the dark matter hypothesis isn't perfect, but the alternatives are worse
The Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), at center, is the second-largest satellite galaxy orbiting our own. This image superimposes a photograph of the SMC with one half of a model of its dark matter (right of center). Lighter colors indicate greater density and show a strong concentration toward the galaxy’s center. Ninety-five percent of the dark matter is contained within a circle tracing the outer edge of the model shown. In six years of data, Fermi finds no indication of gamma rays from the SMC’s dark matter. (Image credit: Dark matter, R. Caputo et al. 2016; background, Axel Mellinger, Central Michigan University)

You may not be a fan of dark matter, the hypothetical particle that makes up the bulk of the mass in the universe. And it’s true that the dark matter hypothesis has its shortcomings — and, of course, we haven’t found any dark matter particles yet. But the truth is that the alternatives are much worse.

The universe is full of unexplained mysteries (which is what keeps astronomers and astrophysicists happily employed), and many of those mysteries surround gravity. As we watch stars orbit the centers of their galaxies, we find that they’re moving far too quickly given the amount of visible matter that can keep them in those orbits with its gravity. 

Galaxies buzzing around galaxy clusters also move much too quickly given the amount of visible mass in the clusters. Those same clusters bend background light far too much. Even the large structures arose in our universe far too quickly without an additional source of mass.

The best hypothesis scientists have to explain all of these disparate observations is that there is a new kind of particle, known as dark matter, that inhabits the cosmos. This particle would be almost entirely invisible (hence the name), rarely (if ever) interacting with normal matter. This idea isn’t as far-fetched as it seems; neutrinos are particles with exactly these properties. They don’t have enough mass to explain the dark matter, but they do show that such particles can exist.

But the dark matter hypothesis isn’t perfect. Computer simulations of the growth of galaxies suggest that dark-matter-dominated galaxies should have incredibly high densities in their centers. Observations of real galaxies do show higher densities in their cores, but not nearly enough as those simulations predicted. Also, simulations of dark matter evolving in the universe predict that every galaxy should have hundreds of smaller satellites, while observations consistently come up short.

The case for MOND

Given that the dark matter hypothesis isn’t perfect — and that we have no direct evidence for the existence of any candidate particles — it’s worth exploring other options.

One such option was introduced back in the 1970s alongside the original dark matter idea, when astronomer Vera Rubin first discovered the problem of stars moving too quickly inside galaxies. But instead of adding a new ingredient to the universe, the alternative changes the recipe by altering how gravity works at galactic scales. The original idea is called MOND, for “modified Newtonian dynamics,” but the name also applies to the general family of theories descended from that original concept.

With MOND, you pretty much get what’s on the label. At planetary or solar system scales, Newton’s gravity works just fine (except, of course, where you need the more detailed calculations of gravity provided by general relativity). But once you go big, the usual F = ma we’re familiar with doesn’t quite apply, and the relationship between force and acceleration follows a different rule.

Under MOND, there’s no need for an additional particle to explain the observations — just a slight tweaking of the gravitational force. And because the tweaking of gravity under MOND is explicitly designed to explain the motions of stars within galaxies, it naturally does that very well. The theory also doesn’t suffer from the overproduction of satellites and the extremely high galactic cores of dark matter.

The flawed champion

But MOND is far from perfect. The modifications made to gravity to explain stellar motions have trouble explaining the motions of galaxies within clusters and the lensing of background light. And MOND isn’t a fully relativistic theory (all modern theories of physics must be compatible with special relativity). An update to MOND that is equivalent, called TeVeS, can compete head-to-head with general relativity — and falls far short. Models based on modified gravity have significant trouble explaining the growth of structure in the universe, features of the cosmic microwave background and more — all places where dark matter works quite well.

There is no MOND-like theory that can account for every single observation when it comes to dark matter; all of them fail at least one test. While MOND may still be accurate when it comes to galaxy rotation curves, there are enough observations to tell us that we would still need dark matter to exist in the universe.

No, the dark matter hypothesis isn’t perfect. But then again, no scientific hypothesis is. When evaluating competing hypotheses, scientists can’t just go with their guts, or pick one that sounds cooler or seems simpler. We have to follow the evidence, wherever it leads. In almost 50 years, nobody has come up with a MOND-like theory that can explain the wealth of data we have about the universe. That doesn’t make MOND wrong, but it does make it a far weaker alternative to dark matter.

