Whether you think it’s the peak of unpredictable but exciting IndyCar street racing or a contrived mess, Nashville certainly divides opinion between drivers, teams and fans.

On the one hand, it gives us the most exciting race of the year on a street or road course and it reflects the series’ ‘any driver can win on any given weekend’ mantra. But the way in which that has happened the last two years will challenge the purists, who want to see the fastest driver and team win.

So, contrived crashfest or unpredictable but brilliant drama and action? The Race breaks down the arguments for and against what Nashville brings to the table.

For: Exciting track

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

This section pretty much speaks for itself, but the drivers absolutely love driving this track.

With good driving, even the tightest corners such as Turn 10 and 11 at the end of the lap become passing areas, and the Turn 4-8 section might be narrow and tight but it tests tyre management and shows drivers teeing up a pass later in the circuit.

Turns 4 and 9 that follow each end of the bridge are at the end of a long straight with an almost 90-degree corner at the end, so that provides plenty of overtaking opportunities.

The resurfacing done at those two corners made cars more stable in the braking zone, which also encouraged overtaking bravery. It’s likely there’d be a tonne of overtakes were there not so many caution laps and we actually saw drivers getting worse over a stint, when those who saved tyres or had better cars came to the fore. You rarely get a stint long enough to show that.

I thought Turn 9 was better before it was narrowed to include hospitality suites. But ultimately I don’t think it changed the racing massively.

This track is an instant classic. The fact that it’s in one of the most fun and vibrant cities in America is just a bonus.

For: Big comebacks are exciting

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

In the two races in Nashville, both winners have come from the back of the pack and a lap down. It means even if a driver’s qualifying is ruined (and it probably was; we’ll get on to that in a minute) like Alexander Rossi for example, who didn’t get a clean lap, they are still able to come back and race into the top five.

The short pitlane opens up strategies for drivers who have been sent to the back and can top up on fuel or get fresh tyres to give them an advantage later in the race.

Plus, there’s plenty of overtaking opportunities if you are brave enough to try and sensible enough to know when not to.

For: Bridge is dramatic

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

At no other track does IndyCar race over open water. The Korean War Veterans’ Memorial Bridge is a staggering backdrop to an already scenic cityscape.

I know that’s a side story when we should be focusing on the racing, but when a track looks like this it really adds to the prestige.

For example, Monaco hasn’t produced good racing in F1 for years, but it’s still one of the most popular events on the calendar because of the glitz, the glamour, and the harbourside backdrop.

Nashville ticks some of the same boxes for me, and the bridge certainly helps.

For: Drivers need to take responsibility

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

This is a net negative point but a positive one in terms of defending the track.

The IndyCar grid gets plenty of credit for how strong it is – both in terms of the calibre of drivers, and how close and even the field is. There’s almost a race-by-race reminder of this. So with that as context, the driving standards in Nashville have been embarrassing.

There were more caution laps this year than last. You’d have thought, knowing how last year’s race went, that the drivers would approach with a bit of hindsight and sensibility, but as soon as the engines were fired many of them chose violence instead.

It’s a shame because if everybody raced properly in Nashville, the races would be even better because there would be no need to keep closing the pack up for there to be overtaking, it can happen naturally and as cars degrade over a stint others will come to the fore.

And then we’d see the fastest driver in the best car having a shot at winning. A quaint idea that, isn’t it?

Both years the fastest driver and fastest car haven’t won. You can argue that poor driving is at the heart of that.

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

“It’s not fun when you lose out on yellows with a fast race car, but at the end of the day, it’s just IndyCar, and it’s as much of a driving issue as it is a track issue,” said Penske’s Scott McLaughlin, who was on pole and had comfortably the best package last weekend.

“I don’t blame the track at all. I think the track is a great track. Yes, it’s tight. Yes, you’ve got to be assertive when you pass, but sometimes people just don’t give up, and that’s what happens.

“But, look, I think the driving standards are great in the series. It’s just sometimes things happen. It’s racing. It’s a good spectacle.

“Unfortunately, it’s probably one too many cautions that we have. I don’t know if you are going to fix that by lengthening or shortening it. I think all the changes they did this year were fantastic.”

Against: Too many cautions

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

You’ll probably have identified some interlocking themes here, with poor driving standards leading to more cautions, which in turn often reward drivers further back and penalise the fastest driver, resulting in a wonky finishing order.

