from the magazine, classified information, national security, u.s. space force

The Joint Task Force-Space Defense Commercial Operations cell conducts an exercise in Colorado Springs, Colorado. Credit: U.S. Space Force Photo by Lekendrick Stallworth

Secrecy is innate to military space, and it’s been that way since the start. But officials are increasingly expressing frustration with a classification system that at times appears to be doing more harm than good.

The culture of secrecy emerged in the opening decades of the space age when only two superpowers owned the domain. Space has since gone global, with 90 countries belonging to the once highly exclusive club, including many U.S. allies.

Today’s U.S. military space leaders frequently trumpet the importance of international partnerships. They point out that the security challenges in outer space are global and the United States can’t do it all. The Space Force, for example, talks about creating hybrid networks — and has advocated for joint programs with other nations.

But the rhetoric rings hollow if information cannot be shared, said Maj. Gen. Doug Schiess, who runs U.S. Space Command’s Combined Force Space Component Command.

Schiess’ organization, responsible for monitoring and analyzing objects and activities in orbit, brings in officers from allied countries to work side-by-side with U.S. space operators. He said it is becoming more difficult to share information, even with close partners, because documents routinely are labeled NOFORN, meaning they cannot be shared with foreign nationals.

“All too often we slap a ‘NOFORN’ control on a sensitive document,” Schiess said at a recent industry conference.

“There are times, of course, when the NOFORN label is required, but lately it’s become too universal,” he said. “If we’re going to be truly integrated by design, we need to ensure our allies and our partners have access to the information they need to accomplish the mission,” he added. “I can assure you our senior leaders are paying attention to this.”

Facilitating work with allies also is a priority of Air Force Secretary Frank Kendall who recently sent new guidance to Department of the Air Force employees on the use of the NOFORN label. He is asking managers to be more selective in what gets billed as “no foreign” and make sure it doesn’t unnecessarily undermine efforts to work more closely with allies.

Kendall’s guidance is reflected in a recent memo that assistant secretary of the Air Force for space acquisitions Frank Calvelli sent to procurement agencies. One of the directives in the memo is to “avoid SAPs and over-classifying.”

SAP, or Special Access Programs, is a specific category that imposes much tighter access restrictions than normally required for information at the same classification level.

Putting programs in the SAP category “hinders our ability to integrate space capabilities across other domains … and can hinder getting ideas from a broader pool of industry, and future sharing with allies,” Calvelli wrote. “Protect capabilities, if necessary, through normal security classification guidelines such as SECRET and TOP SECRET but avoid creating stovepipes with SAPs.”

Space Force officials also have suggested that talking more openly about U.S. military capabilities would make enemies think twice before attacking the United States. “If you have everything classified, that really erodes your ability to deter conflict. You have to be able to talk about your capabilities,” Gen. John “Jay” Raymond, the first chief of the Space Force, said last year.

This mindset appears to have influenced Kendall’s decision to reveal the Air Force’s B-21 stealth bomber at a Dec. 2 event at Northrop Grumman’s facilities in Palmdale, California. The Air Force to date has only shown renderings.

Charles Beames, a space industry executive who once worked on classified space programs at the Pentagon, has been a longtime critic of overclassification.

“People are rewarded for saying declassification is a good thing, but they’re not rewarded for actually doing it,” said Beames.

The defense secretary, the director of national intelligence and others in the executive branch of the U.S. government have the authority to declassify. “It isn’t hard to do at all. It can be done in a memo,” Beames said. “But there’s no reward for them to do it. It takes a lot of courage and people can risk their careers.”

Of course, there are always things that should be kept secret, but the space business takes it to the extreme compared to other sectors of the military, he said. “It’s a weird cultural thing.”


from the magazine, classified information, national security, u.s. space force

 

Sandra Erwin covers military space for SpaceNews. She is a veteran national security journalist and former editor of National Defense magazine.

“On National Security” appears in every issue of SpaceNews magazine. This column ran in the November 2022 issue.

