A fortnight after five lions escaped at Sydney’s Taronga Zoo, an amused zoo visitor captured footage of Echo the superb lyrebird as he mimicked alarm sirens and evacuation calls with astonishing accuracy.

News outlets were quick to link the lyrebird’s alarm impersonation with the lion’s great escape. But while this tale made for a great headline, the truth of this story is far more interesting.

Superb lyrebirds are arguably the bird world’s greatest mimics. Using their phenomenal voiceboxes, males will sing elaborate songs and perfectly imitate sounds made by other birds to impress prospective mates.

Not only this, they share songs in a form of cultural transmission. In the wild, some songs become more popular while others wane. Think of it as pop charts for the bush.

But Echo was bred in captivity. He wasn’t exposed to wild song culture. Instead, he learned from what he was exposed to – and that includes “songs” like the alarm call. Echo had been practising this call for years to get it that good – not just the two weeks after the lions escaped.

The ability of these birds to imitate sounds is rightly world-famous. But for their song culture to continue, we need healthy wild populations. Otherwise, they could face a future like critically endangered regent honeyeaters, which are now borrowing mating songs from other birds.


Why do lyrebirds learn human-made sounds and songs?

Many of us are familiar with the famous sequence in David Attenborough’s Life of Birds where a lyrebird accurately imitates camera clicks, a chainsaw motor and construction sounds.

Millions of people have watched this clip of a lyrebird imitating cameras and machinery.

But most watchers wouldn’t have guessed the bird’s secret – it was bred in captivity. That’s why it was so good at imitating our sounds.

Similarly, Echo of Taronga Zoo was also captive-bred. Mimicking a human-origin sound such as the alarm is a behaviour not commonly seen in the wild, other than in heavily visited areas such as in Victoria’s Dandenong Ranges where wild lyrebirds may hear, say, human voices every day.

Superb lyrebirds can mimic human speech, as in this clip from Victoria’s Sherbrooke Forest. Alex Maisey, Author provided523 KB (download)

That’s because lyrebirds seem to learn which songs to sing by listening to their peers, rather than simply soaking up sounds around them like a sponge.

In Victoria’s Sherbrooke Forest, lyrebirds mimic the familiar melodic whip-crack of the whipbird above all other mimicked sounds. But in Kinglake forest just 60 kilometres north, the whipbird’s call was only the 12th most popular for local lyrebirds, while the calls of the grey shrike-thrush and laughing kookaburra took top billing.

This is culture – the songs and sounds are passed from one bird to the next, between generations, and undergo change over time.


But how do they do it?

It’s not magic – it’s a complicated organ. Our voicebox – the larynx – is in our throats. But birds have theirs – the syrinx – further down, at the bottom of their windpipes. As they breathe out, they pass air through the syrinx to make their calls and songs.

Remarkably, many songbirds can control airflow from each lung, meaning they can produce sound in mono or stereo and have greater control over the types of sound they can make. They can use one side of the syrinx, both together, or switch back and forth.


Lyrebirds take it a step further again. They have fewer pairs of muscles around their syrinx, but the ones they do have are extremely well adapted to the job of making sound. Some lyrebird researchers believe this may be the reason they can produce such an extraordinary range of sounds, but this has yet to be conclusively shown.

that siren-imitating  lyrebird at taronga zoo? he lost his song culture – and absorbed some of ours

Lyrebirds can independently moderate the air flow through each side of their syrinx. The trachea and syringeal muscles are in yellow. Alex Maisey, Author provided

Even so, they’re not born superstars. Young lyrebirds struggle to reproduce mimicked sounds as perfectly as adult lyrebirds can. This suggests a lyrebird’s voice improves over years of practice.

Added to that is the dancing. Male courtship displays involve dance moves accompanying their song. That’s a cognitively challenging task, which is why not all of us are capable of being K-Pop stars.

To combine song and dance needs a large and well-developed brain. And that, after all, may be the point – the male’s ability to coordinate and song with dance is thought to be the key selection criteria for females choosing their mates.

So for Echo to perfect his fire alarm song, he had to practice and practice and practice to get it to the point where we can recognise it. Like humans practising a language or a musical instrument, lyrebirds must work at their songs.

Male lyrebirds have to coordinate song and dance to maximise how impressive they seem.

Why does bird culture matter?

Imagine if Echo was inspired by the lions and escaped. How would he fare in the wild? It’s unlikely he’d ever manage to impress a mate with his “evacuate now” mimicry and siren song. It’s as if a human was raised by wolves – it would be all but impossible to reintegrate.

The reason why we watch videos of Echo and find them amusing is because we are instinctively drawn to animal behaviour we can make sense of through our own. Animals acting like humans is amusing and appealing for us. But, alas, there’s a serious point here.

Take the critically endangered regent honeyeater, which once flew through box-ironbark forests in dense, raucous flocks. Now there are only 300 or so left in the wild.

With a population this low, the species loses not only genetic diversity but culture as well. Regent honeyeaters are losing their courtship songs, because the young birds simply don’t have enough peers to listen to and learn from. Without peers, some males only sing the songs of other species.

While lyrebirds are good survivors during natural disasters, there’s no room for complacency. The Black Summer fires put the superb lyrebird at real risk from habitat loss as well as introduced predators. If we’re not careful, the lyrebird too, could lose its culture and its songs.

