowing a child’s geographical position cannot guarantee their safety when faced with an incident in real time, but checking where they are can help ease parental fears.

Alleviating uncertainties

Other parents surveyed admitted to monitoring their children’s geographical position only in the case of unanswered phone calls or unfulfilled requests. Rather than a systematic method of surveillance, geo-tracking acted as a “last resort” option after parents failed to reach their child.

Mohamed, a 39-year-old private-sector executive, said that he self-regulates in his use of the tool because he finds it “unhealthy” to geo-track his son except in very specific circumstances.

Alexandre, a 54-year-old baker, explained that he felt reassured when his daughter was where he expected her to be. He stated that he often experienced “doubts about whether she is OK” and wanted to know. For this reason, he “can’t stand it” when his daughter circumvents the boundaries that he sets using the app. If she turns off her phone at some point during the day, for example, this often becomes a subject of discussion later on.

Mixed reception

In cases where it was seen as a necessity, geo-tracking appeared in principle to be quite well accepted by some teenagers in our survey. Mélanie, 13, seemed to have internalised her parents’ safety warnings, saying how she always saw “weird things happening” on the news and adding that “at least, if there’s something wrong, your parents know where you are”.

However, most teenagers in our sample were critical of their parents’ use of monitoring apps. When asked whether they thought any of apps’ options were excessive, almost all commented on geo-tracking and time restrictions placed on social media.

Dylan, 16, saw the former as “a step too far,” while Florian, 17, stated that “everyone deserves their privacy, especially at a certain age”. And Julie, 16, likened the technology to a lapse of parenting:

“I think you have failed as a parent if you track your children like that, just to find out if they’re lying to you about what they’re doing and where they’re going”.

Subjective words versus objective data

In cases where the expected location did not match that provided by the app, many teenagers interviewed bemoaned the fact that the tracking device left little room for context and even less for cover-up. Unlike texts or photos, which would offer a certain margin for interpretation, young people found it much more difficult to justify an unexpected geographical position to their parents.

Some teenagers in our survey had already experienced such situations. One of the more striking accounts was that of Xavier, 15, who was unaware he was being tracked by his father and skipped a catch-up lesson to play video games with his friend. Upon returning home, he found himself faced with a technology that gave him no opportunity for discussion with his parents:

“[My dad] asked me if I had been to tutoring and I lied… Then he showed me the tablet, and there’s nothing you can say to that. It’s all there: where you were, what time…”

Trust under trial

Geo-tracking is thus not without its ramifications on intra-family relationships. Xavier, for instance, said that discovering he was being tracked has profoundly undermined the trust between him and his father. “You don’t go and install something like that if you’re not suspicious of someone,” he deplored.

Furthermore, tensions among parents may also arise regarding whether or not such tools should be used, particularly in cases of shared custody. “I have already spoken about it several times with my ex-wife,” Mohamed explains. “She has her way of raising our daughters; I have mine. We don’t have the same view of the issue.” He gave his interpretation of how such disagreements could come about: “Trust is key. If you are spying on your kids, then there’s no trust. And if there’s no trust between a father and a son, then something has really gone wrong.”

Subscribe for counterintuitive, surprising, and impactful stories delivered to your inbox every Thursday

The ability to track without being tracked oneself, the inability to switch off a device without the tracker being notified and the tracker’s preference for data over the tracked person’s word all serve to widen the gap between parents and children.

The supervision of young people’s digital activities used to be confined solely to the home (e.g., checking children’s browsing history, the photos they take, the apps they install, etc.). But geographical monitoring directly challenges young people’s need to learn to go out into the world unchaperoned, both hindering teenage autonomy and generating tensions in parent-child relationships.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.


New discovery shows that humans still have genes for a full coat of fur

The fur gene is still present in humans, according to a new study published in eLife. The new research claims that the hairlessness of certain mammals evolved at least nine different times along different branches of the mammalian family tree. It might seem like the gene has ceased to exist ...

View more: New discovery shows that humans still have genes for a full coat of fur

Qantas flight mayday: can a plane normally fly on just one engine? An aviation expert explains

You may have seen the news Qantas flight 144 from Auckland landed safely in Sydney yesterday after the pilot was forced to shut down an engine and issue a mayday call while flying over the Pacific Ocean. The plane was reportedly a ten-year-old, twin-jet Boeing 737 and was carrying 145 ...

View more: Qantas flight mayday: can a plane normally fly on just one engine? An aviation expert explains

A nuclear-powered rocket could take astronauts to Mars in just 45 days

NASA’s manned mission to Mars would take seven months with the current technology we have for rockets. However, a nuclear-powered spacecraft could make that trek in just 45 days, according to news shared by the space agency. The design, which has been in the works in some fashion for ...

View more: A nuclear-powered rocket could take astronauts to Mars in just 45 days

Hubble’s stunning Butterfly Nebula image shows how our Sun will die

The sun will die, eventually. Like any star, the one at the center of our solar system is not meant to live forever. Eventually, it will use up all of the nuclear fuel in its core and explode, becoming a shell of what it once was. Now, Hubble’s various images ...

View more: Hubble’s stunning Butterfly Nebula image shows how our Sun will die

Test Your Knowledge of the Lands Between in This Elden Ring GeoGuessr

GeoGuessr is a browser-based game that uses Google Streetview to drop players somewhere on Earth, and they must use surrounding clues to guess their current location. You have a massive advantage if you know plenty about geography, foliage, or wildlife. In a twist on that formula, a fan has ...

View more: Test Your Knowledge of the Lands Between in This Elden Ring GeoGuessr

Top 10 Best Shows Like Ginny & Georgia

Ginny & Georgia has a special quality to its production that isn’t easy to find elsewhere. special the show has, that’s uniqueness. And if you’ve just wrapped it up, we totally get that its major cliffhanger probably has you pining for something similar. So, here we’re highlighting the 10 best ...

View more: Top 10 Best Shows Like Ginny & Georgia

Hubble spotted a black hole snacking on the donut-shaped remains of a star

NASA’s Hubble space telescope spotted a black hole munching on the donut-shaped remains of a star in a galaxy nearly 300 million light-years away. The telescope was unable to capture any images of the donut-shaped remains, as the galaxy is too far away. But it was able to capture ...

View more: Hubble spotted a black hole snacking on the donut-shaped remains of a star

Scientists in Canada detected an 8 billion-year-old radio signal in a distant galaxy

Scientists have detected a record-breaking radio signal from atomic hydrogen in a very distant galaxy. The galaxy that the signal originated from is believed to have come from a galaxy at redshift z=1.29. Because of the galaxy’s immense distance, the emission line had shifted to a 48 cm line from ...

View more: Scientists in Canada detected an 8 billion-year-old radio signal in a distant galaxy

Green Bank Telescope captured the most detailed images of the Moon ever taken from Earth

Polar Ignite 3 fitness watch review: Excellent battery, not great performance

Scientists think Jupiter’s moon Io may be home to alien life

Stellantis & Vulcan look into geothermal energy in Germany

Vulcan and Stellantis explore geothermal energy to supply Rüsselsheim plant

Nreal Air smart glasses review: A lightweight augmented reality experience

Physicists have used entanglement to ‘stretch’ the uncertainty principle, improving quantum measurements

NASA already unveiled a successor to James Webb that will search for life on alien planets

Astronomers reveal the most detailed radio image yet of the Milky Way’s galactic plane

Revolutionary SBSP tech will try to beam solar power to Earth from space

Why does Nepal’s aviation industry have safety issues? An expert explains

Study claims the Milky Way is missing almost half of its regular matter


Top Car News Car News