commentary

Taiwanese companies have been adding more and more independent directors to their boards and increasing the overall level of board independence during recent years. Is this contributing to the overall effectiveness of board oversight and performance of Taiwanese companies? Or are these independent directors reticent to challenge management over fear of losing their board position?

Many global organizations and institutional investors advocate an independent majority on the board of directors. Proponents suggest that an independent majority board is better able to foster independent decision-making and will consider the best interests of all shareholders, reducing conflicts of interest. Although an independent majority board may be more common for US-based corporations it is still very rare to have more than 50% of a board classified as independent in most Asian countries.

Currently in Taiwan only 4% of listed-companies have a majority-independent board of directors. The International Corporate Governance Network (ICGN) explains independence as those “who are able to exercise independent judgement free from any external influence.” The ICGN guidelines suggest that a director would generally be not considered independent if he/she was recently a former employee, worked for a material supplier/customer, was paid outside remuneration by the company for services other than the directorship or is a reasonably significant shareholder.

These are standard requirements that are echoed by many organizations and regulators in their varied definitions of independence. The ICGN goes further to highlight that independence may also be compromised if the director has or had close family ties with any of the company’s advisers, directors or senior management; holds cross-directorships or has significant links with other directors through involvement in other companies or bodies; and is or has been a nominee director as a representative of minority shareholders or the state.

In Taiwan, candidates for independent directors can be nominated by minority shareholders. Taiwan’s regulations are quite supportive in protecting minority shareholders rights with the requirement of cumulative voting for directors, something which is uncommon in other regions. Minority shareholders holding 1% of shares outstanding can nominate a candidate or a full slate of candidates to the board during the nomination period.

In Taiwan, a seat on a board of directors can sometimes be won with as little as 2% shareholder support or could require as high as 12% during a contested election. Does this mean that candidates nominated by shareholders are less independent than those nominated by the management? Not necessarily, independent directors have a fiduciary duty to help to ensure that decisions are made in the best interest of the corporation.

The ability for a director to participate effectively on the board is dependent on many factors such as financial acumen, relevant experience, communication skills and strength of character. Independent directors can contribute to the boards by monitoring management but also by leveraging their relevant expertise in board discussions and strategic decision-making.

The independent directors play a very important role in board oversight in Taiwan by participating on the Audit Committee, Remuneration Committee and other special committees formed to review transactions. Regulations in Taiwan allow shareholders holding 50% of shares for at least 3 months to freely call an Extraordinary Shareholder Meeting (EGM). There is also the option, in theory, for a shareholder who has held 3% of shares for at least a year to call for an EGM, but this requires regulatory approval which could be difficult to receive.

Independent directors in Taiwan have also been given the power to call EGMs if he or she feels that is necessary to do so, generally in the interest of better corporate governance. In principle, this is an important means to hinder decisions being made at board level that are only beneficial to a smaller group of shareholders or are not in the interests of the majority of stakeholders.

In practice, some EGMs have been called by independent directors to ensure shareholder approval for important issues that affect all shareholders but it has also been used to call early board elections, remove directors from the board, or seek management control changes which are not always in the best interests of advancing shareholder value.

Should an EGM only be convened by an independent director when all independent directors approve? This could be a limitation to the key objective of holding management to account. If the result of a board election would also mean current independent directors being removed, it may be harder for these independent directors to be impartial.

Are there may be other ways to ensure better oversight but to safeguard that this power is used for the best interests of the company and not abused? In the global investment community there is increasing support for boards to appoint a Lead Independent Director. This role currently exists in markets such as the UK, US, Australia and Singapore when the Chairperson and CEO are held by the same person or a non-independent chair.

The Lead Independent Director (LID) can help to maintain a counterbalance on the board and also helps in areas such as overseeing communications with shareholders, offering input to the board agenda and providing leadership to other independent directors. In the Taiwan market there are more than 500 listed companies where the Chairperson also retains the title of CEO.

Editor’s note

To give our readers a more in-depth and comprehensive knowledge about investor relations from the investor’s perspective, DIGITIMES has invited QIC as a contributing partner to share their insights. The article is the 17th part of the QIC Inside Investor Relations Series, which was originally published on QIC website.)