‘This case has made legal history’: young Australians just won a human rights case against an enormous coal mine

Profound grief for a pet is normal – how to help yourself or a friend weather the loss of a beloved family member

Giant Floating Wind Turbine Research to Begin in Japan; New Models 3x Larger Than Existing Ones

It’s natural to want to feed wildlife after disasters. But it may not help

Stripping carbon from the atmosphere might be needed to avoid dangerous warming – but it remains a deeply uncertain prospect

Climate-fuelled disasters: warning people is good, but stopping the disaster is best. Here are 4 possible ways to do it

Hurricanes knock out traffic lights. Could a Tampa solar sidewalk change that?

Adapting to a hotter planet has never been more important, and progress edged forward at COP27

State of the climate: what Australians need to know about major new report

They might not have a spine, but invertebrates are the backbone of our ecosystems. Let’s help them out

US Watchdog Claims Offshore Oil, Gas Facilities Targeted by Cyberattackers; OTs Have Security Flaws

The Biggest Battery Storage in Europe Goes With a Tesla Megapack Goes Live

Shell to ‘re-examine’ £25bn green investment pledge after windfall hike

Scientists need help to save nature. With a smartphone and these 8 tips, we can get our kids on the case

COP27 flinched on phasing out ‘all fossil fuels’. What’s next for the fight to keep them in the ground?

COP27’s ‘loss and damage’ fund for developing countries could be a breakthrough – or another empty climate promise

TECH NEWS RELATED

Loss, decay and bleaching: why sponges may be the ‘canary in the coal mine’ for impacts of marine heatwaves

Marine sponges were thought to be more resilient to ocean warming than other organisms. But earlier this year, New Zealand recorded the largest-ever sponge bleaching event off its southern coastline. While only one species, the cup sponge Cymbastella lamellata, was affected, a prolonged marine heatwave turned millions of the normally ...

View more: Loss, decay and bleaching: why sponges may be the ‘canary in the coal mine’ for impacts of marine heatwaves

Clashing laws need to be fixed if we want to live in bushfire-prone areas

It’s almost bushfire season. Yes, even though floods are still racing through parts of eastern Australia. Fire conditions are above average including in inland New South Wales and Queensland. When we switch back to a neutral or El Niño climate cycle, our fire risk will likely intensify, given the huge ...

View more: Clashing laws need to be fixed if we want to live in bushfire-prone areas

Half of Australia’s biggest companies have net-zero emissions plans, but climate action may come too late

About half of Australia’s biggest listed companies have plans to reach net-zero greenhouse gas emissions, our new analysis has found. We assessed the climate change commitments of 187 companies out of 200 listed on the Australian Stock Exchange – the ASX200. Together, these 187 companies produce 32% of Australia’s operational ...

View more: Half of Australia’s biggest companies have net-zero emissions plans, but climate action may come too late

Solar Panel Options in Florida To Help Save Energy Bills: Costs, Incentives, More

Solar energy is a renewable resource readily available to the sunshine state’s citizens, and here’s how you can tap its potential. In the previous two decades, the price of solar panels has decreased dramatically, making the conversion to solar more accessible. Solar system costs have been reduced by 69% since ...

View more: Solar Panel Options in Florida To Help Save Energy Bills: Costs, Incentives, More

Green factories are changing minds in more conservative US states

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain At least $25.7 billion in new US clean-energy factories are in the works, thanks in part to the generous subsidies in President Joe Biden’s landmark climate law. Most of these projects—and the jobs that come with them—are in traditionally conservative states. In Dalton, Georgia, green ...

View more: Green factories are changing minds in more conservative US states

Energy crisis driving climate-friendly power savings: IEA

The IEA said one in every eight cars sold globally is now electric. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has driven countries across the world to boost energy efficiency, creating “huge potential” to tackle high prices, security and climate change, the IEA said on Friday. Governments have scaled up fossil fuel ...

View more: Energy crisis driving climate-friendly power savings: IEA

54% of projects extracting clean energy minerals overlap with Indigenous lands, research reveals

Vast quantities of minerals are needed to accelerate the transition to a clean energy future. Minerals and metals are essential for wind turbines, solar panels, and batteries for electric vehicles. But Indigenous peoples have raised concerns about more mining on their lands and territories. A new study led by authors ...

View more: 54% of projects extracting clean energy minerals overlap with Indigenous lands, research reveals

Why does lightning zigzag? At last, we have an answer to the mystery

Everyone has seen lightning and marvelled at its power. But despite its frequency – about 8.6 million lightning strikes occur worldwide every day – why lightning proceeds in a series of steps from the thundercloud to the earth below has remained a mystery. There are a few textbooks on lightning, ...

View more: Why does lightning zigzag? At last, we have an answer to the mystery

A China-backed dam in Indonesia threatens a rare great ape – and that’s just the tip of the iceberg

‘Earth’s empty quarter’: many Pacific nations now have falling populations

Curious Kids: What would happen if all animals on Earth were herbivores?

Coastal property prices and climate risks are both soaring. We must pull our heads out of the sand

Many forests will become highly flammable for at least 30 extra days per year unless we cut emissions, research finds

Five UK energy storage projects share £32m funding

We all know the Great Barrier Reef is in danger – the UN has just confirmed it. Again

Rolls-Royce, easyJet Successful Test Run for its Hydrogen-Powered Jet Engine—Towards Carbon Neutrality

COP27 was disappointing, but 2022 remains an historic year for international climate policy

UK start-up behind algae-based packaging bids for Earthshot glory

Victoria faces a grave climate and energy crisis. The new government’s policies must be far bolder

Get True Power Independence With Zendure Portable Power Station SuperBase Pro 2000

OTHER TECH NEWS

Top Car News Car News