TECH NEWS RELATED

NASA Makes Asteroid Defense a Priority, Moving its NEO Surveyor Mission Into the Development Phase

There’s an old adage in the engineering field – what gets funded gets built. So it’s sure to be a happy time over at the Planetary Society, as NEO Surveyor, the project the organization has primarily supported over the past few years, has made it through NASA’s grueling budgetary ...

View more: NASA Makes Asteroid Defense a Priority, Moving its NEO Surveyor Mission Into the Development Phase

Lightweight Picogram-Scale Probes Could be the Best way to Explore Other Star Systems

Inspiration for space exploration can come from all corners. One of the most inspiring, or terrifying, sources of inspiration for some in space exploration came from computer science expert John von Neumann, who laid out a framework for self-replicating machines in a series of lectures he gave in 1948. ...

View more: Lightweight Picogram-Scale Probes Could be the Best way to Explore Other Star Systems

The Universe is Brighter Than we Thought

Over seven years ago, the New Horizons mission made history when it became the first spacecraft to conduct a flyby of Pluto. In the leadup to this encounter, the spacecraft provided updated data and images of many objects in the inner and outer Solar System. Once beyond the orbit ...

View more: The Universe is Brighter Than we Thought

Is the Milky Way… Normal?

Studying the large-scale structure of our galaxy isn’t easy. We don’t have a clear view of the Milky Way’s shape and features like we do of other galaxies, largely because we live within it. But we do have some advantages. From within, we’re able to carry out close-up surveys ...

View more: Is the Milky Way… Normal?

Anti-Helium Generated in the Large Hadron Collider can Help in the Search for Dark Matter

For decades, astrophysicists have theorized that the majority of matter in our Universe is made up of a mysterious invisible mass known as “Dark Matter” (DM). While scientists have not yet found any direct evidence of this invisible mass or confirmed what it looks like, there are several possible ...

View more: Anti-Helium Generated in the Large Hadron Collider can Help in the Search for Dark Matter

Webb’s New Image Reveals a Galaxy Awash in Star Formation

When a spiral galaxy presents itself just right, observations reveal more detail. That’s the case with NGC 7469, a spiral galaxy about 220 million light-years away. It’s face-on towards us, and the James Webb Space Telescope captured its revealing scientific portrait. NGC 7469 is scientifically interesting for a number ...

View more: Webb’s New Image Reveals a Galaxy Awash in Star Formation

SpaceX wins Sentinel 6B radar satellite launch contract

SpaceX has won a contract to launch the joint US-European Sentinel 6B radar satellite as early as November 2025. Five years ago, NASA also chose SpaceX to launch Sentinel 6A, the first of two identical satellites designed to use radar altimeters to determine global sea levels more accurately than ...

View more: SpaceX wins Sentinel 6B radar satellite launch contract

Scientists Investigate Potential Regolith Origin on Uranus’ Moon, Miranda

In a recent study published in The Planetary Science Journal, a pair of researchers led by The Carl Sagan Center at the SETI Institute in California investigated the potential origin for the thick regolith deposits on Uranus’ moon, Miranda. The purpose of this study was to determine Miranda’s internal ...

View more: Scientists Investigate Potential Regolith Origin on Uranus’ Moon, Miranda

A Star Came too Close to a Black Hole. It Didn’t End Well

Perseverance Places its First Sample on the Surface of Mars. One Day This Will be in the Hands of Scientists on Earth

SpaceX might launch first Starlink Gen2 satellites next week

NASA Just Tested a new Engine That Will Launch Artemis V and Beyond

This Will Probably Be InSight’s Last Picture Before it Runs Out of Power Forever

Webb Stares Deeply Into the Universe, Showing How Galaxies Assemble

Astronomers Scanned 12 Planets for Alien Signals While They Were in Front of Their Stars

What Kind of an Impact did DART Have on Dimorphos? The Science Results are Here

Comet Impacts Could Have Brought the Raw Ingredients for Life to Europa’s Ocean

SpaceX’s Starlink satellite internet gains 750,000 subscribers in nine months

Ukraine will get 10,000+ more Starlink antennas

Astronomers Spot Stars in the Most Distant Galaxies for the First Time

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News