Learn more by listening to the “Ask a Spaceman” podcast, available on iTunes (opens in new tab) and (opens in new tab). Ask your own question on Twitter using #AskASpaceman or by following Paul @PaulMattSutter (opens in new tab) and (opens in new tab).

Follow us on Twitter @Spacedotcom or on Facebook.   


NASA's DART spacecraft crashes into asteroid in defense test

In this image made from a NASA livestream, the Double Asteroid Redirection Test spacecraft crashes into an asteroid on Monday, Sept. 26, 2022. Credit: ASI/NASA via AP A NASA spacecraft rammed an asteroid at blistering speed Monday in an unprecedented dress rehearsal for the day a killer rock menaces ...

View more: NASA's DART spacecraft crashes into asteroid in defense test

New findings on the effects of Covid-19 on the colon

Although SARS-CoV-2 infections mainly attack the lungs, in many cases they can also damage other organs, such as the colon: around 60% of patients experienced digestive tract impacts. Researchers at MedUni Vienna have analysed the manifestations of Covid-19 in the lungs and colon and pinpointed the differences at a molecular ...

View more: New findings on the effects of Covid-19 on the colon

The distance to the Moon and the length of the day 2.46 billion years ago

Photo: Frits Hilgen At a slow pace, the Moon is moving away from the Earth and the Earth is rotating more slowly around its axis. To say something about these changes in the distant past, geologists use information stored in rocks and fossils. But the further back in time ...

View more: The distance to the Moon and the length of the day 2.46 billion years ago

Germany’s oldest beer scientifically considered

Researchers at TUM have analytically and sensorially characterized Germany’s oldest beer to date. Study reveals molecular profile of 19th century beer sample After almost 140 years, researchers at the Technical University of Munich (TUM) opened a lager beer that had been kept at room temperature throughout to analyze it. ...

View more: Germany’s oldest beer scientifically considered

“Erasure” – New Discovery Could Be the Key to Practical Quantum Computing

A team led by Jeff Thompson of Princeton University pioneered an approach to more efficient error correction in quantum computers. Credit: Gabriele Meilikhov/Muza Productions A new error correction method. Researchers have uncovered a brand-new technique for correcting errors in quantum computer calculations, potentially eliminating a significant barrier to a ...

View more: “Erasure” – New Discovery Could Be the Key to Practical Quantum Computing

The fundamental problem with gravity and quantum physics

No matter what you may have heard, make no mistake: physics is not “over” in any sense of the word. As far as we’ve come in our attempts to make sense of the world and Universe around us — and we have come impressively far — it’s absolutely disingenuous ...

View more: The fundamental problem with gravity and quantum physics

Tesla Fremont Factory is in full throttle in Q3’s final stretch

The end of the third quarter is coming, and Tesla’s electric vehicle factories are at full throttle. This includes the Fremont Factory, which is filled with vehicles that are ready to be delivered to customers. Flyovers of the Fremont Factory in recent days indicated that vehicle production is in ...

View more: Tesla Fremont Factory is in full throttle in Q3’s final stretch

NASA spacecraft successfully slams into asteroid ten months after SpaceX launch

Ten months after launching into interplanetary space on a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket, NASA’s Double Asteroid Redirect Test (DART) spacecraft has successfully impacted an asteroid moon. Falcon 9 lifted off from Vandenberg Space Force Base (VSFB) Space Launch Complex 4 (SLC-4) carrying the 630-kilogram (~1400 lb) spacecraft on November ...

View more: NASA spacecraft successfully slams into asteroid ten months after SpaceX launch

Scientists in Antarctica Have Access to Starlink Now. It’s Available on 7 Continents

NASA Pushes Through With Its Artemis I Launch Next Week; Agency Says It's Not Risking Its $4.1-Billion Rocket to the Moon

DART goes silent after hitting an asteroid [Update]

New herbicide solution inspired by cholesterol medicine

Found the origin of fascioliasis, a priority disease according to the WHO, in Southeast Africa and the Middle East

Bullseye! NASA’s DART spacecraft slams into asteroid

Deep space: Massive light burst detected on Earth came from ’infant’ Universe

Undercount of Cook County opioid deaths

Screening for pregnancy anxiety in the first and third trimesters can help reduce early births

New study allows scientists to test therapeutics for rare disease affecting young children

Doctor and patient in consultation: who interrupts whom (and is that bad)?

Research shows that some trees become overheated in warmer rainforests


Top Car News Car News