QIC
Photo: QIC

TECH NEWS RELATED

Several Tech Companies Affected in China’s Heatwave as Supply Factories Closes

Tech companies are affected by the heatwave that China is experiencing now as the Sichuan province, where all of their factories are located, implemented a six-day lockdown for these factories to ease a power shortage to help the country’s crisis, based on a report by The Verge. (Photo : WANG ...

View more: Several Tech Companies Affected in China’s Heatwave as Supply Factories Closes

Apple: iPhone 14 to Go On Sale on September 16, A Week After Launch [RUMORS]

Apple is seeing rumors for its iPhone 14 that is set to reveal this September 7, and the device is to be available by September 16, more than a week after its release event. The company is seeing yet another September Fall event for the new iPhone that will bring ...

View more: Apple: iPhone 14 to Go On Sale on September 16, A Week After Launch [RUMORS]

Russian astronauts' spacewalk disrupted by spacesuit issue

A screenshot of a video footage shows Roscosmos’ cosmonauts Oleg Artemyev and Denis Matveev conduct their spacewalk on the International Space Station, August 17, 2022. /CFP Two Russian astronauts ended their spacewalk earlier than planned on Wednesday as one of them had a battery issue with his spacesuit, Russia’s ...

View more: Russian astronauts' spacewalk disrupted by spacesuit issue

OnePlus 8 and 8 Pro to get OxygenOS 13 earlier than expected

Back in the last week, OnePlus introduced OxygenOS 13 with the first beta for the OnePlus 10 Pro. It’s natural to see the company rolling out the update to its flagship firsts. This week, the OnePlus 10 Pro got the second Open Beta. Apparently, OnePlus addressed the issues with delayed ...

View more: OnePlus 8 and 8 Pro to get OxygenOS 13 earlier than expected

Janet Jackson's 'Rhythm Nation' Caused Windows XP-Era Laptops to Crash, Says Microsoft Principal Software Engineer

Some pop songs enliven people and get them into the groove, but for a chart-topping hit of music legend Janet Jackson in 1989, the effect was so engrossing that laptop users playing the song’s music video caused their hardware to crash. Repeated Playback of ‘Rhythm Nation’ Led to Laptops, ...

View more: Janet Jackson's 'Rhythm Nation' Caused Windows XP-Era Laptops to Crash, Says Microsoft Principal Software Engineer

OnePlus 10 Pro gets OxygenOS 13 Open Beta 2 update

OnePlus started its pursuit of the stable Android 13 version back in the last week. As usual, the OnePlus 10 Pro as the company’s flagship was the first to get it. The device got its first OxygenOS 13 Open Beta to build in the last week. Now, the company is ...

View more: OnePlus 10 Pro gets OxygenOS 13 Open Beta 2 update

India won’t follow in EU’s footsteps, exploring two types of chargers

The Indian government has confirmed that it will set up expert groups to consider using common chargers for portable electronic items. These chargers will be used for charging smartphones as well. Consumers Affairs Secretary Rohit Kumar Singh made the announcement and raised concerns over e-waste. Moreover, Singh revealed that industry ...

View more: India won’t follow in EU’s footsteps, exploring two types of chargers

Sunplus cautious about 2H22 amid macro headwinds

IC design house Sunplus Technology has expressed caution about its business prospects for the second half of 2022, as customers request shipment deferrals amid inflation and other macro concerns. Specializing in IC solutions for multimedia and automotive applications, Sunplus indicated that end-market demand has turned weak despite the easing of ...

View more: Sunplus cautious about 2H22 amid macro headwinds

Amazon testing TikTok-style feed on its app, AI firm says

China's largest container-like computing facility connects to network

Oops! Google rolls Android 12 instead of 13 to some users

No turbos, no electric motors, the new Porsche 911 GT3 RS is pure race car for the road

Scientists Develop 'Artificial Leaves' Made for Clean Fuel Production in UK

Heatwave in China Causes Factories Supplying to Tesla, Apple, and More to Shutdown

HP launches cartridge recycling partner initiative in ASEAN

In security, what is zk-SNARK?

Apple Releases Security Updates to Fix Two Zero-Day Vulnerabilities Attackers Use to Hack iPhones, iPads, and Macs

Tesla Denies Bloomberg’s Report Claiming Legal Exec’s Departure in a Rare Twitter Response

Sony Opens Another Public Queue for PlayStation 5 Restock

Android 13 will reach Vivo X80 Pro and iQOO 9 Pro users soon

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News