study finds law enforcement is hampering harm reduction programs
Negative law enforcement experiences reported by SSP participants. Credit: Harm Reduction Journal (2022). DOI: 10.1186/s12954-022-00690-w

In 2016, North Carolina enacted legislation providing legal protections to people who make use of programs designed to reduce harms associated with illegal drug use. However, a new study finds these legal protections are not recognized uniformly by law enforcement, raising questions about the extent to which the actions of law enforcement personnel are hampering the effectiveness of these programs.

“Harm reduction efforts, such as syringe services programs (SSPs), are scientifically proven to reduce overdoses and communicable diseases without exacerbating drug use,” says Jennifer Carroll, an assistant professor of anthropology at North Carolina State University and lead researcher on the study.

“SSPs are also effective at linking people to substance use treatment, but harm reduction services are only effective if people feel safe using them. The goal of the legal protections put into place in North Carolina in 2016 was to save lives by ensuring that people could safely engage with these programs without fear of being charged with illegal syringe and paraphernalia possession. With that in mind, we wanted to know if people using SSPs since the passage of the 2016 legal protections felt that the protections were being honored by law enforcement.”

“This study is not only relevant to North Carolina, but also raises important questions about whether similar challenges may be hampering efforts across the country. This is a particularly timely question, because a tremendous amount of money is about to be injected into counties across the country as a result of the Global Opioid Settlement, with the goal of reducing harms associated with opioids. SSPs are some of the key opioid mitigation strategies allowable under the global settlement.”

The study focused specifically on the experiences of SSP participants, meaning people who use drugs and seek harm reduction services such as access to sterile syringes, overdose prevention and response training, and other evidence-based public health tools—such as naloxone and fentanyl test strips.

“Our study focuses on the relevant experiences SSP participants have with law enforcement, but its findings do not explicitly address the impact those experiences had on their use of SSPs,” says Brandon Morrissey, a Ph.D. student at NC State and first author of the paper. “However, the findings do raise questions about the effectiveness of the existing legal protections—as well as whether law enforcement’s failure to acknowledge those protections is limiting the public health benefit of the SSPs.”

For the study, researchers surveyed 414 people from across North Carolina who make use of SSPs. The survey addressed a variety of issues related to study participants’ drug use, their use of SSPs and their related experiences with law enforcement. More than half of participants reported having “negative experiences” with law enforcement related to the implementation of the 2016 legal protections.

For example, study participants frequently reported that law enforcement officials said they weren’t aware of the law; refused to accept the documentation showing that the syringes or other supplies were from an SSP; confiscated the supplies participants received from the SSP; or arrested participants for having the supplies.

“Put simply, the benefit of harm reduction programs is severely handicapped when law enforcement officials confiscate clean needles or naloxone from people who have obtained those supplies from a state-recognized SSP,” Carroll says.

“Our findings show that, despite laws which protect SSP participants from charges, negative law enforcement experiences are still widely reported,” Morrissey says. “Evidence-based policy interventions to reduce fatal overdose are undermined by these experiences.”

The study also found that the behavior of law enforcement officials in regard to the 2016 legal protections varies tremendously from county to county.

“This suggests that law enforcement leadership at the local level is influencing how law enforcement officials interpret the legal protections,” Carroll says. “This, in turn, suggests that stronger state-level guidance is needed regarding how law enforcement should be implementing these legal protections.”

The paper is published in Harm Reduction Journal. More information: Brandon Morrissey et al, “They don’t go by the law around here”: law enforcement interactions after the legalization of syringe services programs in North Carolina, Harm Reduction Journal (2022). DOI: 10.1186/s12954-022-00690-w Provided by North Carolina State University Citation: Study finds law enforcement is hampering harm reduction programs (2022, September 29) retrieved 29 September 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-09-law-hampering-reduction.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Young scientist becomes first Vietnamese awarded by UK Royal Aeronautical Society

Dr. Nguyen Huyen Duc was granted the Young Persons’ Achievement Award 2022 by the UK’s Royal Aeronautical Society. (Source: VietnamPlus) London (VNA) – With the Young Persons’ Achievement Award, Dr. Nguyen Huyen Duc has become the first Vietnamese scientist to receive the prize from the UK’s Royal Aeronautical Society (RAeS).Duc is the ...

