Take-Two Interactive has been ordered to pay damages to a tattoo artist who created the Viper's distinctive work.

Tattoo artist lays a legal RKO on Take-Two over Randy Orton's ink in WWE 2K games

(Image credit: AMER HILABI (Getty Images))

An unusual lawsuit between tattoo artist Catherine Alexander and Take-Two Interactive has concluded with a victory for Alexander, who argued successfully that WWE 2K16, WWE 2K17 and WWE 2K18 reproduced her work without her permission.

The roots of the case go way back to 2009, when Alexander attempted to negotiate a licensing deal with game publisher Take-Two Interactive for the tattoos she’d inked on pro wrestler Randy Orton between 2002 and 2008. Take-Two rejected the proposal, but offered her $450 for the right to use the images; she refused, but Take-Two went ahead and used them anyway.

Alexander pursued the matter in court, winning a small victory in 2020 when a judge rejected a request for a summary judgment (opens in new tab) in Take-Two’s favor and instead ruled that the publisher and WWE did in fact copy her work, and that she may have suffered damages as a result. The judge in the case declared that “authenticity” is a major selling point for the WWE games, and that “WWE would have rejected Orton’s videogame persona if it appeared without his tattoos or appeared with tattoos that were different than Orton’s actual tattoos.”

In a ruling (opens in new tab) issued on September 30 (via VGC (opens in new tab)), the US District Court for the Southern District of Illinois came down firmly in Alexander’s favor, although for a relatively small amount. The appearance of the tattoos in the game do not qualify as fair use, according to the ruling, which awarded $3,750 to Alexander. The amount wasn’t greater because the court found that none of the profits earned by sales of the game could be attributed to the presence of the tattoos. 

Still, while the award is relatively paltry, it could compel other game publishers to take licensing negotiations with other tattoo artists more seriously in the future. (And, likewise, could convince tattoo artists to more aggressively pursue such deals, too.)

Tattoo artist lays a legal RKO on Take-Two over Randy Orton's ink in WWE 2K games

(Image credit: Take-Two Interactive)

This isn’t the first time that Take-Two has been sued over tattoos in its videogames. In 2016 it was sued by Solid Oak Sketches over work that appeared on Lebron James, Kenyon Martin, and Eric Bledsoe in the NBA 2K games. But in that case, as noted by The Hollywood Reporter (opens in new tab), it won, because the players had granted a license to use their likeness to the NBA, which in turn licensed them to Take-Two.

Andy Chalk

Andy has been gaming on PCs from the very beginning, starting as a youngster with text adventures and primitive action games on a cassette-based TRS80. From there he graduated to the glory days of Sierra Online adventures and Microprose sims, ran a local BBS, learned how to build PCs, and developed a longstanding love of RPGs, immersive sims, and shooters. He began writing videogame news in 2007 for The Escapist and somehow managed to avoid getting fired until 2014, when he joined the storied ranks of PC Gamer. He covers all aspects of the industry, from new game announcements and patch notes to legal disputes, Twitch beefs, esports, and Henry Cavill. Lots of Henry Cavill.

TECH NEWS RELATED

Suburban Horror HELLO NEIGHBOR 2 Launches Early For Deluxe Edition Owners

Publisher tinyBuild has announced that the long-anticipated sequel to the 2017 stealth horror game Hello Neighbor is being made available to play early for players who have purchased the game’s Deluxe Edition.  While the official release date hits on December 6th, pre-orders of the Deluxe Edition of Hello Neighbor ...

View more: Suburban Horror HELLO NEIGHBOR 2 Launches Early For Deluxe Edition Owners

Warzone 2.0 DMZ Strongholds guide: enemies, loot, and more

Warzone was a breakout hit for the Call of Duty franchise. This standalone, free-to-play battle royale game took the popular mode and infused it with the rock-solid gameplay and mechanics people come to the CoD franchise for. After a few years, we finally have our hands on the latest version ...

View more: Warzone 2.0 DMZ Strongholds guide: enemies, loot, and more

The Annual Yogscast Jingle Jam Is Here!

It’s time to open your wallets for charity as the Yogscast Jingle Jam 2022 is here! So, for anyone not in the know, The Yogscast is a gaming-focused British youtube channel and corporation – much like Rooster Teeth in the US. Since their start in the early days of ...

View more: The Annual Yogscast Jingle Jam Is Here!

Mythical Pokemon Keldeo debuts in Pokemon Go next week during the Mythic Blade event

Next week, Pokemon Go players can catch the Mythical Pokemon Keldeo, the Fighting colt Pokemon. The cutie will be available in its normal form during the event and will know the featured attack Sacred Sword. Keldeo has been sighted for the first time in Pokemon Go You will be ...

View more: Mythical Pokemon Keldeo debuts in Pokemon Go next week during the Mythic Blade event

THE WITCHER Rides Again In A Crossover With LOST ARK

For all you Witcher fans out there who also play Lost Ark, there’s some amazing news! Amazon Games and Smilegate RPG have teamed up with CD Projekt Red for a crossover event between the two series. The limited-time crossover will bring Geralt of Rivia, Yennefer of Vengerberg, Cirilla Fiona ...

View more: THE WITCHER Rides Again In A Crossover With LOST ARK

Quirky Adventure Game EASTWARD Out On Xbox

Stardew Valley publisher Chucklefish has announced that their story-rich adventure RPG Eastward has officially made the jump to Xbox, following its success on PC and Nintendo Switch. The brainchild of Shanghai-based developer Pixpil, Eastward follows the story of John and Sam, a hardworking miner and a mysterious girl, whose ...

View more: Quirky Adventure Game EASTWARD Out On Xbox

Mini Review: Super Kiwi 64 - An N64-Style Platformer Ripe With Tricksy Energy

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? Right first time—it was a bird

View more: Mini Review: Super Kiwi 64 - An N64-Style Platformer Ripe With Tricksy Energy

New Update For CRUSADER KINGS 3 Is Here

Paradox Interactive has just released a new update for their hit role-playing, 4X, grand strategy game Crusader Kings 3. CK3 has been a huge success in the 4X grand strategy scene since its release in 2020 as the much-anticipated sequel to the much beloved Crusader Kings 2. The main ...

View more: New Update For CRUSADER KINGS 3 Is Here

Skryim mod adds fully-voiced DLC inspired by Mass Effect, Dragon Age

Pet Trading Card Simulator Codes (December 2022)

Genshin Impact publisher Cognosphere takes legal action against leaker Ubatcha

Best Nvidia Filters for Warzone 2

Warframe On Switch Just Got A Cross Platform Play Update

How to get Seviper Fang in Pokémon Scarlet and Violet

Firearms Expert Reacts To Warhammer 40,000: Darktide’s Guns

Mega Blaziken Raid Guide For Pokémon GO: Heading To Hoenn

NEED FOR SPEED UNBOUND Review: Racing In My Own Style

How to get Zangoose Claw in Pokémon Scarlet and Violet

All New BENDY Merch Is Here In Time For The Holidays!

Feature: Our Verdict On Splatoon 3's Chill Season 2022 Update - New Stages, Weapons, And Modes

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News