While 2021 had more cautions, nine versus the eight this year, 2022 had more laps under caution with 36/80 instead of 22/80 the year before.

Almost half a race spent pootling around under caution.

It’s no wonder the winner Scott Dixon did over 50 laps on a set of tyres. Obviously it comes down to skill that he was able to win against fresher-shod peers, but the fact it was possible is owing to how long the race spent behind the safety car.

Some of that was caused by crashes at Turns 9 and 10 which were almost always someone’s fault, so they shouldn’t be used as a stick to beat this circuit with. Instead, Turn 4-7 is where we should probably look as the downside of the circuit.

Turns 6 and 7 especially are tight and caused one of the biggest issues of the race on lap 28 when a concertina effect sent cars crashing into the back of each other like dominos with nowhere to go.

Seven total cars involved in this incident.@GrahamRahal, @PatricioOWard and @Dalton_Kellett are now OUT.

WATCH LIVE: @CNBC and @PeacockTV.#INDYCAR // #MusicCityGP pic.twitter.com/gwAZkLoNVz

— NTT INDYCAR SERIES (@IndyCar) August 7, 2022

It’s not an overtaking area and doesn’t offer much in terms of the racing. But race winner Dixon reported that the circuit is looking at that area.

“I think some changes will come in the future for kind of that [Turn] 4 through 8 section once that construction is done,” he said. “And they’re talking about even maybe we’ll go up another block and then take a left, which would be great for a passing zone as well.”

That would certainly help alleviate some of the issues in that sector.

Against: Starts in the wrong place

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

Kudos to the organiser for moving the restarts away from Turn 11, as it was too tight there last year and restarting going into an overtaking zone offered a lot of promise. I certainly argued for restarts to be moved to the bridge last year.

However, it’s created another problem.

“I don’t think that restarting on the bridge was a good thing,” said top-five finisher Colton Herta.

“I thought the closing speeds were incredibly unsafe, and I’m sure that they’re going to probably change it to something else for next year because it was really dangerous. Especially going over a bridge like that. You don’t want to go over the back of somebody.”

26 cars going over the Korean War Memorial Veterans Bridge?

Now that’s bridge traffic.

Hop onboard for Lap 1 of the #MusicCityGP. pic.twitter.com/geeR9VBgQt

— NTT INDYCAR SERIES (@IndyCar) August 8, 2022

Dixon added: “It’s better than what we had last year.

“I had a moment, too, where you come over the top, and then everybody is stopped. It’s kind of maybe a big accident waiting to happen unless they kind of make you go at the top of the bridge so you still have a sightline of people in front of you, and everybody that you do see is accelerating.”

The closing speeds were just too high and we almost saw accidents. Problem is, where should the restart zone be moved to? That’s going to take some serious thinking.

Against: Qualifying needs to be longer

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

This might be more of an IndyCar problem than a Nashville one, but it really shows here.

Callum Ilott called qualifying a “joke” after not getting a flying lap in. It’s been a problem for IndyCar on street circuits this year where crashes and mistakes have caused red flags and the clock ticks down. Felix Rosenqvist and Rossi were among the drivers not getting a fast lap in qualifying but both finished in the top 10, as did Simon Pagenaud.

It seemed there was room to extend the qualifying. I understand the schedules are tight and there’s a lot going on in IndyCar alone, not to mention cramming other series in too.

But this track provides a brilliant opportunity to showcase the fastest drivers in the best cars nailing a qualifying lap on a tight, twisty and very entertaining street circuit. We shouldn’t be robbed of that because some crash or make errors.

Conclusion

is nashville a ‘crashville’ mess or one of indycar’s best?

OK, it’s not perfect. Opening up the track through Turns 4-8 would definitely make for a cleaner race and it simply has to get the restarts sorted out and in the right place.

But fundamentally, this is a wonderful track and the organiser has done a brilliant job. This is the best of both worlds: a great track in a fun and vibrant city. Rarely do you get those two things going hand-in-hand.

Much of the blame for the criticisms of the circuit has to fall on the poor driving standards we’ve seen over the past two years. The drivers need to get together and discuss this because even after similar circumstances in 2021, they haven’t all learned their lesson to race with more give and take.

Perhaps that is a result of IndyCar’s current policy when it comes to policing incidents, where it rarely gives out penalties for on-track collisions. But still, drivers just need to work together to stay in the event and not ruin it with half a race of caution laps.