View more: Young scientist becomes first Vietnamese awarded by UK Royal Aeronautical Society

Ram 1500 Revolution BEV Concept: Everything We Know

Our exclusive rendering based on official teaser images shows how the electric truck might look.

View more: Ram 1500 Revolution BEV Concept: Everything We Know

AIS joins e-waste blockchain initiative

Ms Saichon unveils the blockchain-based E-Waste+ platform. Advanced Info Service Plc (AIS), Thailand's biggest mobile operator by subscriber base, has joined hands with partners to launch an electronic waste blockchain system that allows users to track and trace e-waste through the recycling process and calculate carbon reduction scores. Blockchain-based ...

View more: AIS joins e-waste blockchain initiative

Huawei committed to cultivating digital talent

From left, David Li, chief executive of Huawei Technologies Thailand, Mr Supachai, acting Capt Montree Munkong, advisor to the Digital Economy and Society minister, and Mr Deng at the Thailand Talent Transformation Symposium. Global multinational Huawei Technologies has joined hands with partners in the public and private sectors to ...

View more: Huawei committed to cultivating digital talent

Fans are going nuts over this official Avengers concept art

Avengers: Infinity War is one of the highlights of the MCU, a movie worth revisiting time and again. The film delivers various iconic moments as the Avengers try to stop Thanos (Josh Brolin) from obtaining all six Infinity Stones. As a result, we witness several exciting team-ups as the Avengers ...

View more: Fans are going nuts over this official Avengers concept art

iCloud backups will now be end-to-end encrypted

Apple has just made a couple of significant security announcements. The most noteworthy is that iCloud backups will now be end-to-end encrypted. This is part of a larger security initiatives that Apple is calling Advanced Data Protection which will see the number of data categories being end-to-end encrypted rising ...

View more: iCloud backups will now be end-to-end encrypted

Hong Kong’s Pando Finance launches blockchain-themed ETF to give investors a taste of cryptocurrencies ‘with minimum risk’

Hong Kong-based asset management company Pando Finance has launched a blockchain-themed exchange-traded fund (ETF) on the city’s bourse, to allow retail investors to gain exposure to the industry “with minimum risk”, less than a month after cryptocurrency exchange FTX declared bankruptcy. Pando Finance’s two actively-managed ETFs with a focus ...

View more: Hong Kong’s Pando Finance launches blockchain-themed ETF to give investors a taste of cryptocurrencies ‘with minimum risk’

SpaceCREST Cybersecurity Platform will protect Space Communications hardware for DARPA program

Redwire Corporation (NYSE: RDW), a leader in space infrastructure for the next generation space economy, reports that its suite of space cybersecurity tools developed with BigBear.ai (NYSE: BBAI), an AI-powered analytics and cyber engineering solutions company, will be used by Mynaric (NASDAQ: MYNA) (FRA: M0YN) in the development of ...

View more: SpaceCREST Cybersecurity Platform will protect Space Communications hardware for DARPA program

How Silicon Valley looks at the Taiwan miracle (9): Ethnic Chinese associations and industry leaders

Raiders vs. Rams live stream: How to watch Thursday Night Football

ICEYE announces a framework contract with European Maritime Safety Agency

Mad Money's Jim Cramer Advises Investors to Get out of Crypto — Says 'It's Never Too Late to Sell'

Elon Musk found a successor to act as Tesla Global CEO

Indian GCCs to add 3.64 million jobs over next 12 months

Scoop: HUL, other FMCG majors in sale talks with nutrition firm Oziva

Exclusive: Swiggy may fire 250 employees in December, more layoffs possible in coming months

Social platforms flag age-gating fears in MeitY’s IT rules meet

Spice Money to offer B2B transactions on ONDC next quarter

iPhone 14’s Emergency SOS via satellite feature may launch in the UK next week

New kilonova has astronomers rethinking what we know about gamma-ray bursts

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News