With the right approach and a few tweaks, Nashville is, in my eyes the second best race on the calendar after the Indianapolis 500.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Alex Bowman to Miss Talladega With Concussion-like Symptoms

Bowman is the latest to miss time after a crash in a Next Gen car that has produced a worrying number of concussions in its first season.

View more: Alex Bowman to Miss Talladega With Concussion-like Symptoms

The Citroën Oli Is A Pickup Truck Made Of Cardboard

After revealing a refreshed logo a few days back , French carmaker Citroën has revealed a concept car that’s meant to provide an “unconventional” look at family mobility with the Oli. Stylized as the “oli,” it’s a pickup truck that goes against the trend of big screens and gadgets. ...

View more: The Citroën Oli Is A Pickup Truck Made Of Cardboard

Zilisch’s Victory Narrows Mazda MX-5 Title Chase

BRASELTON, Ga. — The Idemitsu Mazda MX-5 Cup presented by BFGoodrich Tires title chase narrowed to 30 points on Thursday courtesy of Connor Zilisch’s victory in the No. 72 Hixon Motor Sports entry. Zilisch beat teammate Selin Rollan to the checkered flag by 0.123-second. Championship leader Jared Thomas finished ...

View more: Zilisch’s Victory Narrows Mazda MX-5 Title Chase

Ricciardo ‘at peace’ with Formula 1 future

Daniel Ricciardo Daniel Ricciardo is at peace with whatever his Formula 1 future may be. The Australian is likely to be absent from the grid next season after agreeing to the early termination of his contract with McLaren. With limited opportunities available, and other drivers seemingly ahead of him ...

View more: Ricciardo ‘at peace’ with Formula 1 future

Tander talks Edwards engineer adjustment

The #97 ZB Commodore Garth Tander has explained the intricacies of working with a new engineer as he prepares for next weekend’s Repco Bathurst 1000. Tander will partner Shane van Gisbergen at Red Bull Ampol Racing, marking the pairing’s fourth Great Race together. Van Gisbergen welcomed a new race ...

View more: Tander talks Edwards engineer adjustment

Here’s how Americans feel about home backup power – and rising outages

As Hurricane Ian slammed into Florida, Goal Zero, a Bluffdale, Utah-based portable clean energy company, released survey results that found 84% of Americans worry about power outages and 26% feel vulnerable to power outages. So here’s how Americans feel about mitigating blackouts with backup power. The online survey that ...

View more: Here’s how Americans feel about home backup power – and rising outages

A brand new all-electric boat racing series begins in 2023

Powerboat racing events have traditionally focused on high-speed, gas-guzzling watercraft, but a gradual shift into electrified racing boats is taking place thanks in part to the introduction of the RaceBird, a fully electric powerboat designed to compete in the all-electric E1 Series starting in 2023. This electric shift is ...

View more: A brand new all-electric boat racing series begins in 2023

Watch: The ultimate guide to EVs is here! Zooming with DRIVEN EP105

On Zooming with DRIVEN this week, the ultimate guide to every new hybrid and electric car you can buy in NZ! David chats about the Nissan X-Trail launch, and Dean checks out the Christchurch EV expo.  Also, a sneak preview of the guide to New Zealand EV chargers video, ...

View more: Watch: The ultimate guide to EVs is here! Zooming with DRIVEN EP105

ROAD TEST: 2022 Mercedes-Benz EQS SUV review

‘No more excuses’ – New York announces new zero-emission vehicle mandate by 2035

An Apple executive is leaving the company after being filmed joking about fondling 'big-breasted women' in a viral TikTok video

5 Best New Vehicles With Leather Seats in 2022 According to TrueCar

Is the Ford Maverick’s Truck Bed the Size of a Piece of Plywood?

Was There Ever a Chrysler 300 Hellcat?

Game on: Mercedes-AMG’s new C 63 S is a plug-in hybrid and more powerful than ever

How to survive in the wild

2023 Ram 2500 Heavy Duty Rebel Joins the Off-Road Party

Prime Day 2.0? Score Amazing Deals Before Black Friday on Auto Parts, Gear, Tools, Tires, and More

'No Time to Die' Aston Martin DB5 Raises $3.2 Million at Auction

Toyota Tops Two Categories In J.D. Power Brand Loyalty Study

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News